Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Question about "no offer, don't refuse"
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Question about "no offer, don't refuse" - Page 2  

post #21 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by sarajane
How can one tell the difference between them really needing it and forgetting it and them just not wanting it?
If they don't want to, they just won't. My dd just turned 1, and there are times when she seems a bit fussy, so I assume she needs to nurse, but then when offered she turns away (and sometimes gets a little irritated with me :LOL). You really can't force a baby/toddler/child to nurse.
post #22 of 27
Interesting. Thanks for the info. For some reason I was thinking that maybe they would take it whenever offered.
post #23 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by sarajane
Thanks for the response. Another question for ya...

How can one tell the difference between them really needing it and forgetting it and them just not wanting it?
Like the previous poster said - You can not force a child to nurse. You just can't. If they don't want to nurse, they won't. I can't imagine how and the logistics of forcing a child to suckle. Impossible. SO, if you offer and the CHILD refuses....they don't WANT to nurse ( at least for that momment..lol)

Sometimes a very active toddler will forget to nurse and when you offer they are SO relieved that you reminded them and come running to nurse! You see just relief in their eyes!

The word "need" is so, well, I can't think of what I want to say but I also want to say that every nursing child "needs" to nurse. I hate when I hear people say, " Your child is X years old and no longer NEEDS to nurse" grrrrrrrrrrrrrr If said child is nursing, the need is there. If the need wasn't there, they would refuse to nurse. But the child refusing to nurse and mom not offering are two different things entirely.

I see it this way, I wouldn't stop offering to nurse my 1 month old, even if they didn't cry or root or whatever to nurse, so I wouldn't NOT offer to nurse my toddler or preschooler or whatever unless I wanted them to wean.
post #24 of 27
I've never thought of "don't offer, don't refuse" as a weaning technique, but my oldest is the kind of kid who would still nurse all day long every day if I let her. I don't have to offer to nurse, she will ask me if she wants to, or if she's bored, or if she's hungry, or tired, or upset, or... you get the point.
My baby, though, is the total opposite! I do find myself offering to nurse her when my breasts start feeling real full. If I wait until she starts getting fussy (which, with my oldest, has always been my sign that she needs to nurse) it's been too long! She's perfectly ok on the floor playing with her sister all day long, and would probably be just fine if I let her go six or eight hours without nursing. So now I'm wondering, if she doesn't ask for it, does that mean she doesn't need it? If I'm following my baby's lead, which is my approach to everything, how is "don't offer, don't refuse" a weaning technique? It seems to me that's the ultimate in child-led weaning. If baby needs to nurse, won't she ask for it herself, in one way or another? Or not? Or is the "don't offer, don't refuse" method a weaning strategy only for moms who might not be as clued in to their children's signs, who aren't as attached, who follow baby-training methods and strict schedules, and who don't follow their children's lead???
post #25 of 27
[QUOTE=stafl] If I'm following my baby's lead, which is my approach to everything, how is "don't offer, don't refuse" a weaning technique? It seems to me that's the ultimate in child-led weaning. If baby needs to nurse, won't she ask for it herself, in one way or another? [QUOTE]

Exactly!

I think the terminology is misleading, and whether it is a weaning technique does depend on the nursing pair.
post #26 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by sarajane
Thanks for the response. Another question for ya...

How can one tell the difference between them really needing it and forgetting it and them just not wanting it?
As you will soon discover- you cannot make a child nurse. You just can't. Kinda like the whole *you can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink*. A child will nurse when he wants to nurse, he might need to be reminded or offered it. But if you offer and he doesn't want to nurse he will definately let you know (shutting his mouth, turning his head away, or- unfortunately- biting a nipple).
post #27 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by StephandOwen
(shutting his mouth, turning his head away, or- unfortunately- biting a nipple).
LOL...Bran came up with a system... He takes his finger and presses the nipple back as far as it will go...sort of like pressing the button to turn it off or something... :LOL
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Child-Led Weaning
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Question about "no offer, don't refuse"