Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › lying, sneaky ds is too smart for me!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

lying, sneaky ds is too smart for me! - Page 2  

post #21 of 35
IMHO I do not think you can underestimate how much a child wants to protect their parent/s from being disappointed in something they they've done. Especially if the parent/child relationship is a close one ... life can be tough even at 9 and to keep that place with his parent as a "soft place to fall" , as something constant and pure, without any difficulties may be something he really needs, not necessarily realistic, but perhpas he's just having a hard time in another area of life/school/friendships????

Not much help - but I know how much I got upset when upset my mum. It was so hard for me!!!
post #22 of 35
In my opinion, Cuppa-Love hit the nail on the head when she said this:

Quote:
I do not think you can underestimate how much a child wants to protect their parent/s from being disappointed in something they they've done. Especially if the parent/child relationship is a close one
My daughter (she's eleven) recently got a detention (her first) and she was *much* more worried about disappointing me than she was about being in trouble at school. Honestly, your son has probably been stressing about this since it happened...
post #23 of 35
Thread Starter 
i completely agree with what all of you said, if that is possible. remember too that i did not type out my entire convo verbatim, just maybe 2 sentences. of course i'm not so narcissistic that i made the whole thing about my feelings, but i do need him to know that i am sad when we fail to communicate. how else will he know i care? i also focus on MY feelings when i say "i love you" to my dc, but i know that no one would suggest i stop doing that, kwim? the whole thing was not about me and my feelings, that was just a small part of it. i tried to ask him questions to draw him out, such as "what feelings did you have that led you to hide the note?" he is very intelligent and articulate, i know he is capable of discussing this, he is just choosing not to. i felt like i should let it go b/c i cannot control his mouth and tongue; i cannot FORCE him to speak, kwim? so if he CHOOSES not to talk, i CHOOSE not to perform a monologue. lol i don't know what to do, but i really want to wrap this up b4 df comes fri pm. thanks for the input, i am learning alot!
post #24 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amywillo
I think you are making sense, but it sounds like you are arguing against the use of "I statements" in general.
Not at all. From my post above (sorry, feeling lazy): "Tell him that you found it and let him know that you're concerned that he might have felt that he needed to hide it from you." I might say something like, "I'm concerned that you felt you needed to hide it from me. Can you tell me why you felt that way?"

Quote:
"I feel worried that you didn't want to tell me about this because it is important to me that you feel that you can trust me" or something like that.
If I were a child, I think that statement would resonate more with me. I'm just not a fan of giving a child responsibility for my feelings (which is how it comes off when we say, "It made me feel sad when you..." That's a "you made me" statement sort of flipped around to sound like an "I" statement.

I think there are definite occasions for those statements (maybe worded a little differently) - when a child lashes out at you directly in some way (though I think there should still be a strong focus on the reason that the child is lashing out).
post #25 of 35
Dragonfly, what would you say?

I think the OP did fine. She talked to her son when she wasn't angy and could speak calmly. She didn't blame or call names.
post #26 of 35
I'm a single mother, too. Have been ever since my daughter was born.

I really dislike the expression "raising children". It implies that they're somehow beneath us, and we bring them up to our level. I don't think people consciously notice this, but the subtle implications of our language can have an effect on our behavior.

As an unschooler, my daughter already spends a lot of time in the "real world". She had a paying job working as an actress for 6 months earlier this year (she's 11). She's done volunteer work since she was 6, with me, and since 8 by herself. She was the youngest solo volunteer at the Democratic HQ before the recent election, making call after call. I see my job as helping her navigate the rules and regulations in the real world, rather than creating more for her. When she choses an activity, she choses to accept the rules around it, but our home isn't a place she can chose to leave - it's her home, too.

I'm not sure it's possible to understand how living this way works without doing it, or at least seeing it, but it does work. Rain sees herself as an integral part of our family, as a partner, and behaves that way. The idea of set mealtimes, for example, would just not fit. She's been making dinner for both of us some of the time since she was 8 or 9 anyway, and if either of us isn't hungry when the meal is served we're capable of heating up leftovers later, or making something else. She's been able to prepare simple meals for herself since she was 3 or 4, really - cereal, sandwiches. Why create struggles about mealtimes?

