Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › The Pasco County FL health department in Zephyrhills SUCKS!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Pasco County FL health department in Zephyrhills SUCKS!  

post #1 of 22
Thread Starter 
I went today to get my exemption for my 2 kids. 6 yrs & 11 months.

After a 20 min wait in a room with a sign stating the health departments vision statement (which included treating clients & patients with respect) I was greeted in the waiting room with "You're the one who doesn't want to give any immunizations?" (Everyone else was called to the back by name. Not "So you're the one who can't afford to feed her baby?" or "So you're the one who needs free condoms?") I was taken to her office. The conversation went something like this:


"Tell me a little bit about why you're here today"
"I'm here to get a religious exemption to vaccination form my children"
"So you don't want to do ANY vaccinations?"
"Correct"
"Well, what do you plan to do to protect your children from these deadly diseases?"
"That's not something I came here to discuss. I'm here to get the religious exemption to vaccination form"
"So you just want me to shut up & sign the form?"
I laugh & say "Well, I wouldn't have put it that bluntly. I wouldn't tell you to shut up"
"Well then, how do you plan to prevent these diseases???"
"I don't intend to prevent all of these diseases, but that's not something I'm going to discuss with you. I discuss medical decisions with my children's doctors. I'm just here to get the forms."
"So you're declining vaccinations for religious reasons?"
"Correct"
"You're going to make this choice for them now, and when they're older, they can make whatever decision they want to???"
"Absolutely"
"And what religion are you?"
"You're not allowed to ask me that. I know for a fact that you KNOW that you're not allowed to ask me that."
Words can not describe the look she was giving me at this point.
"That's not true."
"Actually, you know full well it is. Would you like a copy of the current case law? I brought you one."
"Not particularly"
"Well, it's Curry vs. the Dpt of health if you'd ever like to look it up."
"I ALWAYS ask that & usually people are happy to share so we can discuss things."
"I'm not here for discussion. I'm here for the religious exemption to vaccination waiver."
"It's my job to talk to you about these things. Have you educated yourself at all???"
"Yes"
"And how do you plan to care for your children??? These are life threatening diseases!!!"
"Riding in a car is also life threatening. I've weighed the risks & benefits of that & I allow my children to ride in the car. That's not at issue here. I'm making this decision for my family. I object vaccinating for religious reasons."
"This is such a shame"
(Much paper shuffling & head shaking & looks of disappointment & disapproval) "Such a shame........ Of course, you know I disagree........ "
She asked me to spell out everything & asked for the SSN of my first son. I told her I didn't have it. She said she didn't think she could give me the form without it. I assured her that she could. She called someone to ask, and luckily the person was only one office away & I could hear her answer in real time. Then she said she only had one form and she didn't know I needed two like that was the last one in the building. I told her I was sure they had another one in the front. She went & got it. I took the forms walked to the front (she had to go around a corner to stamp one) She walked back out, into the waiting area full of patients and said very loudly "I hope you don't have to regret this" while shaking her head. I said "Oh, I won't" and she said "What a shame"

I am absolutely INFURIATED that this woman who works for my government that was FOUNDED on the principal of religious freedom, not only disregarded my faith, but did so openly, vehemently, and in front of other patients/clients/employees of the health department. She doesn't have to agree with me, but the law grants me certain rights & protections, and I feel that they were seriously violated by a woman who prides herself on regularly & repeatedly breaking the law - THEN TELLING PEOPLE THAT SHE DOES. I can not even begin to express my anger that I was told by a healthcare worker that my religious beliefs are shameful and that I should have the common sense to REGRET them!!!!!!! She has done this to others, and I was expecting a bit of contention, but I was not expecting to be treated with such disregard by a woman whose paycheck is written with my tax dollars. I expect more from my government & I want her to be held accountable.

