our list...
DD (8yo)
Wood kitchen, wood food, dishes
Baby dolls, cradle, dolly clothes
Scraps of fabric for various imaginative things
art supplies (a favorite)
playdoh
Spy stuff
tinker toys
geometric blocks (the kind you see in schools) ours our wood, both kids LOVE them
Fashion Polly :LOL
some Barbis (she sold most in our yard sale though)
Matchbox cars
books
and the biggest one... DIRT AND ROCKS!! Oh, and STICKS!
Dd is always outside collecting, creating and playing
DS (3yo)
Large Tonka dump truck (his favorite toy by far)
Tonka fire engine (it does have sounds but not too obnoxious)
Wood hammer and peg bench
train sets (brio and we have the FP Geo set (..gift, it's plastic and I didn't buy it!)
matchbox cars
books
art supplies (the hole punch is a favorite and good for them to do)
balls
trike and (new) big boy bike (training wheels!)
FP fold up car track (the kind they wind up, no batteries required...ALL kids who come here play with this toy)
and of course DIRT ROCKS AND STICKS
both my kids love to dig in the dirt and we all know that is a childhood pasttime right? They get the old screwdrivers and really have fun. They have a sandbox and a beach full of sand but they prefer finding the patches of dirt in our yard (newer house) and using the 'real' dirt :LOL

:
Toys I won't allow:
Legos (I like them, but ds throws them so they went into a long time out)
PIT BALLS and the playhut SOLD in our yard sale (picking up 100+ pit balls is not fun!)
Noisy toys that break, remote toys that break
Skateboards (I had a closed head injury on one at 17 and refuse to let my kids own one OR a scooter)
toy guns
toys that are not interactive (we have some but they are not played with so there ya go!)
ETA...I just got rid of tons of toys to our daycare, goodwill and the yard sale. I would love to get rid of more. I really don't like many toys at all, in the summer they are outside digging and running and on their bikes. One thing I have a hard time with is throwing out the stuffed animals
