or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Childhood and Beyond › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe (The Movie)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe (The Movie)

post #1 of 50
Thread Starter 
I have (2) 5 1/2 year old children whom I homeschool. We just finished reading The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe and yesterday we went and saw the movie. I just wanted to share with you that it was a great movie--with absolutely incredible special effects--but very intense. I think it was a bit too much for kids my children's age. Luckily, after reading the book, they knew what to expect, so they weren't freaked out as much as they could have been. I think the movie is probably more appropriate for kids 7 - 8 years and older.
post #2 of 50
I have to agree. I saw it first thankfully with my husband so when we took the kids I was prepared to pull out my son for the taunting and killing of the lion. So fantastic though huh?
post #3 of 50
We took ds to see it the day it came out. We'd managed to read the entire Chronicles of Narnia series aloud at bedtime over the summer, so ds knew what it would be about. He loved it. Dh and I loved it. The sacrifice of Aslan was hard to watch, but it was important to the story.
post #4 of 50
Good to know. We are reading the book right now, and dh wants to take dd to see it. Gonna have to think about that.....
post #5 of 50
I took my 5yo and I would say that she was okay with it, but a more sensitive child may not be. She likes to watch surgeries on TV and has watched graphic birth videos so she can handle a lot. I agree though, about the part where they taunted the lion. I was also about to pull her out.
post #6 of 50

My reviews...

I think this version is pretty much spoiler free.

I was a bit disappointed. *ducks flying debris*

It wasn't bad! I'll totally get it on DVD. But, I went into it expecting to come out of it saying, "WOW! I wanna see it AGAIN!" I didn't.

There were a few changes from the book that weren't necessary to make the transition to film, which I felt actually detracted from the story, and the special effects weren't as special as I thought they were going to be.

The actors, however, were phenomenal! That's not clear enough. They were amazing, astounding, extraordinary, fantastic, marvelous, outstanding, remarkable, sensational, and wondrous. Even in the worst of the scenes, it wasn't the child actors who couldn't pull it off. They were 100% believable every step of the way. They perfected every head tilt and blink. They had inflection mastered in a way that puts to shame some overpaid adult actors (*cough* Cruise *cough*).

I still don't buy Liam Neeson as Aslan. I understand that James Earl Jones is over used in that type of role, but Neeson just doesn't scream "God's animagus" to me.

But, even with all that, I did enjoy it, and I will buy it on DVD, and my kids will watch it 100 times at LEAST, and I'll probably watch it a few times with them.

For the more detailed version, click here ---> WARNING, CONTAINS SPOILERS!!!.

ETA: Both my 7 & 5 year olds went with me. My 5 year old said that she had to close her eyes once, but that it wasn't a "scary movie." 7 year old was 100% fine.
post #7 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by UlrikeDG
There were a few changes from the book that weren't necessary to make the transition to film, which I felt actually detracted from the story...
Can you say what they were without ruining it for people who haven't seen it yet? I saw it and couldn't remember all the details. I'd love to know what was changed.

I had mixed feelings - absolutely loved a lot of it, especially the visual perfection - and the children were everything you said - perfect! - but I felt a lot was lost when the book was simplified to a movie. I think those of us who loved the books probabably mentally add a lot of what we already know as we watch it - but I can see from some of the reviews that a lot was missed, simply because so much in the way of dialogue and thinking had to be left out. I have to wonder if Lewis' books are going to be oversimplified in the public's mind now by all those who will be seeing the movies but not reading the books - I've already seen some pretty stupid things in reviews. Thank heaven for those incredible child actors, though - what lovely role models.

Another thing my son pointed out was that Aslan's lips didn't move in the old English version - he was heard in their minds - which, for some of us, probably worked a lot better. I didn't particulary care for this Aslan at all - but maybe that has to do with the actor who played his voice (?)...

I found something oversimplified about the whole thing, but maybe that's because I loved the books so much.

Funny thing about the children is that some critic(s) complained that they should have spoken like contemporary American children! Can you just IMAGINE?!!! - Lillian
post #8 of 50
I LOVED this movie!! I took my 11yo and my 9yo to see it- the 4yo stayed home.

I read the book a few months ago and I thought the movie was pretty true to the book (except for the opening scene, which wasn't in the book but gives modern audiences some background.) Should somebody start a new thread with spoilers to discuss the specifics? I'd like to hear what you think was changed from the book.
post #9 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lillian J
Can you say what they were without ruining it for people who haven't seen it yet? I saw it and couldn't remember all the details. I'd love to know what was changed.
The major one was the waterfall scene. There were a few other ones, but it has been two weeks since I've seen it, and the details aren't as fresh in my mind.
post #10 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by UlrikeDG
The major one was the waterfall scene. There were a few other ones, but it has been two weeks since I've seen it, and the details aren't as fresh in my mind.
Well, I had to go read your blog about it - and the other review you linked to. They were very helpful. No wonder I came away from it with the feeling that something was off. There were a lot of things off, and I wasn't alone in that perception - I just didn't remember the original details the way others did. It was really beautiful, though - it just didn't come through with the kind of depth that could have made a lot more sense out of it all (especially the Aslan part) for someone who hadn't read the books. I must say I dread seeing the plastic Narnia toys and video games come along...- Lillian
post #11 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lillian J
I must say I dread seeing the plastic Narnia toys and video games come along...- Lillian[/COLOR]

Me too Lillian. It takes the magic out of it when it goes commercial.
post #12 of 50
Do you all know that there is a BBC version of the movie? My kids have seen that several times. My 5 year old was telling everyone what was going to happen next. She picked out a few errors. Plus we have read/listen to them book a couple of time. I think she remembers it better than me.
post #13 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marsupialmom
Do you all know that there is a BBC version of the movie? My kids have seen that several times.
My ILs got the set of BBC Narnia movies for Roman last Christmas. He's watched them a LOT since then. I wasn't going to take Eva to the new Narnia movie, because she really didn't like the BBC version too much, but she saw me watching the trailers online, and asked to go, and she enjoyed it.
post #14 of 50
I'll be the lone voice here, but I have to say it....we didn't care much for the movie. My 5 y/o liked it, but my 10 y/o and I left the theater for the Aslan scene. It was terribly sad and frightening!! I still can't believe that was in a (marketed) children's movie.

