Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › What is Respect? (spin off)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What is Respect? (spin off)  

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I consider Respect, "treating people as they wish to be treated". So, for children to be treated with respect, I believe they need to be treated in the manner they wish to be treated. Just as if my dear old grandmother wishes to have the door held open for her (or addressed as "Yes, Ma'am"), I am treating her with respect when I do so. I help our son to understand how others wish to be treated by giving information about social and cultural conventions, gently pointing out other's non-verbal cues (if missed) and discussing Respect as 'how he and other's wish (or object) to be treated'. In our family, there is no compulsion to treat others with Respect; I believe respect is authentic when freely given. Not mandated. And I work hard at modelling respect of our son and others. He is learning Respect by experiencing and observing it.

What do you consider Respect? And how do you convey the concept of Respect to your children?

Pat
post #2 of 5
Well, my daughter is still too young yet to talk to and interact with verbally (on her part anyway), but we already model respect. Respect to me, is basically what you said, treating people how they (or you would) like to be treated as it relates to kindess, decency, treating someone as an equal to you regardless of age, race, sexual preference, education level etc. In simple terms, treating human beings as they have as much right to exsist and as much of a right to their choices, body, opinions, and preferences as you do.

How we model this with our daughter is basic for now. She is at the age where the only strong cue that she doesn't feel good or is not happy is by her body language, and by crying. Sometimes when I am changing her clothes for instance, she gets upset. I immediately stop what I am doing the minute she cries. She sees me stopping the action that for whatever reason is making her upset, and that is how I show her respect. Usually in a matter of seconds, she chills out and I continue to dress her.

The same with her car seat. Man, she did not dig that thing in the beginning. In the beginning, we stopped the car every single time she cried. Sometimes we would have to pull off and stop 5 times on our way home from a 10 minute trip. Yeah, it was annoying, but every time she cried, we did it, consistantly, and comforted her until she was calm. The result of that is that gradually we only had to stop 4 times, then 3, then 2, then 1, now we never have to stop, as she never gets upset in her seat anymore. I feel a lot of that has to do with the security she feels now that if something was *really* upsetting or wrong with her, she knows we would stop.

Some people might think our child is "ruling" us. I don't at all. If I were upset about something and didn't have the words to express it and someone completely ignored me, that would hurt. I give her the same respect I would expect from anyone that claims to truly care for me.

I think the greatest respect one can have though, is for themselves. To me, if you respect yourself, there is little room for acting out. If you are confident in your choices, your moral character, secure in yourself and your worth, you will most likely project that in your every day dealings with other people, thus showing them respect in return.

In a family dynamic, I think it is hard to teach a child respect for themselves and for others when the people who are supposed to love them the most wield their power over them for no other reason than the fact that the children are smaller and are "their" children...as if they were property. Even if done in a pleasant way, children still know who holds the power in the relationship, who makes the choices, who runs the show, who determines the course of their young lives -- and to me, it is not consistent with mutual respect if one person has all the power over another.

When reflecting and deciding how I want to be with my daughter, I only have to look as far as myself and the people around me. Most human beings, other than our unique idiosyncricies (sp?) are pretty much alike. I have resented almost everyone in my life who has taken pleasure in making it known to me that they are "the boss". On the other side though, I have tremendously respected, valued, and cherished the relationships I have developed with people who, although may have held a higher "rank" than me (boss, teacher, whatever), still treated me as an equal and used their position to act as a source of guidance and assistance rather than an "authority" figure.
post #3 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by captain crunchy
The same with her car seat. Man, she did not dig that thing in the beginning. In the beginning, we stopped the car every single time she cried. Sometimes we would have to pull off and stop 5 times on our way home from a 10 minute trip. Yeah, it was annoying, but every time she cried, we did it, consistantly, and comforted her until she was calm. The result of that is that gradually we only had to stop 4 times, then 3, then 2, then 1, now we never have to stop, as she never gets upset in her seat anymore. I feel a lot of that has to do with the security she feels now that if something was *really* upsetting or wrong with her, she knows we would stop.
Just wanted to add, I think, as the OP said, there's also an element of taking into account individual preferences. Generally, ds didn't have a huge issue with the car, but sometimes he did get upset with car rides when he was very small. We tried stopping each time, taking him out, nursing and soothing until he was calm, and then starting again. What happened for us was that he got progressively more and more upset, because he didn't want to get a brief break. He wanted to be home and *completely* finished with the car ride. For him, all those little breaks seemed to feel like we were teasing him with brief tastes of what he wanted. We eventually discovered that he coped better if we just continued on our way, with me in the backseat with him if dh was with us, and lots of singing and talking to him the whole time. Of course, if we passed a house with a For Sale sign, I had a moment of thinking, "Hmm, maybe we should just buy it, and then we'd be home already!" So, just as one mom wants children to call her "Mrs. Lastname" to show respect while that wouldn't really do anything for me, I think our kids have varying preferences as to how they want their needs met, too.
post #4 of 5
I have taught my children that they need to treat their teachers and other adults respectfully but that whether or not they actually have respect for them is up to my children.

I have taught them that a person can be treated with respect because of their position. But that we do not actually have to feel respect for that person unless that person earned it.

So my dd's understand they have to be polite and obediant with their teachers ( as long as they don't feel that their requests endanger them in any way, in which case they are to respectfully say "no way") , but that they are free to come home and complain about how awful that teacher is, make up rude nicknames for the teacher we use only at home etc....



My dd's get this and enjoy the private disdain we have for certain people while giving them the respectful treatment that their position accords them.
post #5 of 5
I think it's possible to have respectful boundaries. I don't feel it is disrespectful to my dd to refuse her something, or not allow her to do something. However, I could be disrespectful about it, and I know lots of parents are.

I'm not convinced that it's disrespectful to not completely stop what you're doing even if your dc is crying. Sometimes at night my ds is crying while my dh puts his jammies on, but he is because he's hungry and tired, and he can't go to sleep w/out his jammies and diaper on. Not in our frosty house, at least. So while my dh is empathetic and makes faces and tries to get him to stop crying, I think stopping and prolonging the experience would be worse.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › What is Respect? (spin off)