Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Parenting the Gifted Child › Support for Parents of Gifted Children, #4
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Support for Parents of Gifted Children, #4 - Page 5  

post #81 of 284
If anyone has a child in a "Gifted/Highly Capable/Whatever you want to call it" school I'd really appreciate some input on this thread:
http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=290045

I am having such a hard time deciding. The test results came back and DD has a place in the Full-Time Highly Capable Program in the 2nd grade. We're not sure if we want to take it, put her in just one day a week in the supplimental program (we homeschool), see if we can put her in the 1st grade instead (she turned 6 in January)--- which they are resistant to based on her test scores: she qualified for 2nd grade and "they" think she should at least start there.

Have I mentioned that I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT TO DO?!?!?

Thanks
post #82 of 284
Just my opinion, but I would do the one day a week thing if possible. I guess it depends on your reasons for homeschooling. Even if I had access to the best gifted school in the whole world, I wouldn't send my kids there full time, because of our other reasons for homeschooling. But if your reasons for homeschooling are mainly academic, the gifted school might be a good choice, assuming it fits your child well.

I don't see the big deal about her being in second grade at 6... lots of kids started it at 6 (and turned 7 during the fall/winter) when I went to school. I'm sure she could handle it academically. Does she have any social issues that make you think grade 2 would be a bad fit?
post #83 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by lckrause
I don't see the big deal about her being in second grade at 6... lots of kids started it at 6 (and turned 7 during the fall/winter) when I went to school. I'm sure she could handle it academically. Does she have any social issues that make you think grade 2 would be a bad fit?
The first year it wouldn't be a big deal at all. She would be in the 1st/2nd grade split so right in the middle of the age range. The next year could be a bigger issue (with her being 7 in a group of 8-10 year olds).
post #84 of 284
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Britishmum
Dd - Hmmmmm. But did God even invent George Bush?

Me (stifling giggles) - Well, yes, because God created everything.

dd - But why did he invent George Bush?

:LOL :LOL :LOL
: That's hilarious!! : I ask myself the same question....

Tired-- I was a young student, and quite frankly it wasn't a big deal. The only time I can remember being upset about it was in Kindergarten; the teacher made a big deal about birthdays and I noticed right away that the kids were all turning six before I turned five. The next youngest child in my class turned six three weeks before my fifth birthday, and in my little head three weeks was *forever*. I came home and demanded that my mother change my birthday. :LOL I said, "the last kid in my class who was five turned six on Saturday, and I'm still not five. You have to fix that!" She just kept saying over and over again that I'd turn five soon, but I just had to wait it couldn't be helped. I was irritated, but the people we were staying with made a great party for me on my birthday and I felt a heck of a lot better about it all. :LOL

I had a friend in school who's birthday wasn't until March because she skipped kindergarten. She's in veterinary school right now, I think, because she changed her mind about what she wanted to do (she's got a masters in neural chemistry). It's all good. The fact is, as you get older the age difference means less and less, until you get to college and there are kids who are younger than you are and adults who've got grown children and are going back to school and you realize that you only thought the age thing was important in elementary school because the teachers and your parents made a big fuss about it.

As far as socialization goes, I personally had huge issues with it but that had much more to do with my personality than my age. In fact, in retrospect I think that if I'd been in a class of even older children, I'd have had an easier time of it. Looking at the research, I was a prime candidate for grade skipping. I think I'd have been much more comfortable in a class of fourth graders at 4.5 than I was with the older kindergarten class. But I digress.

I'm with lckrause: it really depends on your reasons for homeschooling. If I could afford it and my kids got a place at a "gifted" school, I'd probably consider it, especially for BeanBean. He's an almost overbearingly social child. While I don't see school as the ideal social environment, for him any opportunity to meet more people is and will be a great thing. I'd probably put him in for three days a week initially and take it from there. My reasons for homeschooling are varied, but having challenging work is one of the big ones. If there's a school that can provide that and be a social outlet for BeanBean, I'm all in favor of it.
post #85 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by Britishmum
dd - But why did he invent George Bush?
:LOL Why indeed?

