Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Help - sending 21 month old to room.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Help - sending 21 month old to room.  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
I KNOW that this is not a good thing to do but so help me it's working and I need you to tell me why I need to stop doing this.

It all started last Friday night when we had gone to bed and dd she kept kicking (she sleeps between me and dh). Laying flat on her back and kicking her feet. After we had both been kicked several times (she was not intentionally kicking us) I told her that I wanted her to stop kicking, that it was hurting us and that if she wanted to kick I would take her to her bed (toddler bed in room directly across from ours). Long story - short. I took her to her bed and layed her down and explained that she could come get in bed with us if she decided to stop kicking. She stayed in her bed for about 3 whole seconds and came back to bed with us. The kicking started again and we repeated the same as above. This time when she came back to the bed I asked her if she understood that she could not kick anymore, she said yes and we all fell asleep.

The next afternoon when we layed down to nurse on the bed for her nap she said, "Kicking. No" and we talked about the sequences the night before and she hasn't kicked since.

A few days later she started hitting me when she was not getting her way and I would take her to her room and tell her that we don't hit. That I don't hit you and you don't hit me. That I thougth she should go look at books in her room until she felt like not hitting. I would find her a book and tell her to come back out whe she felt like not hitting mommy.

Now, when she hits me I have started asking her if she wants to go to her room. ( Not in a threating way - or in anger) She says no and stops hitting.

I feel that is working but my gut tells me that it is not the way to handle these issues.

Please tell me why this is not GD cause it just doesn't feel right to me.

I feel very fortunate to be able to come here and learn from you all.
post #2 of 9
You know, I do the same thing... and I know some of my irl AP mama friends do it too. But I also know its not GD for some reason. I'd like to know why, too. Our problem is that when dd starts to get really upset (hitting, pinching, biting me, etc) the two of us taking a quiet time out together doesn't work. She gets more and more upset. If she goes to lay in her bed alone for a few minutes, she calms right down and feels better. So what could have been a two hours tantrum lasts only 10 mins.

Actually, we even do the same thing with bed sometimes. Its not a punishment and we don't say it in a threatening manner or anything. Just, "If you don't stop hitting mommy you are going to have to go into your room to sleep." She always stops.

I would like to learn something that *is* more GD. Really, I do want to learn, too.
post #3 of 9
If you're not using "go to your room" in a threatening, punitive way, then why isn't it GD? If I'm reading your post correctly, you're not doing "time outs".... rather, as her frustration escalates and she lashes out b/c she doesn't know how else to deal with it, you're teaching her an alternative way to handle her frustration - a moment to cool off and decompress. Why isn't that a good idea? Sometimes I need a minute to back away and recollect myself when a situation is making me irritated.... You're not locking her in her room or otherwise forcing her to stay there - it's her choice when she wants to come out. You're not making her time in her room unpleasant - you're helping her find something soothing to do (read books) while she decompresses - I see nothing wrong with that approach.
post #4 of 9
Well, I know for *me* that this approach works and doesn't feel mean or anything... but I feel like I have read multiple times that isolation isn't a positive discipline tool. It just makes me doubt what I am doing...
post #5 of 9
Hi Mabelsmama - I'm not sure what you're doing with your DD (you weren't as explicit as Sun-shine01), but what she described didn't sound like isolation to me.... the door was open and her dd was free to come out and join them whenever she wanted to do so. She also wasn't sent to her room by herself, her mom went with her, found something quiet and soothing for her to do, and invited her to come out when she felt better and more composed.

I don't think isolation is a good idea, either, but that's not how I read the OP...
post #6 of 9
I'm with alaska - sounds fine to me. You're not punishing, you're just teaching her that the logical consequence of hurting people is that the people are not going to want to be with you for a bit. I think you're modeling an appropriate way to deal with her overwhelming emotions - take some time, calm down and rejoin when ready
post #7 of 9
Thanks alaska and MilkfaceMama.

Sorry I semi-hijacked your thread, sun-shine01... I just had the same question, too. :
post #8 of 9
I think that I would probably separate the two different times -- night time and day time generally get different responses from me. We finally transitioned our DD to a crib at night because she kicked so hard that she broke my nose. She was too young to talk to about it, it wasn't on purpose, but I still couldn't cope with her in bed after that. A year later, she spends some time in bed with us at night, but when she gets restless and starts "rabbit kicking" she goes back to her crib. Anyway, if you child seems upset by this, then you might try moving the toddler bed into your room. But if she's OK with it, I don't see a problem. After all, everyone has the right to be safe in their own bed.

For daytime hitting/hurting, I tend to move away rather than move my child away, at least in toddlerhood. For example, if she hits or bites, then I say "that hurts" and move away from her. If she is in my arms, I will put her down and say "mommy can't hold you if you are hurting her". I think this is probably less isolating and scary than moving her into a different space and leaving her. With my older child, we have started using "please go to your room until you can compose yourself", largely to protect the little one because when he gets mad or frustrated people or things get hurt, though not on purpose. Again, for me its a matter of safety for everyone.
post #9 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thanks Mamas! I really appreciate your help on this. The suggestions were a big help.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Help - sending 21 month old to room.