I have filed a harrassement complaint with 909shot.com and I will be filing them anywhere else that I can. If you have a pointer, send it on. I contacted my attorney too. I'm not letting this drop.
post #2 of 22
This is from the Florida Health Department:

Office of the General Counsel
Provide legal representation for the Department of Health; provide training, oversight and coordination for the Department’s health attorneys throughout the state; prepare General Counsel opinions; coordinate risk management referrals, legal assignments and legal representation for all of the Department of Health’s programs and health departments; assure timely and accurate responses to legal issues facing the Department.


http://esetappsdoh.doh.state.fl.us/c...eral%20Counsel

Above is a link to a complaint form directly to the actual attorneys for the Florida Department of Health. If you give us the name of the woman you dealt with, we can coordinate an effective email campaign. This may actually produce quicker results than hiring an attorney - and it's cheaper.

This woman (and others like her) need to be replaced immediately and every county needs to "re-trained."

Your name doesn't need to be specifically referenced b/c I'm sure you're not the first, nor the last person who will experience this sort of harassment. I'm sure the county dept. has received complaints about her, but I'll bet anything no complaint has gone past her supervisor.

An email campaign/protest to the legal department --- now that's a different story. They will speak with her - no doubt about it. Unless someone has filed a recent lawsuit, the legal dept. probably has no idea this is happening. We can generate hundreds of email complaints to them.

Would you consider letting us help you? Do you remember the Call the White House Day a few months back? Can you imagine the attorneys getting emails from across the nation from hundreds of concerned parents looking to move to Florida! They would literally fall out of their chairs.

My "innocently offbeat", but makes-the-point-loud-and-clear email could go something like this:

I'm looking to move to Pasco County in the future. Would you please explain to me what is legally required in order to obtain a religious exemption from immunization in Florida? I have just a few concerns and wanted to get some clarification.

It is my understanding that Ms. ___________, [title], at the Pasco County Dept. of Health has taken it upon herself to hold inquisitions into the religious beliefs and medical decisions of parents seeking to obtain an exemption from immunization.

I've heard that prior to executing the exemption from immunization, Ms. ________ routinely (i) urges parents to discuss with her why they are seeking an exemption from immunization, (ii) requests parents seeking exemptions to disclose their religious denomination as well as their child's private medical information and (iii) makes derogatory comments with respect to the parental decision to withhold immunizations.

Do you know if this is true?

I also wanted to know - since I'm not really all that legal savvy - if it's illegal to bring a very concealed recording device into Ms. ________'s interrogations and tape record our conversation in case I feel my rights may be violated. If it is legal, would it be o.k if I tell all my other Florida friends to tape record their conversations as well? Thank you so much for your assistance.
post #3 of 22
Amanda,

I'm SO glad you are going to file harassment on this person. Some heads need to roll on this.


I about died when I read this:

Quote:
"Actually, you know full well it is. Would you like a copy of the current case law? I brought you one."
"Not particularly"
I wonder what she would have done if you had a tape recorder and pressed record in front of her and asked her to repeat her answer to the quote above.

I'm sorry you had to go through this.


Sherra
post #4 of 22
Thread Starter 
Judith McKay, RN. You can use my name too if that would help.
post #5 of 22
Thread Starter 
I'll work today on getting the names of other people this has happened to. I know of 2 people off the top of my head, although one had a different nurse with similar results. The other was denied an exemption as she stated her religious affiliation and the nurse told her that she knoys XYZists DO vaccinate.

There are 2 non vaxers at my sons school, so I'll check with them. I teach art there, so I my slip a note into the folder of the one child to have the mom call me. I'll ask her how her visit went & if she has heard of this happening to any of her friends. Her husband is a local chiro, and I have heard they also have a religious objection to vaccinating. I imagine that they have friends/associates who have had need of an exemption. I doubt anyone's had a pleasant experience. I was saying to my girlfriend that I have never had to be that blunt & unmovable before. It's not easy to sit there and offend & correct someone who is going out of their way to intimidate you.
post #6 of 22
Thread Starter 
I was just looking at the actual exemption form & it says in bold:
Child's SS# (OPTIONAL)

Guess that was confusing to her. :LOL
post #7 of 22
//
post #8 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmandaBL
I'll work today on getting the names of other people this has happened to. I know of 2 people off the top of my head, although one had a different nurse with similar results. The other was denied an exemption as she stated her religious affiliation and the nurse told her that she knoys XYZists DO vaccinate.
You should give all those you know who were affected (or have the potential to be affected) the link to the email complaint form so they can relay their personal experiences directly to the General Counsel. Unless you definitely plan on hiring an attorney and filing a lawsuit, this is the best course of action.