Overall, I was disappointed. I felt it moved quickly and and many of the nuances and relationships didn't translate on film. I really liked the Lucy and Mr. Tumnus scenes, the performance by the White Witch and the winter backdrop scenery.
post #15 of 50
DH and I saw the movie last night. I read the book ages ago (when I was around 11 or 12 probably). I barely remember the book -- it didn't make much of an impression on me for some reason. So I wasn't super gung-ho about seeing the movie. Unlike UlrikeDG, I was very pleasantly surprised! (Admitedly, I had pretty low expectations. ) Not remembering the book much, I wasn't really aware of what was different, but I thought it worked as a movie. I also thought the animal effects were excellent, although Lillian, I had forgotten that they heard Aslan's voice in their minds -- what in interesting (and potentially important) distinction!

I would never take my 5 y.o. dd to this film. She is very sensitive to any hint of scary-ness. She would have been making for the exit in the very first scene! It will be a long time before my kids see this movie. There were some super young kids (preschoolers) in the audience, which made me kind of uncomfortable. I felt bad for them being subjected to the more violent scenes in the movie, even if they could "handle it". Why should they *have* to handle such violent images at that age?

My only discomfort with the story (movie and book) is the glorification of warfare. I don't mind it as a story element -- it adds excitement and supense. But this is supposed to be a Christian allegory, and it made me uncomfortable in that respect. I understand that the battle could be a symbol for spiritual struggle, and the only humans involved were the children and perhaps the witch, who was at least "humaniod". Nevertheless, I was uncomfortable with the "holy war" feeling that came across -- that there was one side that was pure good ("our" side) and one side that was pure evil ("their side"). I don't think the image of war as good has a place in Christainity as I interpret it. That's my only gripe. I really did love the movie as a movie.
post #16 of 50
I've seen it twice. Loved it. Most of my church family has seen it also.

Allow me to ask a question.....

CSLewis wrote the series as an allegory to Christianity. I went last night to see the movie again with a lady who is not a Christian. She really wanted to see the movie. When it was over I asked her " do you think that was a Christian movie?" and she said she didn't think it was , but it could be if you looked for it.

Thoughts?
post #17 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by luv my 2 sweeties
I also thought the animal effects were excellent, although Lillian, I had forgotten that they heard Aslan's voice in their minds -- what in interesting (and potentially important) distinction!
Actually, I don't think that was the case in the books - it was just the way it was done in the BBC version. Funny thing is, I didn't realize what all was bothering me about Aslan in this movie until my son mentioned the lips - he hasn't seen it yet but had noticed that during the trailers.

Quote:
My only discomfort with the story (movie and book) is the glorification of warfare. I don't mind it as a story element -- it adds excitement and supense. But this is supposed to be a Christian allegory, and it made me uncomfortable in that respect. I understand that the battle could be a symbol for spiritual struggle, and the only humans involved were the children and perhaps the witch, who was at least "humaniod". Nevertheless, I was uncomfortable with the "holy war" feeling that came across -- that there was one side that was pure good ("our" side) and one side that was pure evil ("their side"). I don't think the image of war as good has a place in Christainity as I interpret it.
That was one of the things that, to me, came across differently in the film. In the books, there was just something very different about the battles. The courage and ability to find one's own strength when standing up for good was what came out in the books. Funny thing is, I didn't even get the Christian allegory when I read the books to my son! But I felt it was exaggerated in the movie to the point of over-simplifying the heart of it, if that makes sense... I think there have been precious few movies that have been able to really capture a book. - Lillian
post #18 of 50
We took dd today, and we all loved it. Conveniently, dd needed to use the potty during the Aslan scene. Perfect! I was worried about that--and she missed it all
None of the rest was too scary for her, although we did just read the book this week (so she knew pretty much what to expect)
post #19 of 50
I liked it but it was not as good as I was hoping. I like that they left it bloodless. My 5 yo held her hands close to her eyes, ready to cover, but never did. but she was very familiar witht he story.

the kids were great, the witch was perefct! I htought Aslan could have been more grand. over all it lacked grandness and i think the extra scenes were a waste of time that could have been better spent on stuff that was actually in the book. I think it could have had a better score.

but it was good. my kids know the story so weren't overwhelmed by it.
post #20 of 50
I thought the violence was just too much, and went on and on and on.

Really, I thought the rating should be PG 13, with how the violence was.

They had a technicality of not using fake blood though, so I assume that's how they got away with it. That was kind of stupid itself though. You see all this horrific violence, killing, a war with swords and what-not, and not one drop of blood on a sword that has killed many creatures.

So the fake blood is worse than the potrayal of the act of killing?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Childhood and Beyond › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe (The Movie)