or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Childhood and Beyond › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Nanny 911 Homeschooling family *tonight*! 12/19
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nanny 911 Homeschooling family *tonight*! 12/19

post #1 of 130
Thread Starter 
On 12/19 Nanny 911 is going to feature a homeschooling mom of 6 (I think?). I just hope Nanny won't be talking them into putting them in school. On the preview she said something like, "And she's so overprotective of them that she schools them at home." Let's see what happens . . . :

http://www.fox.com/nanny911/
post #2 of 130
oh goody. Another yelling screaming disorganized homeschooling family that treats their children poorly. Of course hs'ing is at the root. No doubt they family will see the light and begin to public school.

oh gag.
post #3 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jen123
oh goody. Another yelling screaming disorganized homeschooling family that treats their children poorly. Of course hs'ing is at the root. No doubt they family will see the light and begin to public school.

oh gag.

click on the link and watch the preview, I didn't see any yelling
post #4 of 130
Dern. The video wouldn't play for me. I can only imagine how the show will go though.
post #5 of 130
"when most parents breathe a sigh of relief that they've shuffled their kids out the door and onto the school bus, Vicki is just getting started setting up lesson plans in the living room"

Gag me with an eraser! I feel sorry for the parents who "breathe a sigh of relief"

That is so horrible!

And in that video, there was the mom sitting there saying that school is a dangerous place, and then they flash over to the boys fighting. ARG! I wonder how many parents were considering homeschooling and now won't.

I hope that they don't make homeschooling to be this horrible thing that scares parents away.

Olivia
post #6 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by wynkenblynken&nod
"when most parents breathe a sigh of relief that they've shuffled their kids out the door and onto the school bus, Vicki is just getting started setting up lesson plans in the living room"

Gag me with an eraser! I feel sorry for the parents who "breathe a sigh of relief"

That is so horrible!

And in that video, there was the mom sitting there saying that school is a dangerous place, and then they flash over to the boys fighting.
Oh, but hey! Maybe Nanny will tell Vicki all about unschooling, and when she gives it a whirl, the kids won't have so much reason to act out!


Sorry! I just couldn't resist! The whole thing makes me want to find something to laugh about - I almost don't even want to see it... It's hard to understand how those parents could allow this to happen...
- Lillian
post #7 of 130
WHY would a family who has chosen to homeschool anyway, want to bring in "an authority" on how best to raise children?

Much less on national TV?

This is fishy. And I agree, it smells like a setup!
post #8 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfmeis
WHY would a family who has chosen to homeschool anyway, want to bring in "an authority" on how best to raise children?

Much less on national TV?

This is fishy. And I agree, it smells like a setup!
Well, this probably isn't very kind - but who knows what their motivations for homeschooling are? Maybe they're people who didn't have a good sense of how to go about homeschooling in the first place. Maybe they just fell into it and have been struggling with it. Maybe they've had problems with effective parenting all along. Maybe they're in overwhelm with all those kids so close to the same age, and they've grown up in the habit of turning to authority figures when they're in a pinch, but they simply don't see the public schools as real authority figures. A part of me wants to tune in and see what image is being put out there to the public, but a part of me doesn't even want to be subjected to it. One thing about it - people would be pretty silly to think that family represents homeschooling anymore than the other families who appear on it represent public schooling. - Lillian
post #9 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfmeis
WHY would a family who has chosen to homeschool anyway, want to bring in "an authority" on how best to raise children?

Much less on national TV?

This is fishy. And I agree, it smells like a setup!
I totally agree!
post #10 of 130
I'm SO glad my ILs don't get cable.

Not that they would watch Nanny 911 if they did, but they just might tune in to see a hsing family. That's probably what is more dangerous -- not potential hsers being turned off of it, but extended family (or reluctant SOs) being turned against it.

My dh was at his parents' place for a couple of days this weekend, and apparently hs came up. He's a great guy, not really sold on homeschooling, but he defended it the best he could. And his parents are really great ILs, they are just concerned, and while they are too polite to bring it up with me around, they were probably asking him some pointed questions.
post #11 of 130
Ooh, I watched the video and she also breastfeeds. Woder if the'll say anything about that. I'm pretty sure the nursling was over 6 mos.
post #12 of 130
It seems like alot of these nanny shows feature largish type families that can't keep the kids "under control". Now they are adding homeschooling into it. I'm a little nervous about it. I don't generally watch TV but am hoping to catch this episode. What channel and time is it?
post #13 of 130
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ekblad8
It seems like alot of these nanny shows feature largish type families that can't keep the kids "under control". Now they are adding homeschooling into it. I'm a little nervous about it. I don't generally watch TV but am hoping to catch this episode. What channel and time is it?

It's on Fox and it shows at 8PM my time. Check your local listings.
post #14 of 130
I thought it boded ill that the dad was saying something like, "She didn't ask me how I felt about homeschooling, she said 'I'm homeschooling.'"

I hope it doesn't turn into unreasonable (homeschooling) mom versus reasonable (send them to school) dad.

Namaste!
post #15 of 130
Well, given that the nanny shows are vehemently anti-AP I'm not surprised to see that the next 'over-controlling, unhealthy co-dependence promoting' parental choice on their target agenda is homeschooling.
post #16 of 130
//
post #17 of 130
Fwiw, I don't totally hate all of this nanny's advice. I hate the naughty corner and I hate her bedtime rules, but I think in general she gives gentler, more consistent tools to people who are otherwise way too clueless to even know where to start. These parents would otherwise be really demeaning and awful, and the nanny doesn't tolerate that from the parents.

So, anyway, I think the hsing episode will suck. Nanny is pretty focused on independence and I'm not sure I want to watch.
post #18 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by benjalo
Fwiw, I don't totally hate all of this nanny's advice. I hate the naughty corner and I hate her bedtime rules, but I think in general she gives gentler, more consistent tools to people who are otherwise way too clueless to even know where to start. These parents would otherwise be really demeaning and awful, and the nanny doesn't tolerate that from the parents.

So, anyway, I think the hsing episode will suck. Nanny is pretty focused on independence and I'm not sure I want to watch.

I think you may be thinking of Supernanny. This one is Nanny 911 when they pick one of three nannies to go to the chosen house.

I'm interested in seeing the episode just to see how they handle it. For those who don't normally watch, it's on Monday night on Fox.
post #19 of 130
oh, yea, that could be. It's that same one, Jo, or whatever. Is Nanny 911 worse than her?
post #20 of 130
Quote:
Originally Posted by benjalo
oh, yea, that could be. It's that same one, Jo, or whatever. Is Nanny 911 worse than her?

Jo seems to have a more laid back approach where the nannies on 911 are more stern and to the point. Kwim? Jo gives constructive critisism (sp) (ie: here's where it's going wrong-this is how you fix it-warm hug when accomplished) where the others seem to lay out the rules and roll their eyes when things don't go according to plan. They do get the job done, I just don't like how they handle themselves.

As I'm sure you can tell, I like Jo so much more than the others.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Childhood and Beyond › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Nanny 911 Homeschooling family *tonight*! 12/19