Receiving written "clarification" from the legal department is priceless. They would have to respond to your inquiry. Before they respond to an inquiry such as this, they would have to do some sort of "investigation" -- meaning they're definitely not going to respond w/o speaking with Nurse Ratchet first.

In the "Contact Us" section, there are other people that can be cc'd as well. Here's a link to all the persons involved with the immunization division (emails included): http://www.doh.state.fl.us/disease_c...ontact_boi.htm

Since I'm thinking of moving to Florida and I have a school age child, I have an interest - so I'll be emailing a few people at the Florida Department of Health right away in order to get some clarification.
post #9 of 22
Wow, she sounds like a real peach of a woman. I loved how you wouldnt discuss it with her, its NONE of her business! Good for you for filing a complaint.
post #10 of 22

just wanted to say

way to go!
you're doing a great job. thank you for not being silent.
post #11 of 22
Good for you going in there armed with the correct info! And also for not letting this woman get away with it!!

I'm also in Florida, Broward County, and was given a hard time when we went to get our religious exemption. DH called the health department and they stated that we HAD to sit through a meeting with an RN to discuss the issue. Luckily, we were armed with the laws and he told them that legally they had to give us the exemption "no questions asked". Looks like Florida likes to harrass parents .
post #12 of 22
Thread Starter 
File the complaint with KNOW florida. That lady has all the good contact info! PM me & I'l give you her email if you haven't done it already.
post #13 of 22
AmandaBL - For your information and also for your to pass on to K.N.O.W.


This email is in response to your October 6th, 2005 inquiry regarding the religious immunization exemption process in Florida. Thank you for contacting the Florida Department of Health Bureau of Immunization and taking the time to write. The following information should assist you.

Section 1003.22 Florida Statute requires immunization for school entry and attendance and allows for medical or religious exemption from immunizations. Only the county health department (CHD) issues an exemption from immunization for religious beliefs. The DH 681 Religious Exemption From Immunization form is completed/signed at the county health department. This form is not available on the internet and cannot be faxed or mailed to you. Florida does not provide an exemption from immunization for personal or philosophical reasons. The statute is accessible at the following link: http://www.flsenate.gov/Statutes/ind...1003/Sec22.HTM

I recommend that you call the Pasco County Health Department at: (727) 869-3900 to arrange for the exemption. Please verify clinic locations and whether an appointment is necessary to obtain the DH 681 Religious Exemption From Immunization form. Upon review, a completed Florida DH 681 Religious Exemption From Immunization form is provided for a childcare center or school. Be sure to ask for the immunization supervisor and indicate that your call is regarding the DH 681 Religious Exemption form. Florida county health department telephone numbers can be found at the Department of Health Internet address at http://www.doh.state.fl.us/chdsitelist.htm

I apologize for any inconvenience experienced by your friend and encourage you to direct your friend to the Pasco CHD nursing director. The Nursing Director, Ms. Cummins is happy to assist your friend and respond to the concerns cited below. You may contact Ms. Cummins directly at: (727) 869-3900 x107.

Finally, you asked about a concealed recording device. I am not an attorney, nor am I permitted to offer legal advise. I recommend that you seek appropriate counsel for legal inquiries. Please note that Chapter 934 of the Florida Statutes addresses "Security of Communications." See ss. 934.03-934.09 for additional details. You may access the statutes online at: http://www.leg.state.fl.us/Statutes/...934/ch0934.htm

The Bureau of Immunization has field representatives assigned to each county. The contact list is found at: http://www.immunizeflorida.org/root/contact.htm . Additionally, the Florida Department of Health and the Centers for Disease Control [CDC] Web pages offers valuable immunization information about immunization schedules and vaccine safety at:
http://www.cdc.gov/nip/vacsafe/conce...f-interest.htm
http://www.immunizeflorida.com/root/faq.htm

I hope this information is helpful regarding the current Florida immunization religious exemption process. The Bureau welcomes you to the sunshine state and Pasco County.

