Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › WHY do I watch the birth shows on TLC?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

WHY do I watch the birth shows on TLC?  

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
It's so sad. I just watched this beautiful first time mom push out her baby with absolutly NO expression on her face at all and without making so much as a whimper. She just looked dead, like she was totally detached from what was happening to her. Actually, I guess that was the issue here -- birth was happening TO her, not THROUGH her.

She was totally numb from the waist down, on her back on a table with her legs being held all the way back, both her parents, her husband's parent, her husband's sisters, and two friends were in the room with them, bright glaring lights, someone telling her when to push & counting. They asked if she wanted a mirror to see the baby crowning and she was just like "whatever".

The doctor was pulling the baby out by the head while she was pushing, then chopped the cord the second he was out, and whisked him over to the bassinett to be poked/prodded/washed/shot up by the nurses. Finally, wrapped in about 5 blankets, and only able to see his face, he's brought to his mother and laid on her (gown covered) chest for a few brief minutes. Then he's whisked off to the nursery to be checked some more (she was induced 5 wks early). Dad went to the nursery at least. Of course the kiddo is crying at the top of his lungs the whole time he's not with Mom. The nurse says, "We like them to cry, it gets them more oxygen." Then right after she says that she sticks a glove covered finger into his mouth so he'll *stop* crying, while asking "Did she want to nurse? Oh, we better do that soon then." So the first thing this poor babe gets to suckle is some latex covered finger. Even a bottle being held by Mom is better than that! :

Meanwhile the crowd of people in the room is growing, people are making phone calls, and the Mom's just sitting there in the middle of it all with this dazed look on her face like "What happened to me? Did I give birth?".

*sigh* It makes me want to have another baby just to prove, yet again, that you really can have a successful natural birth.

Holly
post #2 of 16
It is sad. I don't watch them anymore. I have great blood pressure and don't want to ruin it. Why on earth did they induce her five weeks early?
post #3 of 16
I don't have a TV at home, so normally I CAN"T watch TLC, even if I wanted to, but a couple weeks ago I was housesitting, so I watched 3-5 shows. A couple were so bad I just turned the channel, but I saw one in a birth center, one in a pool at home, and one using hypnosis. Those were really cool, because each of the moms had unmedicated births, and they didn't look *that* bad! The birth center one even had her little girl there (though she got scared and went downstairs to make cookies).

THose shows were nice, because I have been researching both hynobirthing and water births. I din't think I want to watch Baby Story any more, though!
post #4 of 16
In Baby Story's defense, not all experiences are like that. Just this morning I remarked to my fiance that more and more you see new mommies breast-feeding, and I noticed most of them are natural births, in water, mid-wife assisted. I watch the show several times a day, pretty much every day, and you can't judge the show by one sad story.
post #5 of 16
They induced her 5 weeks early because her water broke and rather than "risk infection", she opted to go ahead and let them induce (with Cytotec, no less). I saw it, too. What I thought was really sad was her mother saying that she had natural births and her daughter (the woman giving birth in this episode) had wanted a natural birth, too. But when the pain of induced labor was too much for her to handle, her mother encouraged her to get an epidural - I don't recall her exact words but it was to the effect of medicine has progressed these days so that women don't need to suffer any more.

Anyway, I just wanted to say that I have watched at least 5 episodes of the new TLC show "Bringing Home Baby" - if you haven't seen it, it essentially documents the first few days after a new baby is born, how the family adjusts to a newborn, etc. ALL FIVE of the episodes I have seen have had breastfeeding mothers and they have shown it in a pretty positive light! In the one today, the grandma was trying to talk the new mom into giving the baby a bottle of formula so he would sleep longer and because she was afraid he wasn't getting enough milk with breastfeeding. The mom stood her ground and didn't let grandma do it. The other episodes have shown how it can be hard in those first days, nursing around the clock, but they have all been positive about it. (And have shown plenty of footage of the babies nursing). I'm impressed!
post #6 of 16
Yes, bringing home baby is a great show, with diverse family dynamics as well! The first episode I saw was a mom who had 2 under 5 and just delivered twins, lots of great footage of tandem bfing, she said she had bf'd the others so she saw no reason not to with twins!
post #7 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by lesley&grace
In Baby Story's defense, not all experiences are like that. Just this morning I remarked to my fiance that more and more you see new mommies breast-feeding, and I noticed most of them are natural births, in water, mid-wife assisted. I watch the show several times a day, pretty much every day, and you can't judge the show by one sad story.
That's good to hear. I've watched it quite a bit too, but seems like over half the time I'm watching a medicated and/or c-section birth. There is a similar show on Discovery Health Channel that I honestly think is worse. That just happens to be the one I saw today.

