Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › I'm going to participate in my local hospital's OB focus group - give me ideas
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I'm going to participate in my local hospital's OB focus group - give me ideas - Page 2  

post #21 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by hopefulfaith
Also, don't forget about the "childbirth ed" classes that the hospital offers. If they're revamping everything, maybe they'll go to a more pro-woman format rather than a "here's how to be a good patient in our hospital" format.

I went to mine last weekend, and here's how the breastfeeding discussion went:

Instructor: "Is anyone here planning to breastfeed?"
(half class raises hands)
Instructor silently passes out "The Essential Guide to Breastfeeding" to those of us with our hands up.

...and goes on to the rest of the material. Spends no time discussing anything.

I was so disappointed. Missed such a great opportunity!!

So, don't forget about suggestions for the childbirth classes!


BTW, good good good for you. I'm so glad you're doing this -- on behalf of women who will follow you into that hospital:

hopefulfaith,

WOW about you said about this and wonderful oppunity to do this kind of thing. Again, as I been saying in my replies in this thread all of the US hospitals should be baby friendly now. Thank you.
post #22 of 40
Thread Starter 
OK. This thing is tomorrow evening. I'm really excited. I'll surely update after it's over. Here's what I came up with:

1. Offer VBAC - I have lots of stats. They currently have 100% 2ndry CS rate. I think there's room for improvement.
2. Baby friendly hospital info
3. IBCLC on staff or on call
4. Distribute local LLL meeting info
5. Advertize that they have midwives practicing there (CNM, but pretty good - I had them for my 1st son.) People are looking for CNM's right now, and the closest hospital that has them is 35 miles away.
6. Waterbirth oprions & labor tubs (many local hospitals have this - they're behind the curve on this one)
7. Good, thorough breastfeeding info at the CB classes. Give moms other CB class options (the classes are free, and ok at the hospital, but we have Bradley, Lamaze, Hypnobirthing, and no brand ones in the area too)
8. Minimize seperation when a CS is done

I am too "high strung" about circ & am having a really hard time comming up with a "reasonable" way to present this. Help would be awesome as it needs to be mentioned. I was re-reading the AAP statement, and was impressed with the # of times it mentions, factual, unbiased, accurate information on risk/benefit being offered to moms. I should probably go with something like that? I need help here - all I could think of was yelling "Stop mutilating baby's!!!!" but I think that may send the wrong message. :LOL Maybe not.
post #23 of 40
amandabl,

Totally love your presentation to them and hope it all goes well. Thank you.
post #24 of 40
Thread Starter 

It went really well

It went really well! The marketing director was there as well as the head of the LD unit (she's got a long history in LD nursing, but I guess has moved on to doing policy?) There were only 4 moms & one grandma there out of 1300 invites. Of those 4 moms, one was a emergency CS, one was a planned hospital birth with epidural that ended well, and TWO were planned homebirths - one transfer due to extremely long labor, ending in vaginal birth with vaccume extractor and me who was an unplanned induction & epidural due to ovarian cyst torsion, ending in vaginal birth.

They had a survey with a 3 page list of items/services. We were asked to # the items 1-5 as how important they would be to us. Of the highlights were, waterbirth, double services, double beds for dads to snuggle, sibling/grandparent classes, lactation visits, baby friendly status. I can't remember all of them, but it was a pretty good list I thought, coming from an OB department.

They want to start a parent advisory board & they asked me to join that which I did. They want to have a list of local doulas, and I said I'd get one for them. They want to offer other childbirth classes, either at the hospital &/or a list of contact info to give to moms, I said I'd work on that. They want "peer counselors" for their breastfeeding group & for moms to talk to. They want to have a babywearing class. Me & the other crunchy mom said we'd do that. We brought up cloth diapering - that ws funny. Nobody knew there were still cloth diapers!