Respectfully,
Vivienne Treharne, RNC, BSN

Community Health Nursing Consultant
Bureau of Immunization
2585 Merchants Row Blvd. Room 210H (Bin A-11)
Tallahassee, Fl. 32399-1719
850-245-4444 ext. 2384
Fax: 850-922-4195
www.ImmunizeFlorida.org

****************************
This is in response to your e-mail inquiry regarding the required immunization documentation for entry/attendance in Florida schools. One of our nurse consultants has also replied to your e-mail addressed to our zzzz Feedback, HSD_Immunization site. I am confident her information has answered your questions and has also provided a contact with the Pasco County Health Department.

While the application process appears to set up barriers, certain minimal notification has to be provided to parents in order to protect both children holding exemptions in addition to the other children in the classroom. As public health practitioners, the staff must counsel anyone who is holding any type of immunization exemption for specific communicable diseases in the event there is a communicable disease in the classroom. As cited in statute: if there are any cases of a communicable diseases for which immunization is required in the school, any child who has no proof of immunity will be temporarily excluded.

Please call if I have not answered your questions.

Phyllis Yambor
Executive Community Health Nursing Director
Bureau of Immunization
Division of Disease Control
Florida Department of Health
(850)- 245-4444 Ext. 2385
post #14 of 22
You seemed to have handled yourself sooo well under those conditions. Bravo to you!!!
I'm sure there is also a way to make a complaint about your privacy being violated through the FL dept of health -- maters discussed in private should not have been brought out into the waiting room where others could hear PERIOD.
Don't let it go until it's handled, an apology would be nice.

Man, VA was so easy -- form on-line, took to the bank where we bank and had one notarized for each child. I feel very fortunate at this moment.

I am sorry you had to go through all of that, but really you did a super job of not discussing what isn't an issue to discuss with THEM.
post #15 of 22
Thread Starter 

you guys are awesome

I'll keep you posted. I get pissed just thinking about it. I also have a heck of a time comming up with things I could have said. Probably good that I stuck to the facts & didn't.... um..... embelish. :LOL I wish I'd have had a recorder.
post #16 of 22
Mouth falling open here.... :
Oh my goodness!!!! I am sorry mama...Good for you for keeping your cool!!!
I am also glad to hear that you filed a complaint!
post #17 of 22
Long Island..are you going to follow up? It doesn't sound to me like there is going to be any inquiry into how the woman acted and they later state that such inquiry is necessary (what you bolded). I hope all the Florida mamas who are looking for exemptions read this thread and follow what AmandaBl did by not embelishing.
post #18 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by theatremum
Long Island..are you going to follow up? It doesn't sound to me like there is going to be any inquiry into how the woman acted and they later state that such inquiry is necessary (what you bolded). I hope all the Florida mamas who are looking for exemptions read this thread and follow what AmandaBl did by not embelishing.
Not unless Amanda requests, but I really wanted her to be able to get an idea what their reasoning is behind this "consultation" before she took it any further, especially if she wants to sue. As enforcers of public health law, they feel there is a compelling state interest to "counsel" parents before an exemption is granted. The problem with this? It appears they are using this "counseling" session as a means of discouraging parents from excercising their rights.

In order for them to look into Nurse Ratchet's mode of consulation, the OP will need to make a formal complaint with them. Hopefully, something will come of it, but I think the only way to ultimately put a stop these "consultations" would be a lawsuit.
post #19 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmandaBL
I was just looking at the actual exemption form & it says in bold:
Child's SS# (OPTIONAL)

Guess that was confusing to her. :LOL
Well it is a big word..... :LOL

Sorry you were harrassed. I'm glad you aren't letting it drop.
post #20 of 22
Thread Starter 
The lady from KNOW sent me the contact info for a woman they work with at the Bureau of immunization. I'm waiting to hear what my lawyer says first. I don't really want to muddy the water for him. I will keep you all posted for sure! Thanks for your info LongIsland - I'll pass it on. I agree that a deluge of emails might be most effective.... I'll update soon.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Vaccinations
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › The Pasco County FL health department in Zephyrhills SUCKS!