Scarlett and Keira and Vanity Fair.

[journeymom]

http://www.sky.com/showbiz/article/0...211681,00.html

I wish my first view of this issue had been the magazine itself at the checkout stand or something, rather than in the internet news. I wonder if my reaction would be the same. Maybe it would be, so what? (Can't deny Scarlett has a nice butt, though.)

This issue is treated like it's controversial. I guess it's not arty enough for some, not Page Three Girl enough for others?

Scarlett has a nice a$$, though.

[KaraBoo]

I don't see why it's controversial. I do feel, however, that is doesn't show Keira or Scarlett at their best. I don't think the poses or hair/makeup are flattering. And I just plain don't like Tom Ford.

[MamaBug]

I don't think it is offensive but it's not the best photo, and I can now understand why Rachel McAdams opted out, she was to be in that photo instead of Tom Ford

[TranscendentalMom]

I think its pretty hard to make 2 girls with such amazing beauty and toned bodies look unflattering naked...and yet somehow they managed! I don't care for the photo at all.

[OakBerry]

I agree, they are both gorgeous women but that shot is very unflattering. Scarlett's lower body looks great, but her upper body is all scrunched up and like someone mentioned, the makeup and hair are awful. Keira has such a delicate beauty and she looks too harsh.