Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › just got a birth plan
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

just got a birth plan  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
from a family I'm working with. This is the second baby for them, I doula'd their first birth as well. With their first, they knew they were having a girl, but in their birth plan they had, IF it's a boy, we'll circ. I said, have you really looked into that? They said, no not really. I said, I know it's a girl, but for your next one, you should really do some research about it, if you need help finding reliable sources, I have a bunch. I won't cut my sons (didn't have ds yet, was pregnant with him though), you know, my whole nice rant to the parents I take on that say yes to circ. The next version of their birth plan (same baby) said, don't circ.

I have recently started thinking maybe they only put that in there because it wasn't an issue, since they knew they were having a girl and they just wanted me off thier backs.

BUT!! I just got their birth plan for this baby (again they *think* it's a girl, but say they are prepared for a boy, so I don't think the ultrasound was as clear this time) and they have "do not circumcise our son, do not retract our son's foreskin"!!!

Now, as far as I know, I have never heard of foreskins being retracted actaully at the hospital, but who knows about that, but I really think that line speaks to me that they actually researched it at least a little bit to know that part is a threat, don't you think?

I'm so happy, I was seriously spinning in the computer room while dh laughed at me.

This is why I still say I won't automatically reject people who say they might circ. (It's so not about money; I'm doing this birth for free because they can't afford me this time, don't try to tell me it's about the money.) I'm so glad they had me as a doula last time, instead of some doula who didn't bring it up. I'm glad there are doulas out there who don't take them, but I think we need more than one kind of advocate. I have never had a family who circ'ed and I know that some of them would have if I hadn't been a part of it. The hard part will come when a family circs even though i've spoken out against it. I know that will be heartbreaking; maybe after that, I won't be able to take them on anymore. I just don't know.
post #2 of 6
That's terrific! What a wonderful feeling to know you're doing good.
post #3 of 6
It's very obvious they have done some research and my best guess is that they also visited a discussion board such as this one. That's because they were very well aware that an infant's foreskin should not be retracted for any reason. Other sources would not have put such an emphasis on this and they were clearly concerned.

I've also never heard of a baby's foreskin being retracted immediately after birth but it is fairly common at the first well baby visit. It appears that this is one of the fine points they missed but they are definitely informed and that's very good. Congratulations to you for opening their eyes!



Frank
post #4 of 6
Yay!

It's so exciting...you've made a real difference not only in one baby's life but in his descendent's lives to come. Way to go!
post #5 of 6
That's so fantastic!! Thank you for your activism
post #6 of 6
That is wonderful!

I can see your point in taking a couple who want to circ or are on the fence about it. Your infomration could be just what it takes to fully inform them and cause them to firmly insist that they take the WHOLE baby home.

I share your excitement!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › just got a birth plan