Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Refusal to wear anything but favorite item . . .
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Refusal to wear anything but favorite item . . .  

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
This is one of the most frustrating things I've encountered so far with my ds. He's almost 3.5. I miss the days when I could pick out an item of clothing and put it on him and that was that. I just need to vent about this but any and all suggestions are welcome because it has us so stuck.

Here's the thing: his grandparents got him a set of batman pjs with a little cape this summer. Summer pjs, shortsleeves and legs. DS loved it, loved to wear it all the time, how cute, right? Well it was at the time, briefly, and I didn't care for a long while how much he wanted to wear it although it has by now gotten really nasty (it's that synthetic fabric that pills almost immediately) and I don't care if he wants to wear pjs during the day or whatever but now that the weather has gotten cooler, I can't let him go outside in shorts. I let him wear his rubber boots till they didn't fit and had holes in them but this is different. Plus if he has wet the bed the pj top sometimes gets a little wet and then it smells like pee. So, every morning there's an exhausting frustrating struggle with him crying and my husband and I trying every tactic: cajoling, trying to convince him how cool his other clothes are, firm, putting other clothes on his struggling body (he takes them right off again), to even saying OK then you can't go outside till you put long pants on (which backfired I think as it only resulted in my staying in a beautiful morning with him). He insists on being batmanesque so he won't wear the few pairs of brand-new, really nice pants we've gotten him so I've gone out and bought two more pairs of black pants. That worked for a few days and then this morning he refused to take his pj shorts off so I had to put the pants on over them. This whole thing has touched a button of frustration in me that I didn't even know I had. I know, he is doing it to exert some control over his life. I know also that the more energy and upset I put into it or show about it the longer it will last. It's just that I want him to be warmly and reasonably cleanly dressed--here he is with a cold refusing to wear a sweatshirt or jacket because it will cover up batman. I've even bought a batman pj top that's long sleeved but this morning he refused to wear it (after he'd worn it a few times so I can't return it now--it's not the right KIND of batman). He is so stubborn about this and he gets sort of hysterical crying if something isn't JUST right, like the cape is twisted or something. I am hoping someone will tell me that they're kid went through this and it didn't last more than a few months--I don't think I can take much more than that. URRRGGGHHH. Or just tell me you went through this!
post #2 of 11
My brother had a pair of green jeans and a blue t-shirt celebrating Key West seceding from the Union on April 23, 1982, which is, incidently, his birthdate, when he was about 2.5.
He wore nothing else for 2 years.
He sat naked under the clothes line waiting for it to dry enough to put on.
He wore it until his belly poked out and the jeans were practically up to his knees, the butt was threadbare, the t-shirt was little better than a spiderweb.
Then he decided he didn't want to wear it anymore.

My youngest wouldn't wear any color than red and blue cuz he was Spiderman for a long time.

Maybe he'll agree to wear the pj's over his warm clothes? Get him a Bat-cape he can wear over everything?

It is a phase, this too shall pass.
post #3 of 11
Thread Starter 
The story of your little brother at least made me laugh, though it's not what I wanted to hear.

It may come to that, putting the pjs over warm clothes. Today I began to wonder why it is bugging me as much as it is--I like to think of myself as the kind of mother who lets her child express themselves through their appearance however he/she likes but I guess I have to let go of wanting him to wear the new adorable outfits he's gotten recently from grandmas and aunts. I've decided I'm not spending any more money on clothes (unless truly necessary) and if he has to end up like your brother (v. funny image) then so be it. Anyway after the worst of the winter is over.


It was a rough morning so I appreciate your post.
post #4 of 11
DD had a little short set with tank top, which she called her "pink outfit". She wanted to wear it every day, all the time, even in winter. I don't remember how we did it, but I did manage to get her to take it off long enough to wash it every couple of days. I also let her wear it in winter, but she had to wear something over it to keep warm. She agreed to that, but I don't know how. I might have opened a window just to show her how cold she would be....
This went on from age 3 until she the winter that she was 4. At some point she just wanted to wear the top (the shorts gave her a wedgie, I wager), and then the top got lost and she forgot about it. She asked about it a few times, and I found other pink things that were acceptable substitute. I found it a couple of months ago when we moved. But she didn't want to wear it.
I keep it in my underwear drawer, which is also where I have keepsakes. It used to annoy me that she wanted to wear it all the time, and it was starting to look ratty and was too small. Sometime I miss seeing her in her pink outfit, when she was small enough to wear it, and would proudly pick it out and get dressed all by herself.