Holly
post #8 of 16
Birth Day (on Discovery Health channel) is HIDEOUS. I watch those shows, but selectively. I use my TV's program guide to try to find crunchier families.

I'm kind of liking Baby Baby these days. There's a lot of c-sectioning and formula feeding (the show only deals with multiples)--but they don't spend tons of times showing the sections; the focus is more on family dynamics and they DO show breastfeeding quite often, as well as diverse families (there was one West African Muslim/British Jewish couple, for instance). A lot of time is spent on the pregnancies and life with the babes after birth, so it's not just a parade of hospital gowns.
post #9 of 16
It is masochistic to watch those shows!

The fact that is the standard of maternity care in our society is a sad commentary on us to be truthful.
post #10 of 16
The mom was indifferent to the birthing process because she probably was dehydrated, hungry, full of demerol, and tired.
post #11 of 16
I became obsessed watching them AFTER my daughter was born....but that only lasted a week or two!!! It was weird because I wasn't interested in watching them before, then all of a sudden I couldn't turn them off! Thankfully, the urge to watch went away!
post #12 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by danav
Anyway, I just wanted to say that I have watched at least 5 episodes of the new TLC show "Bringing Home Baby" - if you haven't seen it, it essentially documents the first few days after a new baby is born, how the family adjusts to a newborn, etc. ALL FIVE of the episodes I have seen have had breastfeeding mothers and they have shown it in a pretty positive light! In the one today, the grandma was trying to talk the new mom into giving the baby a bottle of formula so he would sleep longer and because she was afraid he wasn't getting enough milk with breastfeeding. The mom stood her ground and didn't let grandma do it. The other episodes have shown how it can be hard in those first days, nursing around the clock, but they have all been positive about it. (And have shown plenty of footage of the babies nursing). I'm impressed!
Dana,

Totally agree with the TLC show Bringing Home the Baby is much then A Baby Story. Most of the episodes that I saw far more much then A Baby Story, but one episode that aired couple of days ago. The mother really didn't do much that much, just let the father handle it, pumped breastmilk, so I just hated the whole episode of that episode.

Thank you.
post #13 of 16
I do watch. Usually, if the stage is set for a natural birth, then I will keep watching. I'm not interested in the caesareans or modern hospital births, so I'll turn the channel if it appears to be going in that direciton.

I have seen some really nice homebirths, birthing center scenarios, and natural hospital births. That is when I love the show!
post #14 of 16
I can't remember now which one it was, whether it was baby story or bringing home baby..no matter..the part that got me was the Mom got an epidural and after the child was born she was elated that she was able to have a "natural childbirth". Nothing like the misinformed misinforming others. She thought because it was vaginal, it was natural. Kitty
post #15 of 16
Before I was pregnant I would watch Baby Story sometimes and I am very thankful for that show because it shows how birth culture is in the U.S. very well- lots of epidurals and moms being "delivered", many C-sections, a few beautiful births with moms at home/birth center giving birth naturally, and very rare few natural births at the hospital. It's a good representation I think- it's what made me say "I have to have a home birth! I can't go through one of those horrid deliveries!"

A Baby Story is a public service announcement for homebirth!

I can't watch them anymore though since I'm trying to cut down on cursing tirades in front of ds :LOL
post #16 of 16
I was liking Bringing Home Baby until I saw an episode the other day where the poor baby was crying, and the mama said "I know she's hungry, but she just ate an hour ago!" So they let the poor thing cry for 4 HOURS, and the whole time, the mama, her partner, and her mom were snarking at each other and whining that they weren't getting any sleep, yet they just kept trying to shove a paci in the poor babe's mouth. Finally they let the poor thing eat, and what do you know? She fell asleep. Duh. I stopped watching after that episode, it pissed me off so much!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Birth and Beyond
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › WHY do I watch the birth shows on TLC?