We all introduced ourselves, told a bit about us, our children, our births. Everyone shared their hospital specific complaints. We said that the nurses are not homebirth friendly. I reminded them that homebirthing is statistically safe, and my legal right to choose. In the event a homebirther comes to the hospital, they should NOT be treated poorly. I pointed to that the only homebirths they see are transfers, and that's about 12%. There other 88% are fine & they never hear of them. I also pointed out that I have many HB ing friends who delivered successfully, as did the other homebirther.

The "crunchy" mom had a boy, no circ, the other 2 had girls. I gave them a good circ consent form, brought up the AAP policy about "accurate, unbiased info" and how the topic is asked about & that gives the impression it should/needs to be done. They said they were in the process of coming up with a statement about that and she liked my form. Thanks to the mothering mama who got me that form!!!

I gave them the ICAN white page on PPD, PTSD as it seemed really comprehensive to me. Thanks to the mothering mamas for that suggestion - I never would have thought of it

They already have a letter of intent from "Baby Friendly" and have stopped formula distribution, although they give the diaper bags out still, but w/o the cans. I pointed out to her that she was taking notes on an "Enfamil" note pad. She laughed & said she didn't even think of that. I pointed out that I made the nurse not use the Enfamil tape measure on Luke's head. Everyone got a kick out of that. The other crunchy mama pointed out that the Zephyrhills water we were drinking is a nestle product & they should check out babymilkaction.org

I gave them info on the mother friendly childbirth initiative.

I gave them tons of LLL info & talked about a CS recovery meeting - they liked that idea. I told them "you don't have to reinvent the wheel" that there are people who would probably be willing to have the meetings there for them. She said they'd love that - ha-ha - wait till the ICANers show up!!!

The one planned hosp birth mom is a pastor wife of the local 7th day Adventist church, and she wants to have LLL mtgs at the church. So I gave her my contact info & will work on that with her.

Then I let the fun begin. I told her that while all of those things are important, and would make a difference, that there is an issue they can fix. It would improve revenue AND dramatically improve mother/baby care. Its something no hospital within 30 miles is duplicating, and only 3 hospitals within an hours drive do it. It's proven safe, has existing protocol, and mothers talk to me & my friends at least once a day looking for it. I told them that the women I know tell women not to have a baby at this hospital because of this. (They were on the edge of their seats ha-ha) I said VBAC, and the faces fell. She told me that she wasn't going to try & defend the practice, but "bla bla bla 24 hour anesthesia bla bla bla"

I very calmly said, "What I'm about to say, may sound somewhat 'attacking' but there isn't a better way for me to frame the question. I so much appreciate being invited here, and I really want to help, so please, keep an open mind. (they were nodding & looking a little worried) "First of all, I believe the standard is that you have to have anes available within 30 min of an incident, not actually 24 hour anes. (They agree) "If you can't provide surgery to a patient in 30 min, you shouldn't be called a hospital. What are you going to do for me as a healthy laboring woman with NO CS if I have uterine rupture or cord prolapsed or a separation? What about a patient on another floor you determine has a blood clot that can kill them in 40 min?" She says "Very good point"

That's when the emergency CS mom lost it about how afraid she was to have another baby b/c the CS was so horrible & she already knows no Dr will do it & until they change that there's no way in hell she'll ever come back to this hospital. The lady starts talking about the "risks" of rupture. I flip to my ICAN white page on the statistics & the highlighted portion of the fact sheet & share with the group. She is looking at me disbelieving and asks where it came from. I look at the footnote & quote the orig source and she shut up.