Dar
post #27 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda KS
Dragonfly, what would you say?
I answered that a few times.

I think it's apparent that the OP has a very good rapport with her son. In writing what I did, I wasn't criticizing her parenting. She asked for advice and other thoughts. That's what I was offering.
post #28 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dar
I I think the easiest way to understand it is to think of how you would live with a roommate, or spouse. Somehow you manage to resolve issues without punishing them, right? The same works with children, especially children who aren't worried about being punished, and who see their parents as allies in problem-solving.

Dar

NOPE I completely disagree on sooooooo many levels.


Comparisons to spousal or roomate relationships are IMHO very sad and wrong.


First of all, a spouse or roomate can do something to break the ties with us. There is a breaking point in these relationships. With kids there is no breaking point. They are always ours. You simply can't compare these relationships.

Second, we do not have an obligation to guide our spouses or roomates through life. That obligation comes only with our kids.


Third, people "punish" their spouses all the time, by yelling at them, refusing to talk with them, or worse.


That said I do use GD. But to me that includes some logical consequences (which I use to protect the person or property of others).
post #29 of 35
I understood Dar's analogy to be pointing to basic human rights that we are conditioned by society to see more easily in our adult relationships, and conditioned to undermine in our relationships with children. While we are responsible for our children's safety and wellbeing in a way that we are not with other adults, it is sometimes helpful to think carefully about how we might interact with a peer before attempting a difficult interaction with our children. To check that we are respecting their dignity as we would with any other person.
post #30 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragonfly
I answered that a few times.
yeah, I think we were posting at the same time
post #31 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by maya43
NOPE I completely disagree on sooooooo many levels.
.
Yes, well... I'm not really surprised. It's not an exact analogy, of course. The biggest difference is our obligation to our children, to be there for them and help them. However, in day-to-day living the dynamics of the relationships are pretty much the same. If I care about someone enough to marry them, I am going to be committed to staying with them, and to helping them, just as I am with my child. I don't "guide" anyone, but I offer advice or feedback when it seems appropriate, to my child or my friends or anyone I love. Maybe living with my brother would be a better example, because he's always mine.

I don't think "punishing" a spouse by yelling or refusing to talk to him is unhealthy and unkind behavior. I certainly wouldn't advocate it or put up with it. YMMV, I guess.

The important part of the anaolgy, though, is the structure of day-to-day interaction. People work together to accomplish things. No one is punished. It's an awfully nice way to live. If you enjoy punishing your children and telling them what to do, that's your choice. I'm just pointing out another option.

Dar
post #32 of 35
Thread Starter 
maya, i think we are on the same page. but mamaduck, when you put it the way you did, i can see the validity of it, but on a basic level i still feel about the way maya put it.

so here's the latest: several times today i tried gently to feel ds out and see if he was receptive to talking. i did tell him i was sad that we were not communicating, and that i really would be glad if he could explain his feelings and motivation to me, i hoped it would be soon, but i was willing to wait on him. this seemed to work. we were on our way home from a gathering tonight, around 9:30, and he asked me if i noticed how much time he had been away from the group, in the bathroom, i honestly hadn't, so he told me he checked his watch and it was 15 mins. he said he spent the time staring at the ceiling thinking about his reason for not telling me about the dtn. what he came up with was that he just really wanted to go to chess club, and knew if i saw the notice, i would make him serve it, and he would miss chess club. then he told me he was unhappy that he lied to me and said sorry. he really did lie, i always say "how was chess club?" when he gets in the car. he always tells me a story about it. so whichever day it was, i'm not even sure anymore, he made up a story about what happened in CC. that is a lie and in my home it is unacceptable to lie. it carries a consequence. the consequence for this lie is that i have lost trust in his word. we've been through a big thing the last few months about him wanting more personal responsibility, like bathing completely alone, brushing teeth alone, etc. so i told him that since he lied to me once, i might not believe him now when he says he used soap in the shower, etc. i might find it neccessary to check up him a little more, for a while at least. i'm sure that some of you would say this is punishment and so is inappropriate, but it just makes sense to me. and doing what made sense to me got me to ebf, co sleep and babywear, so i have faith in my intuition.