Just let it be. This too will pass is really the only thing to be said. I remember being about 3 or 4 and loving a pair of red bellbottom Health-Tex pants with white elephants all over them.
post #5 of 11
Sorry!
But at least you know you're not alone!
He probably won't want to wear his Bat-jama's for 2 more years, my brother is an extreme case. It may comfort you to know he's a total neat freak now, showers all the time and is very fastidious about his clothes. Would never wear the same thing twice without washing it first!
He still likes blue t-shirts, though!
post #6 of 11
Tell him it's time to be Bruce Wayne! Tell him he has to go undercover, so that his arch enemy (who was it? My boy liked Spidey) can't find him!
His true identity must remain a secret.......................
post #7 of 11
Quote:
Tell him it's time to be Bruce Wayne! Tell him he has to go undercover, so that his arch enemy (who was it? My boy liked Spidey) can't find him!
Just had to say that I LOVE that!

Kids just don't get the "dress appropriately thing at 3. I know that I wore my satin ballerina tutu (with just little straps on the shoulders) for the entire month of February in New England when I was 3.

Maybe if the struggle went away the desire would too? I can understand you wanting him to look nice and be warm but is it really that dangerously cold where you are that he can't wear shorts? If he has shoes/socks on and will wear a coat over his PJ's what would the harm be? Even if he won't wear a coat you could bring it with you and if he got cold later he could put it on.

I have found with my 3 year old that as soon as something becomes a non-issue the desire to do it dissipates.

He went a good part of Sept refusing to wear PJ's. He would only wear a t-shirt to bed and ideally the t-shirt he had worn all day. At first it bothered me than I asked myself what the worse that could happen? He ends up smelly in his dirty old shirt? He gets cold during the night? I could not think of one really bad thing so I let him (even after he had a bath and watching him put on a dirty t-shirt on his clean body drove me crazy) I still offered PJ's each night but when he said no there were no struggles. One day he said yes and he's been in PJ's ever since.
post #8 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by HollyBearsMom
He went a good part of Sept refusing to wear PJ's. He would only wear a t-shirt to bed and ideally the t-shirt he had worn all day. At first it bothered me than I asked myself what the worse that could happen? He ends up smelly in his dirty old shirt? He gets cold during the night? I could not think of one really bad thing so I let him (even after he had a bath and watching him put on a dirty t-shirt on his clean body drove me crazy) I still offered PJ's each night but when he said no there were no struggles. One day he said yes and he's been in PJ's ever since.
My dd will not wear pjs either. I've never even tried to fight it. She's always been a little oven, so I took her lead on this one. She often sleeps comfortably in just her undies in winter. We're in New England, too. I put extra blankets on her, and she tends to kick most of them off. Only really a problem when she sleeps with us, and kicks the blakets off everyone!
post #9 of 11
My guys a little steam engine too. It wasn't so much the no PJ's as it was the dirty shirt If he would have a least put on a clean one..... But like I said as soon as the struggle stopped so did the resistance. I take that stance with everything now except for dangerous situations.
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by HollyBearsMom
I have found with my 3 year old that as soon as something becomes a non-issue the desire to do it dissipates.
This is so true for my very stubborn 3 year old, too! Can you post it like in every other thread in this forum?
post #11 of 11
Thread Starter 
The desire is definitely fed by the struggle; I think 3 year olds can smell it when you REALLY want them to do something which instantly flips their resistance switch. But I also think this is just something that's part of their development too; establish separate identity and all that and also never underestimate how important dressing up to be something else is to a 3-year-old or any kid around that age; my ds is constantly wrapping himself in toilet paper (mummy), wearing the clothes hamper (knight in armor) and so on. And dressing in a certain outfit must be some sort of talisman-type thing. Parthenia, that's sweet that you kept her little tank top; I tried to think of the batman pjs that way but I can hardly bear to touch them, the material is so nasty.

And sevenkids those ARE good suggestions and I'm going to try the Bruce Wayne thing because he's also fascinated with Peter Parker and Bruce Wayne being ordinary and then super heroes, the transformation I guess.

Wouldn't you know that last night we got a package in the mail from my sister that has a halloween shirt in it? I'm just not going to tell her ds won't wear it (she doesn't live nearby). So, enjoy dressing your baby to 2 1/2 year old in whatever you choose while you can.

No, it hasn't been truly cold, but getting there. We were in Vermont last weekend and I let him wear shorts in a light drizzle, around 47 degrees. I thought maybe his teachers at his new school would think I am a negligent mother because he wears the same thing day after day but then I thought, they must see this pretty often.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Refusal to wear anything but favorite item . . .