Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I'm not feeling very gentle right now...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I'm not feeling very gentle right now...  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
*sigh* I'll try to make this brief.

For the last few weeks, DS (almost 5) has been telling DD (2.5) to do things that neither of them are supposed to do and DD thinks this is a hilarious new game. For example, throwing things in the house, banging on the walls, hardwood floors and furniture with toys, kitchen utensils, a flashlight, etc. causing damage. Ripping pages from magazines, hitting me, harrassing the cat, saying "Don't do xyz" that either I or DH has told her to do and that she would have otherwise done. And so on. After DD does whatever DS has told her to do, DS laughs and DD thinks that this is great fun.

FWIW DS did not come up with this on his own, last year at preschool a girl did this to him-- it took a few weeks but we did get him to understand that he was responsible for following our rules even if someone else told him differently. Well, this year, another girl, who DS thinks hung the moon, is doing the same thing -- telling him to do things that end with him getting in trouble. And NOW, at home he has started to do this with DD.

I was going to say that I'm at my wits end, but really, I don't have any wits left at all. I'm starting to feel not very gentle at all and I really don't want to feel this way. DH has really had it too and we've kinda lost the "one sane parent" safety valve we have been using to maintain GD.

Please, has anyone else dealt with this-- I really don't have any idea where to start on this one. Almost forgot to mention that DS has a 1- 2 year social delay otherwise he is extremely bright.

TIA - fizzymom
post #2 of 9
DS1, who is the same age as your son, does a similar thing with his brother who si 2. He will, for example, give him a toy and say "throw this across the room Sam". Then Sam will do it of course. I am in a similar state of wondering what in the heck to do! I hope someone has some great advice for us
post #3 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by fizzymom
For the last few weeks, DS (almost 5) has been telling DD (2.5) to do things that neither of them are supposed to do and DD thinks this is a hilarious new game.
Somehing similar happens in our family too. In fact, my dd1 (almost 5) and dd2 (3) whisper at each other or just look at each other in a special way and then they run off doing exactly the things you described, especially, emptying toys boxes on the floor or throwing water. They have been doing this for awhile now. What I do is I start reading out loud a book that they like without paying attention to what they do. Usually, they will join me... else I suggest a bath and I start running the water. They love being in the tub together. I try talking about it later but I get not much response. Fortunately, this has yet to happen when weare not at home. Good luck to you. It is sooo exasperating. Oh, and I wanted to add one more thing before you blame the preschool for this too much: mine really DID figure this out on their own...
post #4 of 9
Quote:
For the last few weeks, DS (almost 5) has been telling DD (2.5) to do things that neither of them are supposed to do and DD thinks this is a hilarious new game. For example, throwing things in the house, banging on the walls, hardwood floors and furniture with toys, kitchen utensils, a flashlight, etc. causing damage. Ripping pages from magazines, hitting me, harrassing the cat, saying "Don't do xyz" that either I or DH has told her to do and that she would have otherwise done. And so on. After DD does whatever DS has told her to do, DS laughs and DD thinks that this is great fun.
The best way to deal with a problem behavior is to try to get at the root cause. What does your son gain from this game? Behaviors like this could be attention-seeking, the result of boredom, or sibling rivalry (or a combination of issues). If DS is getting bored and looking for attention, one possible solution might be to keep the kids involved in more structured activities throughout the day. If DS is trying to get DD in trouble, maybe there are some sibling rivalry issues that need to be worked through (Siblings Without Rivalry is a good book, and the book Playful Parenting has a good chapter on playing your way through sibling rivalry).
post #5 of 9
I am dealing with this as well. I am also reading siblings w/o rivalry..just started it again..and trying to find new ways to deal with the challenges I face with my kids behavior and personalitys. Somedays are better than others.
post #6 of 9
I wonder if it might be a bonding thing, like we're doing this together, this game's only for us. I think the pps suggestions are great, starting an activity that might otherwise engage them sounds great.
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by gaialice
Oh, and I wanted to add one more thing before you blame the preschool for this too much: mine really DID figure this out on their own...
I really wasn't trying to place blame, though reading through my post again I can understand that interpretation. I was trying to indicate that we had been through it last year and were able to resolve it, but this time through we aren't getting anywhere.

I don't think it is a sibling rivalry issue because they get along very well for the most part and he is not acting like he is trying to get her in trouble-- it seems more like it is just a big game.

I need to think through some of the ideas here and I will get back tomorrow -- I'm having a hard time keeping my eyes open.

Many thanks - It helps to know I'm not the only one going through this.
post #8 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunnysideup
The best way to deal with a problem behavior is to try to get at the root cause. What does your son gain from this game? Behaviors like this could be attention-seeking, the result of boredom, or sibling rivalry (or a combination of issues).

i have been doing this. sometimes, afteror instead of addressing the behavior (which i shouldnt even do bc then i get upset and....yell)..... i will just sit with ds and talk ....... I talk about what is going on and what he is feeling and that I love him and need him to help me to teach dd how not to **** and that she loves him very much and that is why seh wants to be with him all the time and how that makes him feel.. .i think when its a rivalry thing, talking about how much dd loves him makes him feel all warm and fuzzy inside.... .. we have a lot of issues with teasing and would love some input on that. My dad is a teaser and hense, I tease a little, but my kids LOVE to tease each other. I just was talking to ds about when enough is enough.... he just goes to far... I have really been limiting my teasing bc I feel he just doesnt understand when it comes to teasing her... i know this is a whole 'nother thread... but I am curious as to how to handle this.....
post #9 of 9
This happens in our house to, but at bedtime when the lights are out nd my kids in bed. Ds who is 7 tells ds who is 4 to do x and then the little one does it. I find that ds who is 7 is often an instigator who tries to do things in a devious way so he does not get caught.

I'm open for suggestions as well. Oh and said dc sleep in bunk beds , my older ds sleeps in another room and cannot share a room.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I'm not feeling very gentle right now...