or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Work from Home Parents › My advertising results with Mothering
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My advertising results with Mothering

post #1 of 37
Thread Starter 
I bought a banner ad to promote my new cookbook and I wanted to share the results with you now that the campaign is over.

I bought 300,000 impressions for $140.00

I got 370 total clicks (around .12% click through rate)

From those clicks I got 3 sales. Around 1% conversion rate (normal and expected)

I was hoping for at least a 1% click through rate, which would have been 3,000 clicks, then with a 1% conversion rate it would have meant 30 sales.

3 sales at $20 = $60. Not enough to pay for the cost of the ad.

But 30 sales at $20 would have been $600 so the ad would have been worth it.

So that ad campaign was a loss for me. The click through rate on the banner ad is just not up to snuff.

However, the signature ad I purchased for $55 for 6 months has made me 10 times my investment. Which is why I've had a signature ad for well over a year now.

I'm wondering what results you guys are getting from your banner ads. Are your click through rates similar to the one I got of .12%?

In my experience of running my own magazine I know that discussion board ads don't get a high click through rate. Mothering should lower the cost for these ads considerably to take into account the low click through rate.

I also placed a similar ad on a Veggie Discussion board site and got even worse results, just 1 sale. But the cost of that ad was only $30. So I'm only out $10 instead of $80.

Do you know how effective your online advertising is? Are you losing money without realizing it?
post #2 of 37
Wow, thank you for sharing your statistics! It is very helpful to see/hear some hard numbers.

I don't have any statistics to share regarding banner advertising as I have not done any... but I will say that my signature, combined with contributing to the community that relates to my product line has absolutely helped to grow my business.

As a consumer, and contributor to various message boards I will say that after about 6 weeks of participation I become completely desensitized to the advertisements on any site. I can only imagine that most consumers are the same.

Thanks agian.
post #3 of 37
Thanks for the info! I haven't been a WAHM long enough to have stats for my advertising. But before I was a WAHM I wouldn't really notice banner ads, and if I did I rarely clicked to the site. I did click on lots of siggy ads though, because my eye naturally went past them as I was reading, and because I was curious to see each posters' sites. So I've started out with siggy ads, and plan to stick with those for a while, until business picks up.
post #4 of 37
Thanks for sharing, Erin. I was sitting on the fence about advertising here, but it is too much of a risk for me. You must have gotten in on the advertising prices before the change. As a first-time advertiser, 300,000 impressions would be $350. :
post #5 of 37
Thread Starter 
Now remember, though, my product is geared towards vegans for the most part. ONly 16% of the visitors at Mothering are vegan (according to an informal survey done a while back). You might have a product that appeals to 90% of the visitors here. Something to consider.

That's why I'm asking everyone else, what are your click through rates? Same as mine or better?

A good rule for determinign if an ad is worth it to you or not is the 1% rule. Take the number of impressions and divide it by 1%. That's how many clicks you can expect. OF THOSE you can expect only a 1-2% conversion rate, meaning that only 1-2% of the people who click on yoru ad will actually buy something.

Take the total cost of your ad and figure out if peopel bought what you're selling would you make enough money to cover the ad cost.

High cost items work best. If I had been selling my book or another product for $50 I would have been okay. So you have to look at it from your own perspective.

The click through rates on other sites are way higher than they are here (pm me and I'll tell you where).
post #6 of 37
Right. I'd be interested in seeing others' results too.
post #7 of 37
i don't have numbers, but running a banner on mdc resulted in maybe one sale.

the signature ad was much more effective.
post #8 of 37
I was shocked when mdc raised their banner ad prices. When I did a banner ad, I can not say I got any business from it. I am implementing coupon codes now, so I would be able to tell better, but I was very dissapointed and I had only spent like $40 for a month!

When they raised their prices, I just couldn't believe it. They didn't just raise them a little, either, they raised them tremendously! I mean way over the top. I have found much better places for advertising. Signatures are good though, and cheap. But I am sure they will raise them too. My ad is coming out in mothering magazine next month and I will let you all know how it does.

Stacey
post #9 of 37
My click-through on my current campaign has been .18%. I wavered on this, but decided to buy one year's worth of ads right before the price change (so $40something a month). So far it has paid for itself each month. I've gotten between one and three sales a month from it. However, I will most certainly not purchase again at the higher rates; what I've seen so far doesn't demonstrate that it is worth it.
post #10 of 37
I will be running one starting on the 15th and used the old rates too. I will let you know how it does.
But I can say I was blown away by how high the rates are now and that is geared towards WAHMs....come on, that is a bit too steep.
If it wasn't for all the WAHMs I don't think MDC would be doing as well as it is.