Last summer DD1 made an animal parade of all her HABA figures. Along one side she set up a row of trees and shrubs. A guest asked her what kinds of trees they were and she answered, using her sweetest voice, "A peach tree, and apple tree, [a couple more things], and that jackass bush. I was very pregnant at the time and actually hurt myself laughing.
post #86 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by Britishmum
Socially I think there are ages when it's not a big deal, but when you hit puberty, I think it is much more of an issue. JMO, but it's not something I would do, especially if you have a good thing going at home anyway.
I am assuming that my kids won't be in traditional school during/after puberty. This would be simply a 2nd-5th or 6th grade thing for us.

Quote:
Originally Posted by eilonwy
Tired-- I was a young student, and quite frankly it wasn't a big deal. The only time I can remember being upset about it was in Kindergarten; the teacher made a big deal about birthdays and I noticed right away that the kids were all turning six before I turned five. The next youngest child in my class turned six three weeks before my fifth birthday, and in my little head three weeks was *forever*. I came home and demanded that my mother change my birthday.
Do you mean that you were put in kinder as an early 4? So all the other kids turned six before you turned 5? Thats funny because I have gotten a lot of comments about "Is DS going to kinder next year?" because he is right about that level (though not that size!!!). But his b-day is Aug 31st, so he will actually turn 4 the week school starts. I would definately not put him in traditional school, but DD goes to a supplimental homeschool program (where she takes many of her classes) and he could go if I tested him in. But, I think we're going to go ahead and wait until he is a very young 5 instead. I my time with just DS while DD is in her class!
post #87 of 284
Oh, I just wanted to add:

Quote:
Originally Posted by eilonwy
If I could afford it and my kids got a place at a "gifted" school, I'd probably consider it, especially for BeanBean.
It is actually a program through the public schools. It is a fairly large school district (24-25 schools averaging 4-600 students per school) and they simply have small magnet schools. If I had the $ I would be drawn more toward a Democratic/Child-Led school.
post #88 of 284
I started kindergarten when I was 4 and didn't turn 5 until the middle of November. It never bothered me at all until my junior year of high school - all my friends had their driver's licence before I was old enough to get my learner's permit. That was a huge bummer! But I never had any socialization problems or anything.

I had wonderful experiences in the public school gifted programs. I was in pull-out programs (met once a week or once a month, being pulled from regular class into a gifted class) from third grade through 7th grade, nothing much in 8th-9th grade, summer after 10th grade I went to a specialized camp for gifted kids, and 11th-12th grade did a half-day specialized school that pulled gifted students from all the surrounding schools. DH also had wonderful experiences in public school in the gifted program - we actually met at the specialized high school.
post #89 of 284
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by NoHiddenFees
:LOL Why indeed?

Last summer DD1 made an animal parade of all her HABA figures. Along one side she set up a row of trees and shrubs. A guest asked her what kinds of trees they were and she answered, using her sweetest voice, "A peach tree, and apple tree, [a couple more things], and that jackass bush. I was very pregnant at the time and actually hurt myself laughing.
: We had to work so hard to watch our mouths around BeanBean, because the ILs are hyperconservatives. As it is, he saw Bush on TV once down there and said, "it's that moron, mamma!" Luckily MIL was in the kitchen and FIL was taking a nap. :LOL

Tired-- I was a late four when I started kindergarten. There was a morning class for the "younger" kids and an afternoon class for the "older" kids (the idea being that younger kids might still need a nap in the afternoon). The district I was in had a cut off date of September 30th, which meant that my brother made the cut but I didn't. We'd have been in the same class, and my mother didn't want that so she had me tested. There were about a dozen other kids tested that year; four of them "passed" and were put into the younger kindergarten with the other five year olds. I was put into the older kindergarten, with all the kids who hadn't made the cut off date the previous year and whose parents had held them back for whatever reason. Most of them turned six in September, one or two were six at the beginning of the year. I turned five in October. My mother tells me that they wanted to put me in first grade, but she wouldn't allow it.