She says that they have been getting a LOT of pressure from their main OB group to do VBAC, as they've lost 2 clients this week b/c of it & they loose many more regularly. I told her that one of those 2 clients that changed practices is named "Jane Doe". She's one of my good friends, and she transferred because of me. I pointed out that women like me may be the minority (in that we care so much about birth VBAC & maternity care) but we're an extremely active & vocal minority. I told her that if they could get us "on their side" it would benefit them tremendously. I also pointed out that there are HUGE bio-ethical & legal issues surrounding CS & VBAC ban, and they ARE going to get caught in the fray. I gave her the info I printed on the Vermont/NH project the local ICAN mama sent me . She said it was interesting & would talk to the others about it, but she didn't know. I pointed out that ACOG thought it was great & gave her a copy of the ACOG press release about the award VT/NH proj got. That impressed her more than anything, I think - that I had the protocol, the contact info, and the ACOG award info. We'll see.

I feel good about it. I feel like I got my foot in the door. They were impressed with my local involvement & history with the hospital - I dropped a few names. I will get working on all the stuff I said I'd do (SOMEONE STOP ME BEFORE I VOLUNTEER FOR ANYTHING ELSE!) and stay in close contact with them. I'd appreciate your thoughts....

Thanks so much for all the info people got to me I think it turned out to be pivotal. There's a celebration & nurse-out at Wal-Mart from 10 - 2 this Sat in honor of breastfeeding week. Me, my youngest, my sling, lots of LLL info, my "support, encourage, protect breastfeeding" bracelet ( thanks to the MDC co op mama ), and my "lactivist" T shirt ( from Breast or Bust, thanks to the MDC Banner ad ) are gonna be there. I'm keeping close to these people. I think it might help.
post #25 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmandaBL
It went really well! The marketing director was there as well as the head of the LD unit (she's got a long history in LD nursing, but I guess has moved on to doing policy?) There were only 4 moms & one grandma there out of 1300 invites. Of those 4 moms, one was a emergency CS, one was a planned hospital birth with epidural that ended well, and TWO were planned homebirths - one transfer due to extremely long labor, ending in vaginal birth with vaccume extractor and me who was an unplanned induction & epidural due to ovarian cyst torsion, ending in vaginal birth.

They had a survey with a 3 page list of items/services. We were asked to # the items 1-5 as how important they would be to us. Of the highlights were, waterbirth, double services, double beds for dads to snuggle, sibling/grandparent classes, lactation visits, baby friendly status. I can't remember all of them, but it was a pretty good list I thought, coming from an OB department.

They want to start a parent advisory board & they asked me to join that which I did. They want to have a list of local doulas, and I said I'd get one for them. They want to offer other childbirth classes, either at the hospital &/or a list of contact info to give to moms, I said I'd work on that. They want "peer counselors" for their breastfeeding group & for moms to talk to. They want to have a babywearing class. Me & the other crunchy mom said we'd do that. We brought up cloth diapering - that ws funny. Nobody knew there were still cloth diapers!

We all introduced ourselves, told a bit about us, our children, our births. Everyone shared their hospital specific complaints. We said that the nurses are not homebirth friendly. I reminded them that homebirthing is statistically safe, and my legal right to choose. In the event a homebirther comes to the hospital, they should NOT be treated poorly. I pointed to that the only homebirths they see are transfers, and that's about 12%. There other 88% are fine & they never hear of them. I also pointed out that I have many HB ing friends who delivered successfully, as did the other homebirther.

The "crunchy" mom had a boy, no circ, the other 2 had girls. I gave them a good circ consent form, brought up the AAP policy about "accurate, unbiased info" and how the topic is asked about & that gives the impression it should/needs to be done. They said they were in the process of coming up with a statement about that and she liked my form. Thanks to the mothering mama who got me that form!!!

I gave them the ICAN white page on PPD, PTSD as it seemed really comprehensive to me. Thanks to the mothering mamas for that suggestion - I never would have thought of it

They already have a letter of intent from "Baby Friendly" and have stopped formula distribution, although they give the diaper bags out still, but w/o the cans. I pointed out to her that she was taking notes on an "Enfamil" note pad. She laughed & said she didn't even think of that. I pointed out that I made the nurse not use the Enfamil tape measure on Luke's head. Everyone got a kick out of that. I pointed out that the Zephyrhills water we were drinking is a nestle product & they should check out babymilkaction.org

I gave them info on the mother friendly childbirth initiative.

