Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Nicole Kidman's new film- are you going to go see this??
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nicole Kidman's new film- are you going to go see this??  

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
Your opinion please on her new movie subject matter???
You going to go see this one??

TIA

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNew...=Entertainment

New Kidman film can't shake controversy
CTV.ca News Staff

The new Nicole Kidman movie, "Birth" has been stirring controversy even before its release. The story of a middle-aged woman falling for a 10-year-old boy goes too far, say some. But the film's director says they're missing the point.

The movie's complex plot centres on a boy who claims to be Kidman's reincarnated husband, who died on the same night that the boy was born. Though Kidman's character dismisses the boy at first, she soon begins to believe the boy really is who he claims to be.

In one scene, the child walks in on Anna while she is taking a bath. He disrobes in front of her and climbs into the bath with her. In another, Kidman and bright kiss.

Filmgoers at the Venice Film Festival booed the film, calling it scandalous and obscene.

For 11-year old actor Cameron Bright, who won the role for his boyish face and manly gaze, he admits that he doesn't see what the fuss is all about.

"There's not much to tell about it. Nothing really happens in it at all," he says.

The young actor from Nanaimo B.C. and his co-star were never actually nude together. After all, his mother approved his role.

"I knew that there wasn't anything to do with anything bad in those scenes," Bright says.

Much has been made of the mature nature of the movie. But director Jonathan Glazer insists this is a story of love, not sex.

"The idea was to try and construct a story where you believe these two should be together, and were in love with one another," Glazer says.

Kidman has said much the same, telling a press conference at the Venice Film Festival that she " responded to this woman who was in mourning.".

"It wasn't about, 'Oh I want to make a film where I get to kiss a 10-year-old boy.' To me it was I wanted to make a film where you're trying to understand love," she said.

Some of the first Canadians to see the movie on Friday say the controversy has been overplayed.

"I wasn't too keen on that, but it didn't go too far, you know," one filmgoer told CTV. "You anticipated it might have, but it didn't. It was done tastefully."

"They went out boldly on a limb at time, but not distasteful," says another.

So far, the film critics' reviews have been poor. The Canadian Press gave it only two stars, calling it "pretentious" and "ultimately unsatisfying," saved only by the performances of Kidman and Bright.

Still, film critic Jim Gordon says the debate will certainly prompt many curious filmgoers to head to the multiplex regardless.

"It's going to get lots more box office this weekend because of the controversy," Gordon says.
post #2 of 21
I doubt it would get much attention at all if it were a midlle age man and young girl as his reincarnated wife.
post #3 of 21
most likely not at the theatre but it's on my netflix queue
post #4 of 21
I saw 'Birth' and it was very interesting. I don't see the contraversy. It's not like they were actually naked.
post #5 of 21
No.

Not that I get to the movies much, but no, I find it distasteful. That sounds haughty, huh? :LOL
post #6 of 21
The trailer really looks good...aside from the fact that is the primary purpose of a trailer. Beautiful, deep cinematography (the key to my infrequently movie-going heart) and powerful actors. I would rather judge the hullabaloo on my own terms as opposed to what a critic has determined. Although, one critic has called it "Mary Kay Letourneau meets Ghost" :LOL

Trailer is here: http://www.birthmovie.com
post #7 of 21
go OUT to a movie....that's a good one.

:
post #8 of 21
I think the trailer looks terrific. If I could go to movies still, I would definitely go see it, but alas, my little toddler would probably find it incredibly boring. No trucks or fishing involved.

From what I saw in the trailer, this is not a predatory movie. It does seem to be about loss, and grief and longing for love. I don't believe art, or anything else should be censored. I too will put this one my netflix list.
post #9 of 21
Nah, won't see it. Can't really see movies as people already mentioned. I try to avoid stuff with triggers for me... a movie with an anorectic just isn't wise for me to see.
post #10 of 21
Was there any big controversy about the remake of "Lolita?" Not that I can recall and there were some pretty graphic scenes in that one (but I like it! )

I probably will rent it when it comes out on video, just to see what all the fuss is about. But it's not really something I'd be interested in seeing otherwise.

I thought it was gonna be a movie about um, BIRTH, until I read the OP! LOL
post #11 of 21
Yeah I was all excited thinking it was going to be a movie about Birth too! LOL.

No I won't see it. I think the idea is distasteful but wouldn't watch it anyways, can't stand Nicole Kidman!

Kitty
post #12 of 21
Moving this to Books, Music & Other Media...
post #13 of 21
I think it looks interesting as all get out. Reincarnation fascinates the heck out of me, and I fully buy that it is possible.

I will see it.
post #14 of 21
have to wait for video - we dont get to the movies
post #15 of 21
I'll definitely see it if I can manage to get out to the movies!
post #16 of 21
Saw it. Found the controversial"scenes quite uncomfortable--but that was the filmmaker's intent, I think. An adult woman having romantic feelings for a young child *should* make you feel uncomfortable. The story did not seem prurient or exploitative to me--and I am quite sensitive about such things, due to my own personal history.
post #17 of 21
I haven't seen it yet, but here's something interesting about that movie. The birth of the boy was an actual natural waterbirth that took place about 3 months ago at the birth center where DS was born! I'm going to watch it for nothing more than that fact.
post #18 of 21
I have never heard of this, never seen previews. In Utah they hide a lot of stuff from us, potentially offensive movies included.

I wouldn't mind seeing it, sounds interesting.
post #19 of 21
When is it coming out? Or is it already? I can't find it in theaters anywhere around here, which is really weird considering where I live.
post #20 of 21
There was controversy about the remake of Lolita with Jeremy Irons, but the actress who played Lolita was an adult playing a child. This is a child playing an adult.

The book, Lolita, was MUCH more disturbing than the movie.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Nicole Kidman's new film- are you going to go see this??