American Idol -- The Top 4 or YAY! Scotty's gone! - Page 2

[MamaBug]

Didn't watch last night! Thanks so much for your regular lodown Cranberry it's like I was watching anyway! :LOL Will try to see who gets the boot, should be A but who knows!

[Cranberry]

I read somewhere that Vonzell was upset last night because her dog died. Seriously. Don't know if it's true. ETA: I feel sad for my baby Vee.

Also, Corey Clark is now claiming he has proof of his relationship with Paula... hmm, videotape anyone? Polaroids? DNA, perhaps?

[stayinghome]

I hope Vonzell doesn't go tonight.

Who is Clive?

[Alkenny]

Clive Davis is a record producer.

Okay, last night...I actually thought Anthony did pretty good. Not my style, but he didn't mess anything up and the ballads suit him.

Carrie sucked, even in "her" genre. I usually like Vonzelle, but I think she's gone and we'll have another week of "He's so a-MAZ-ing" Anthony.

Bo was pretty good...unga-bunga.

[armonia]

Someone throw some water on me...Bo is so yummy. You are right: the sandals, the shades, the chest, his voice.
Vonzell: I really liked the second song.
Anthony: Didn't suck as bad as he usually does.
Carrie: Loved the first song. Amy did it really well, too in a previous season...probably a little better. But I do like Carrie because she seems so down-to-Earth. She doesn't try to sell herself..she is like "whatever". I think that is funny.

Probably good-bye Vonzell.

I miss sexy Constantine. It would have been cool to see what he came up with in the finals.

[ERSsmom]

I thougt everyone did a good job last night, including Anthony. In fact, I was a little amazed by him. Vonzell did really mess up the lyrics, I think she started singing the wrong verse. I wish it were Anthony leaving, but it may be Vonzell. However, those tears may win her some sympathy votes, it was really sad. Then again, we may be surprised and see Carrie or Bo leave.

[Cranberry]

I am such a loser. :

I need to get a life. :

I am desperately waiting for idolmedia.tv to post last night's songs so I can watch Bo sing that Money song again (and again and again).

If he gets voted off, I will not watch the rest of the season. Seriously.

[Carsonsmama]

Well then this will not be so well received..... : But I don't like Bo! EEK!!!
I find him very unattractive and he rocks out to every song....even when you shouldn't be rockin to them. He definitely likes to yell through every song..."money" suited him well and I thought her did a good job of it....though it involved allot of borderline screaming...which is his style.
I am disappointed that he seems to have picked up that terribly annoying habit of Constatines and carries the mike stand all over the stage with him!

As for Anthony....is that his accent coming through in his singing that makes it so...unenjoyable? I find that he seems like he is talking through some parts of the songs...and is he in pain or trying to feel the emotion of the song. My personal opinion is that he should go tonight....sorry Anthony!

And Carrie...I think she is cute....she reminds me of a cousin of mine that dies when she was 20 so it doesn't really matter how she sings to me. I like her anyway. However she definitely has her element and that is country music...and I think she is one of the better for "preforming" and acting like she is having fun at least. I also didn't think she did as bad of job as Simon thought she did with "If you don't know me by now".

And Vonzell...I think she is super. I really do...I totally enoyed the second song she sang even though I didn't know it well. Simon called her manic and that he was nervous or stressed for her...I thought she looked like she was having fun. I like her voice....I think she has lots of potential. They probably thought she was weak though losing it during the first song.....

I guess we'll see....however my fingers are crossed that Anthony sings his last song tonight and that the girls are the final two contestants....although I wouldn't really be surprised if one of them gets voted off tonight.

[ERSsmom]

Originally Posted by Carsonsmama

As for Anthony....is that his accent coming through in his singing that makes it so...unenjoyable? I find that he seems like he is talking through some parts of the songs...and is he in pain or trying to feel the emotion of the song.

I think that is exactly his problem. It seems so unnatural when he sings, like he is reading the words or something.

[TurboClaudia]

bo's sandals made me laugh :LOL and then i wanted to run my fingers through his yummy hair over and over and over and... did i just say that on the public web?

and vonzell: really, her pooch died? *sniff sniff* i was just remembering last night that you've come a long way, baby vee, from your early performances. reminded me of kimberly locke.

anthony: you did okay, but are you on steroids or something? your face looks chubbier now than in the beginning...

carrie: you are so sweet, but natalie maines shows more personality in two phrases of that song than you have in the entire season thus far. i want to like you, really, i do, and i respect your "whatever" attitude because that's a healthy way to be most of the time, but i won't be buying your album.

now bo's album, on the other hand, can't wait to see what ends up on that...

and did you hear that bo's girlfriend is about 3 months pregnant?

and bo's mom does not look old enough to be his mom. she looks guh-ood. hope i look like that when my son is 29. ha ha...