I gave them tons of LLL info & talked about a CS recovery meeting - they liked that idea. I told them "you don't have to reinvent the wheel" that there are people who would probably be willing to have the meetings there for them. She said they'd love that - ha-ha - wait till the ICANers show up!!!

The one planned hosp birth mom is a pastor wife of the local 7th day Adventist church, and she wants to have LLL mtgs at the church. So I gave her my contact info & will work on that with her.

Then I let the fun begin. I told her that while all of those things are important, and would make a difference, that there is an issue they can fix. It would improve revenue AND dramatically improve mother/baby care. Its something no hospital within 30 miles is duplicating, and only 3 hospitals within an hours drive do it. It's proven safe, has existing protocol, and mothers talk to me & my friends at least once a day looking for it. I told them that the women I know tell women not to have a baby at this hospital because of this. (They were on the edge of their seats ha-ha) I said VBAC, and the faces fell. She told me that she wasn't going to try & defend the practice, but "bla bla bla 24 hour anesthesia bla bla bla"

I very calmly said, "What I'm about to say, may sound somewhat 'attacking' but there isn't a better way for me to frame the question. I so much appreciate being invited here, and I really want to help, so please, keep an open mind. (they were nodding & looking a little worried) "First of all, I believe the standard is that you have to have anes available within 30 min of an incident, not actually 24 hour anes. (They agree) "If you can't provide surgery to a patient in 30 min, you shouldn't be called a hospital. What are you going to do for me as a healthy laboring woman with NO CS if I have uterine rupture or cord prolapsed or a separation? What about a patient on another floor you determine has a blood clot that can kill them in 40 min?" She says "Very good point"

That's when the emergency CS mom lost it about how afraid she was to have another baby b/c the CS was so horrible & she already knows no Dr will do it & until they change that there's no way in hell she'll ever come back to this hospital. The lady starts talking about the "risks" of rupture. I flip to my ICAN white page on the statistics & the highlighted portion of the fact sheet & share with the group. She is looking at me disbelieving and asks where it came from. I look at the footnote & quote the orig source and she shut up.

She says that they have been getting a LOT of pressure from their main OB group to do VBAC, as they've lost 2 clients this week b/c of it & they loose many more regularly. I told her that one of those 2 clients that changed practices is named "Jane Doe". She's one of my good friends, and she transferred because of me. I pointed out that women like me may be the minority (in that we care so much about birth VBAC & maternity care) but we're an extremely active & vocal minority. I told her that if they could get us "on their side" it would benefit them tremendously. I also pointed out that there are HUGE bio-ethical & legal issues surrounding CS & VBAC ban, and they ARE going to get caught in the fray. I gave her the info I printed on the Vermont/NH project the local ICAN mama sent me . She said it was interesting & would talk to the others about it, but she didn't know. I pointed out that ACOG thought it was great & gave her a copy of the ACOG press release about the award VT/NH proj got. That impressed her more than anything, I think - that I had the protocol, the contact info, and the ACOG award info. We'll see.

I feel good about it. I feel like I got my foot in the door. They were impressed with my local involvement & history with the hospital - I dropped a few names. I will get working on all the stuff I said I'd do (SOMEONE STOP ME BEFORE I VOLUNTEER FOR ANYTHING ELSE!) and stay in close contact with them. I'd appreciate your thoughts....

Thanks so much for all the info people got to me I think it turned out to be pivotal. There's a celebration & nurse-out at Wal-Mart from 10 - 2 this Sat in honor of breastfeeding week. Me, my youngest, my sling, lots of LLL info, my "support, encourage, protect breastfeeding" bracelet ( thanks to the MDC co op mama ), and my "lactivist" T shirt ( from Breast or Bust, thanks to the MDC Banner ad ) are gonna be there. I'm keeping close to these people. I think it might help.

amandabl,

I'm glad it went well. Thank you.
post #26 of 40
Glad it went well!!! That is great that they asked you to be on the parent advisory board!