he asked if i was gonna make him quit CC. i really did think of it, but it didin't feel right, and i told him just this. then he says, "well, if you want to make me quit, go ahead. i lose all my games anyway, so i don't want to go. and mr. M made us sign a form so i we miss more than a few meetings, we get kicked out of CC. so if you want to take it away from me, go ahead!". not snotty, just matter of fact. i really wasn't gonna make him miss meetings, but if i had planned it, this woulda killed any possible lesson! he really is too smart for me.

so he and i began talking about this yesterday, and wrapped it up tonight. i told him that although i was angry at first, knowing he felt bad for lying made it cool. then we each said 3 things we hoped the other would work on. (i guess i've been yelling a bit lately, and a few times i made *gasp* an idle threat! lol i told him i was really tired of him throwing his baby bros toys around the LR. then he reached into his backpack and pulled out a pretty "diamond" heart necklace he bought at the school store! paid for with his own $!

i can't wait to rub it in his df's face (out of ds's earshot, of course)! he really thought he should be spanked. not only did i not hit my baby, i got a diamond pendant from him!

thanks all. i'll prolly be sticking around this forum for a bit.
post #33 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dar

I don't think "punishing" a spouse by yelling or refusing to talk to him is unhealthy and unkind behavior.
Dar
Is this really what you meant, or was it a typo????

In any event,
I dont' punish my kids in the traditional sense. I have in the past used some logical consequences (if you hit your sister with the ball, I will take it away)
but I don't use them much now that they are older.

However, I do set many rules that my kids are "expected" to follow. Although there is little consequence to not following those rules, other than an expression of my disaproval and a restatment of the rules. Even this I really dont' have to do much right now.

My point is that I don't use the spouse or friend relationship to guide my relationship with my kids. Its too unique.
post #34 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by blessedwithboys
mamaduck:

i just really mulled over your words. my instinct tells me this is not what happened with ds, but i'm gonna spend some time thinking of ways to ask him if that is what he felt. but i don't want to suggest it b/c he may use it to just back out of the whole situation. lol so i'll really think of just how to put it. thanks.

CO, i'd like to know what you had wanted to say. i'm really trying to learn and improve myself. pm me if you like. i won't be too offended by anything anyone says, after all, i came here admitting i was having a problem and i needed advice, right? so share!
I was going to argue (I thought I little boringly, with more reference to the child's human dignity vs. the parents' elemental responsibility) about why you shouldn't give up on this situation. I see that one thing we have in common is that we don't like to parents when we feel frustrated or upset. I know that my upbringing didn't prepare me to be a calm, non-reactive parent! So I'm glad that i didn't leave my post up until I read what you wrote. I get now that you were giving up because you didn't think you could react to your son from a calm place. I have trouble with this even now when my son is an unbelievably cute toddler.


If your son is getting stuck on the issue of whether he lied (and maybe by some technical definition he believes he didn't) then let THAT part go. But going forward, you need an explicit understanding of what should happen in the future. By this I mean, a statement from you about what you want from him around misbehavior (or even punishment without misbehavior!) at school.

If it were me, I would want total transparency at this age, you know, that he would tell you any time he gets in trouble, but you can work out between you what you think is appropriate. It would also be good for him to let you know what is actually helpful for you to do. For example, if your son would be uncomfortable with you intervening with the teacher about detention, that's something you need to hear from him.

This is clearly not something you should just let go of, look at the title you picked for this thread! It's not good for your relationship with your son for that (I get that it's sarcastic!) thought to surface.

It would also be good to get a committment from your xh that you will be able to share any information about your children without having to fear that he will spank. You want to be totally honest with him and you can't be because of the spanking! Obviously if you are ex-spouses that is going to be tricky though, so I don't presume to know how you should proceed.
post #35 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by maya43
Is this really what you meant, or was it a typo????
Typo. It should have been either "don't think... healthy and kind" or "think... unhealthy and unkind". I just never figured out which one...

Quote:
My point is that I don't use the spouse or friend relationship to guide my relationship with my kids. Its too unique.
I wasn't really suggesting using these relationships to guide relationships with kids, but rather using the spouse/roomie relationship as an example of how a living situation looks when there are no punishments and problems are resolved mutually.

Dar
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › lying, sneaky ds is too smart for me!