In second grade, I started attending a teensy weensy little private school where I pretty much had my own curriculum. I was given a sixth grade spelling book, no reading book at all (because I knew how to read), a fourth grade math book and, after one month of playing catch-up, my own fifth grade Hebrew class. Over the following summer, my mom tutored a high school kid in algebra and my brother and I learned it along with him. I had a few really good years in terms of education, but I remember a lot of wasted time waiting for kids to catch up. Despite the fact that there were never more than three kids in my grade and eleven in my class, I did an awful lot of waiting. : The wasted time is something else that really ticks me off about school. I don't think that most parents realize how little time in school is actually spent doing school work, especially for a child who can finish "an hour" of work in two or three minutes. I can remember just wandering around the classroom for hours on end, looking out the window because I'd finished my book and hadn't had room in my backpack for another. It was around the end of third grade that I decided that longer books were the way to go, and that Star Trek novels simply weren't long enough; I started reading anthologies. :LOL Boy, did I get some funny looks for that.

I definately hope to avoid wasting so much time with my own kids. I've heard people say that if I was really so smart, I'd have found something to do in school. They don't really get it; I did everything that there was to be done, and didn't want to play games-- I wanted, needed to learn something new and there just wasn't anything for me to do. I was in the oldest class in my school, so I couldn't wander down the hall to find some older kids. I'd already gone above and beyond what they had to offer me. I never want my kids to feel like they ought to be learning something but they don't have the opportunity to do so. If they finish everything I can throw at them, I will *find* something else for them to do. I'm not sure what I'll do if they don't prove to have the same voracious appetites for the written word that I do, but I'll think of something. Where there's a will, there's a way, and boy have I ever got the will!

It's very cool that your public school system has a special place for gifted kids. When I got back into public school for seventh grade, I was put into the top class, and given all kinds of extras but they weren't really enough. For example: the class I was in took pre-algebra in seventh grade. Three other girls were in an algebra I class with me. It was all well and good, but I got a B in that class despite the fact that I only turned in homework once every other week or so. I loved the teacher, she was great, but the work just moved too slowly, and the class consisted entirely of material that I'd covered when I was 7, in the summer before third grade. I was bored and remained bored throughout the year. I joined the chess club, and participated in OM and PJAS and Speech & Debate, and I was still bored. I spent a lot of time reading novels in class, and I was late for school more often than not. I just didn't want to be bothered. The whole thing felt like a waste of time. I'd have been happier in the library for those eight hours every day, and I'd probably have learned more.

I gave up doing homework entirely in eighth grade, doing only assignments which I found interesting. In general, these involved research which was (still is) one of my favorite things to do. I wrote my quasicrystal paper in eighth grade, and several essays for civics class. I missed a lot of school being sick and participating in "extra" activities-- that year I won several awards for "school projects" despite spending more time out of classes than in. I had a lot of fun that year, but that just reinforced the lesson that school is a waste of time-- all of the good stuff happened outside of class. My teachers didn't know what to do with me, and I must have heard the "you have so much potential..." speech a hundred times that year. My English teacher told me that she was hurt by my refusal to do her assignments (I managed not to laugh until I was out of earshot, but it was difficult), my math teacher was oblivious and gave me a B because "she's always so quiet during class and she does well on her tests," and my science teacher (who was also my homeroom teacher) just didn't get me at all. I'd ask questions in class that would make his hair stand on end, and help other students to get A's and then turn around and not hand in assignments. "They're so easy for you, why can't you turn them in?" But I really couldn't-- how could I possibly focus on the differences between different kinds of rocks when there were much more interesting things going on just a few blocks away in books at the library? I mean, the rocks were interesting for a little while, but I finished reading the textbook about two weeks into the school year and after that I just didn't want to be bothered filling in the blanks on stupid homework assignments.