I would suggest doula training for the L&D nurses. I'm not saying to expect the nurses to function as doulas, but this would still be good training for them so they have some knowledge of normal/natural birth and ways to support women other than offering an epidural. My doula trainer in NC (Ann Tumblin) did specialized training just for hospital staff. She said many L&D nurses have never attended a normal birth w/o interventions. I really got the impression that was the case with the nurse I had when I gave birth to DS. She was skeptical when I came in and didn't want to sit in the bed for EFM and didn't want an IV and said I wasn't planning on using pharmacological pain relief. She got much nicer when she found out I was 9cm. :LOL After the birth our nurse kept going on and on about how "not many people could do that." Blows my mind that it can be this way.
post #27 of 40
Thread Starter 
when my baby nursed seconds after birth they said they'd never seen that before.
post #28 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmandaBL
when my baby nursed seconds after birth they said they'd never seen that before.
That is so depressing!!! What is that video that shows newborn after newborn after newborn crawling up to mamas breast to nurse? They need to see that!
post #29 of 40
Zelda's mom- I so agree with you about doula training for nurses. I was an L&D nurse and until I read lots for myself, I knew nothing about natural birth. Here's what I would have wanted to know- 1. positioning...specifically how different positions help...pushing in other positions besides flat on back 2. that there is a rest and be thankful time during the second stage 3. Massage techniques 4. Nipple stimulation for helping stalled labor 5. Purple pushing is not good
AmandaBL- congrats---It sounds like you were heard!!!
post #30 of 40
Thread Starter 
Where does one get doula traning? I'll find a local place & give her the info if someone can point me in the right direction.

Purple pushing? Enlighten me please.
post #31 of 40
The thing I hated the most was that when I was comfortable during labor the staff kept coming in and asking if I reallt "felt" the contractions. Yeah! But I won't feel them as much if you leave me alone! Don't assume everyone is walking in ready for an epidural and make you feel bad for not getting one.
post #32 of 40
Thread Starter 
My fave was "On a scale of 1 - 10, how bad is the pain?" :
post #33 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmandaBL
My fave was "On a scale of 1 - 10, how bad is the pain?" :
ARRRGGH!! I got that because I was in labour, and then again when I was recovering from my section. My sister was telling me yesterday that when she was recovering from her section (true emergency - second twin was in trouble) under general anesthetic, the nurse actually showed her a row of smiley faces...from frowning to smiling...and asked her to "point to her pain". I'd have screamed!
post #34 of 40
Wow, AmandaBL. Just wow. I'm so impressed with your information, your preparedness, your persuasiveness -- and even more impressed that the hospital is getting serious about some meaningful change. Way to go!!!!!!!!!!!
post #35 of 40
Toasting you from across the ocean with a german beer!
post #36 of 40
Thread Starter 
Thanks guys. I miss you KH I'm big on preparedness - it came in handy here
post #37 of 40
Just reading this thread for the first time, and Amanda, you rock!! What an amazing job you did at that focus group!
post #38 of 40
Amanda BL sorry I didn't respond right away.
Purple pushing is when a mom holds her breath and pushes for 10 seconds. The nurse directs the mom's pushing.
post #39 of 40

doula training info

Doulas of North America is one organization that does doula training. Of the orgs that do doula training, I think it would be the best fit for hospital staff:
www.dona.org/develop/find_a_workshop.php

I think it would be best to use DONA to find an instructor, but to not run a DONA class per se, but instead tweak to meet the needs of the nurses.

HTH!
post #40 of 40
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the definition & the direction on the DONA classes. I'll forward on the info & keep you all updated. I hope something good actually comes of this.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Birth and Beyond
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › I'm going to participate in my local hospital's OB focus group - give me ideas