Lesley, I've thought alot about it too (and in no way am I offended) I guess what bothers me is that you can't know how severe it will be before termination. Yes, if I knew for sure that the baby would suffer/not live beyond infancy/never be aware of his surroundings I would terminate, but I couldn't do it if I didn't know that. I went to school with a girl who's younger brother had downs-fairly bad and this girl cherished her baby brother in a way I've NEVER felt about my own brother. She was an outstanding individual and still is. She is a physician now specializing in special needs children. I was in awe of her ability to be a responsible adult one minute and then the next just get on the floor and be a silly kid. Her little brother holds a full time job that he's had for 7 yrs at our local Loblaws, is it a wonderful job, no, he brings in carts, but he's good at it, he's proud of what he does, he lives in an apartment with 2 other guys with downs. I'll tell you, I've often seen him drop what he's doing with his carts--sometimes at a very inconvenient place because he saw an elderly person or a pregnant lady trying to put her own groceries into her car, he will run over and help. He's not the smartest fellow, but he's got a heart of gold and our entire town (at least until it grew big time a year ago) knows his name and talks to him. When he was born, they were told he would not live past 2 yrs. I guess I just think that the world would not be such a nice place without him, I know I can see him when I'm in a bad mood and be smiling for hours and do something nice for someone else just cause I saw Eric and he flashed me a big smile and wanted to come see the dogs. For me, I can't think of downs without thinking of him. I think another big thing for me with not being able to terminate is that I have lost so many, after all that, to loose one on purpose I just don't think I could do it.
I guess for me the other part is that just cause these tests come back normal is no guarentee of a healthy baby. There are other risks that can't be tested for. My old doctor stopped practicing when her baby was born without a brain stem, he lived 4 hours. She had had amnio, numerous U/S's, you name it, she was told her baby was perfect, so I guess there are just no guarentees.
One other thing, this is something that nobody who hasn't experienced losses would think about. Over on the loss board, we have women who've had miscarriages and some who've had still births. After my third miscarriage, I found myself jealous of the women who had still births or babies who died shortly after birth--reason, they got to meet their babies and I never did. They got to put a face to their grief, they got to hold them, touch them and take pictures of them. I would give anything to have held even one of them for just a minute (and no, I don't expect anyone that has'nt been htere done that to understand that train of thought!)
So, those are my reasons, for whatever they are worth. I can definitely see both sides of the coin though and totally feel for you. And I know that Steve would be thinking more like you--which is why for me I didn't want to open that can worms that would make me make decisions I couldn't make.