I'm coming in this thread late- I sort of skimmed over some of the posts so if I repeat something sorry.
I know what ya'll are going through- I was taken about a year ago by a mom on this board. Never did receive a paypal refund or my dipes

Then recently again with a trade.
Jamie- You said you sent paypal to her "other" email address. This may sound stupid but did you check to see if that email address had a registered account? I've accidently sent money before to an email address that didn't exsist.
Also- I would definalty file a fraud complaint with ebay and contact your state's attorney's office. I think I read that you were trying to find her Address. Paypal should have it. I would call them on the phone and request that information.
888-221-1161. If you are successful at obtaining her address- Then I would send her a ceritified letter and let her know you will be contacting her local.police department and or states attorneys office.
Hope you get your money back or your diapers!
Follow Mothering