~claudia

[Mom2Cora]

Here's my opinion rundown...

Bo- LOVE him! He's adorable, sexy and I love his style. Hated his first performance, boring song. Money was AWESOME though!

Carrie- I really like her, she's cute but needs to work on her moves...I think she has excellent potential as a country artist. LOVED her sin wagon perfrmance.

Vonzell- she does nothing for me, great voice but I'm just not into the dive style ballads.

Anthony- Ugh! AWFUL! How in the world did he get this far???? He is ridiculously boring.

That said, I'm rooting for Bo or Carrie!!!

[Cranberry]

Originally Posted by Carsonsmama

: But I don't like Bo! EEK!!!

You are not welcome here.


You just take your hate somewheres else.

[oldcrunchymom]

Hmmm. I didn't notice Bo's sandals. I was too busy looking at the rest of him. I voted for him 100 gajillion times so he better not go. Actually, I fear Vonzelle might be the next one voted off. Lots of insane tonedeaf people like Anthony. He was so :yawning: last night.

Yup, Amy did Sin Wagon way better than Carrie. It's kind of freaky to see the repeated songs like that. I get all annoyed every time someone does a "Clay" or "George" song. Never mind Carrie and Anthony repeating the same song in the same show! What was up with that?

[bugmomma]

*LOL* Cranberry, you crack me up!! You should turn your posts into a book and title it 'Cranberry Stalks Idol' :LOL

I totally agree about Bo..yummy yum yum.

Lacey

[Cranberry]

I do hope it’s Anthony or Carrie leaving tonight. Not my Bo. Not my BabyVee. But someone is probably going to get Latoya’d. Last year she got cut and we had to endure yet another week with Jazzy, that no-talent girl who consistently sang “out of tyune.” I am afraid that tonight might be the night Vee gets cut. And then next week it’ll be Anthony. He’s gotta get down to Miami before the cruise ship leaves the port.

Yes, Ryan, imagine this show with a different host… why is Ryan dressed like an accountant? White shirt and striped tie? Is he my dad?

Islands in the Stream. Hate, hate that song. Bo is cringing cuz he’s gotta sing such a cheesy song. Yet Anthony is right at home in the cheesefest. Carrie tries to dance… eek. Vee and Bo rock together! Kids, please step away from the catwalk.

Ford commercial. What the did they do to Bo’s hair? : He has officially sold out completely. How will he EVAH face his rawker friends at home??? They are going to kick the living out of him.

Oooh, the original auditions… lot of filler tonight. Anthony, Anatoly? Very yelly, and a tad bit screechy. Ears. Hurting. Here.

Special surprise coming up? Are Simon and Bo’s grandma going to mud wrestle? Because I’d like to get some money on the grandma.

Ouch, someone is getting a one-way coach ticket home… Seacrest, that was cold. I seriously hope it’s you and your excessive hair product.

My Bo is safe. Yes! *tears of joy*

Anthony! *tears of joy*

Perfect.

Yo, Carrie, get yourself a Kleenex.

[seren]

Ok, I missed it, who's gone?

[Mom2Cora]

Anthony's gone! woohoo!

[PancakeGoddess]

Originally Posted by Cranberry

Special surprise coming up? Are Simon and Bo’s grandma going to mud wrestle? Because I’d like to get some money on the grandma.

:


cranberry, my kids agreed that coach flight comment was harsh. but don't you think some writer is to blame? he seems to want to be nicer to the contestants than the judges. anyway... i'm partial to ryans i guess.

very happy with the outcome tonight. now we need a byebyecarrie miracle for next week. vonzell is so awesome.

[oldcrunchymom]

I didn't get what the "surprise" was supposed to be. Was it just that they were flying home? They do that every year!

[Cranberry]

Originally Posted by benjalo

cranberry, my kids agreed that coach flight comment was harsh. but don't you think some writer is to blame? he seems to want to be nicer to the contestants than the judges. anyway... i'm partial to ryans i guess.

You're right. It was probably the writers. I just like to pick on my RyRy.