Recently, I've learned that this phenomenon has actually been documented; far from being alone in this, I was just like hundreds if not thousands of other kids of similar ability all over the country. I was so relieved when I read about it, because it proved to me that I was right all along. I didn't fail schools, they failed me. I can do better for my own kids, by making sure that they've got something interesting to do. They don't have to wait until they're 15 to get to an interesting class with new subject material-- *everything* can be new before then. They'll be busy when they need to be busy, and be left alone when they don't. I'm dead set on making things better for them, so they won't go to school; instead, they'll stay home and get educations.
post #90 of 284
I was young for my grade, though not by too, too much; I have a November birthday and started K at 4. I actually do feel that it was a handicap at certain points: puberty (I also hit it late, at about 13/14) and at the time everyone else got their drivers' licenses. The puberty part was much worse; I was still interested in my elaborate unicorn fantasies and everyone else was obsessed with boys. But I suppose that could happen no matter what.

I see how grade-skipping can be quite helpful to the profoundly gifted. I'm not sure how I feel about it when it comes to mildly to moderately gifted kids (which is what I was). I can't say yet where DD falls; I'd guess she's somewhere in that range, right now. I think she is lopsidedly gifted, like me. Her aptitude for puzzles and things of that type seems very average. But she is light years ahead verbally, and her memory, attention span, and...mental acquisitiveness, I'd guess I'd call it, continue to amaze me.
post #91 of 284
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by loraxc
I was young for my grade, though not by too, too much; I have a November birthday and started K at 4. I actually do feel that it was a handicap at certain points: puberty (I also hit it late, at about 13/14) and at the time everyone else got their drivers' licenses. The puberty part was much worse; I was still interested in my elaborate unicorn fantasies and everyone else was obsessed with boys. But I suppose that could happen no matter what.
Well, I hit puberty fairly early; I got my first period at 10.5, just like my mother. Started growing boobs shortly thereafter, too, so by the time I started seventh grade I was a solid c-cup. I never really looked out of place until later, when everyone else got taller and stopped being so babyfaced (I am *still* babyfaced). :LOL I didn't want to get my license, so it wasn't a big deal that I couldn't take driver's ed "with everyone else." It never phased me. People did look at me cross-eyed in college when I didn't drive at all, especially as a commuter, but I survived. :LOL I didn't get my license until BeanBean was 3 months old.
post #92 of 284
Thread Starter 
you know, if i had evidence that my mom had *tried* i'd probably resent her a lot less. I suppose i should cut her some slack, because she had problems with depression, but she never sought help for that either. i may be nuts and awful, but god knows i try to remember to take my pills, i seek advice and i make an effort. today, my kids love me for it, so i suppose it's all good to this point.

of course, beanbean is only 2.5. :LOL
post #93 of 284
So I met w/the certified teacher I meet w/every 45 days to go over what DD is doing (she takes some classes through the school district, and that means every 45 school days I have a 1/2 hour appt w/a certified teacher). Anyway, I was explaining my concerns and she was looking at me quite oddly. Apparently she & the principal have absolutely NO concerns about DD being in the full time gifted program for 2nd grade--- she if great academically and socially and will probably be very successful there, in their opinions. It did help to hear from actual professionals ( ) instead of just other parents that *I* am probably just worrying too much and DD definatley does "belong" in the gifted school.

So, I'm in turmoil again. We went for a tour yesterday of the one day a week program and are going back next week to actually let DD participate a bit (they were having a guest speaker so we really saw *nothing* besides the school grounds, cafeteria, play ground, bathrooms, etc...). Thursday we go visit the full time school and I guess we'll have decided one way or the other by next Friday.
post #94 of 284
Good luck with your decision Tiredx2... It sounds tricky
post #95 of 284
Thread Starter 
Tired, how's the decision making going?

I'm a little worried that BeanBean is being warped by all the stress around here. We just moved and he's not feeling fabulous, but he's okay; he's just been a lot more sensitive than usual. I know that it will probably wear off, along with being sick and the novelty of the new apartment, but in the meantime I worry that he's just being exposed to too much stress and negativity. He's always been sensitive to the moods and tones of people around him, and I worry that it's all affecting him poorly.

Blech. Mike's right-- I need to bit the bullet and take these kids to the park.
post #96 of 284
I replied w/our "Decision" once before but it obviously didn't take.