JMO

Jes
post #11 of 37
Erin, I stumbled across this post and wanted to let you know that I bought one of your cookbooks as a result of the banner ad, but I bought it through Amazon (I had other books to buy at the time). So it's possible that you sold more books than you realize...at least one more!

(By the way, I love the cookbook -- I'm vegan and hoping to raise my six-month-old son vegan, and am always looking for good recipes to keep him interested when he's older.)
post #12 of 37
Thread Starter 
Aww, I'm glad you are liking it and I'm glad you told me you bought it at Amazon.

I knew some people would go to Amazon to buy it, but Amazon didn't pay for my ad.

I don't make much money from Amazon, unfortunately. The amount they pay minus my costs leaves me with precious little. But I'm glad people are getting a good deal on the book because my primary purpose was, of course, to spread the book around as much as possible.
post #13 of 37
Well, now I wish I'd bought it through you!

*thinking about who might like this as a gift...*


Quote:
Originally Posted by Erin Pavlina
Aww, I'm glad you are liking it and I'm glad you told me you bought it at Amazon.

I knew some people would go to Amazon to buy it, but Amazon didn't pay for my ad.

I don't make much money from Amazon, unfortunately. The amount they pay minus my costs leaves me with precious little. But I'm glad people are getting a good deal on the book because my primary purpose was, of course, to spread the book around as much as possible.
post #14 of 37
Thread Starter 
LOL, that's sweet.

Now that I know the realities of independent publishing I always try to buy directly from the author. Even if the cost is higher than Amazon. Still, it's nice to be able to buy a bunch of different books from Amazon and just pay shipping one time (or not at all). And the discount can't be beat! So I officially absolve you of any guilt you might be experiencing as a result of having bought my book at Amazon.
post #15 of 37
Another thought is that many shoppers will bookmark or keep sites in mind for later purchases even if they don't buy now, the might later. There is also increasing your brand awareness as it were.

I can't afford the banner ads myself now that the prices have increased so dramatically.
post #16 of 37
Thankyoufor posting your stats. Where do you find how the demographics of the MDC boards are broken up?.. IE: aprox % of Vegans, BFers, Bwers ect....
post #17 of 37
Thread Starter 
someone did a poll in another forum a while ago. I took note of the number of vegans. It's not totally accurate, of course, but the vegan population in general is less than 1% so to find 16% here told me that at least the population is much higher here.
post #18 of 37
Thank you for sharing your results. I'm not ready to advertise yet, but we are preparing for advertising on different venues and it's nice to know what to expect a bit.

I would love to buy your cookbook, as before baby I was vegan and had time to cook. After baby and starting up a baby store, and baby not gaining weight, well, being vegan was put on the backburner and now I'm just vegetarian.
post #19 of 37
Quote:
Originally Posted by bethwl
My click-through on my current campaign has been .18%. I wavered on this, but decided to buy one year's worth of ads right before the price change (so $40something a month). So far it has paid for itself each month. I've gotten between one and three sales a month from it. However, I will most certainly not purchase again at the higher rates; what I've seen so far doesn't demonstrate that it is worth it.
This is approximatly where I'm at. I also wavered on trying it out, but with the increase in rates, I wanted to try at least once and I would have been kicking myself a lot harder had I tried at the higher prices. My ad has NOT paid for itself. I haven't had one direct sale from it (that I know of ) and it's been running two months now. I only bought 3 months worth, so I expect it to be ending soon. I won't be buying again, either.

My siggy, though, has definitly been worth it but for me, now that I'm actually getting busy (yey!!) I don't have much time to post. Thanks for sharing, Erin. It's comforting to know I'm not the only one out my $$$. :
post #20 of 37
I also did an ad in December just to lock-in the old rate. It wasn't really a good time for me to run an ad, as I don't really sell a gifty-type of item, but I did get a .41% CTR, but I don't think I got any sales from it. I will try another one in a couple of months when I launch a new product and will be more likely to use the data from that one to help with deciding if I'd do it again.

And my siggie ad has been great when I can get on the boards. I barely gotten to post at all since November and I've seen a clear drop in site traffic.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Work from Home Parents
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Work from Home Parents › My advertising results with Mothering