Anyway, we toured the full time school and have turned in our acceptance letter. We can always decide otherwise, but DP & I were favorably impressed and DD said she would like to go there so

Now I'm beginning to wish I had signed up DS for the 3X weekly preschool instead of the 2X (since it is co-op so I go once a week and I will volunteer at DDs school once a week that leaves no extra days for me )
post #97 of 284
Bleh! I understand not having any alone time...

I sometimes wonder if I belong posting here and then Goo will do something that blows me away.

The last thing was that she was not allowed to have ice cream, so she went off to the living room, got a whiffle ball and a cup and "made" an ice cream cone.
She then proceded to tell us that she was going to have that ice cream. We said "ok, what kind is it?" She looked at us and said " Vanilla, it's white, you see?"

Moo is starting to show more and more traits like her sister.
They are fun, but MAN this can get tough
post #98 of 284
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Foobar
Bleh! I understand not having any alone time...

I'm still waiting for mine. :LOL

Tired-- Let us know how it goes, I'm really curious to hear about how the school works out. It sounds really cool. I understand about being desperate for alone time, but there's always next year for your little guy to go to school full-time.

I feel like my kids are starting to get really strange. BeanBean had a huge (physical) growth spurt recently, and he seems to have gotten older as well. He's still little, but he's much more of a little boy than a toddler these days. He's discovered motors (I blogged a little about that) and he's still really fascinated by the idea. I haven't found one to show to him yet, though, haven't had a chance with Bean and BooBah being sick and the whole moving mess.

Last week, he asked the boy next door who drove the old Toyota by the yard. It was a really old one, before the current logo when they just wrote "TOYOTA" across the front grill, so I guess he really can read that particular word. The BND said, "I don't know," and then looked at me and asked, "What's a Toyota?" BeanBean got agitated and pointed to the car and said, "There, that SUV, that's a Toyota!" He didn't know what to make of it all. BeanBean tried to teach him the names of all the vehicles on our street, but he just wasn't interested; BND is just not all that into cars, which of course was a complete mystery to BeanBean. :LOL He can now tell you what kind of car it is without seeing the logo or the words-- he seems to know them by shape. That's beyond me, most of the time! :LOL Of course, I'm not all that into cars either.

BooBah has decided that she can talk. She is not always clear, but her cadences are identical to BeanBean's, so if you've heard him speak you can understand her a lot more often than you might otherwise. She's always so pleased when people understand her. She gets the biggest, cheesiest grin on her face. :LOL What a love. She did the funniest thing yesterday-- she took a tissue out of a box, took a bite out of it and then shoved it back into the box while looking around furtively. I almost fell over laughing! : It was so funny to see that little brain working, thinking, "If I can't see Mamma, Mamma can't see me!" :LOL :
post #99 of 284
.
post #100 of 284
Quote:
Originally Posted by caloli
Our problem is that he finds it hard to be interested in school stuff - his teacher is wonderful, but she has an obligation to teach the other kids grade-appropriate materials! We're thinking of enrichment activities, but we don't want to place any pressure on him. We've spoken with him about it and he's eager to try a few new ideas. I really do think that learning through play and social experiences is way more important than anything a book can ever teach him, so I'm reluctant to immerse him in 'bookwork'. But I want to do what's best for him. So I'm stuck in a corner at the moment.
Welcome caloli!

Most of us here have few or inadequate options within our local school systems for our children and are choosing to homeschool. Is your son accelerated? In a GT program? Are there any accomodations being made? For anyone not homeschooling, I'd recommend reading:


Genius Denied by the Davidsons
A Nation Deceived Here's some potential resources for afterschooling:
Creative Home Schooling for Gifted Children (now called Creative Home Schooling for Smart Families) by Lisa Rivero
Guerrilla Learning by Grace Llewellyn The former is a great book for all parents of gifted kids, not just homeschoolers.

I'm also partial to Some of my Best Friends are Books.

There are lots of other resources to be found at Hoagies.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting the Gifted Child
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Parenting the Gifted Child › Support for Parents of Gifted Children, #4