Mothering › Forums › Archives › Pregnancy Archives › April 2006 › What is wrong with people?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What is wrong with people?  

post #1 of 18
Thread Starter 
Dh & I never discuss baby names with people in advance of the birth. Primarily, we believe that he & I should be the only people who name our child. If we start telling people what we're thinking then they'll likely give us feedback, either positive or negative, and whether we like it or not it may influence how we feel about the name. So we just avoid that whole scenario but not revealing anything until after the birth. Then people are smart/polite enough to keep their mouths shut if they have a problem with the name... right? Apparently not. For the most part people have said really kind things, but on their 2nd day of life we had MIL call and tell us that so-and-so at work told her teenage sons our sons names and they reported back that one of them will be made fun of for sure. The impression I got was that MIL was suggesting (although dh doesn't think this was the case) that we could still change his name since it wasn't on a birth certificate yet. Then that same day I told one of my oldest friends (who honestly has a big mouth and always says hurtful & inappropriate things) their names and she said, "well, we'll just call F by his first name only". Then today FIL tells me how he likes 3 out of 4 of their names (doesn't like one of the boys' middle names). WTF? Are people insane? I would *never* *ever* say crap like this to a parent - especially a NEW parent! And obviously we didn't want nor ask for their input so why would they feel it's okay to give it now? : Geeze, after those first 2 comments (a day after I had given birth) I was totally in tears. People suck. Just had to vent. Hope none of you are dealing with crap like this.
post #2 of 18
My Mom always starts her stuff with, "No offense, but..." and ya always know you will surely be offended! LOL! She's done that over names we've considered in the past, but we've not included her on any of those. I was surprised to tell a friend one of the names we like for a girl and have her just go NUTSO over it being so old and how could do that to our child. I don't get it~do WHAT to our child? Give her a family name we think is beautiful? Who's business is it, anyway? (((((HUGS))))) sandi
post #3 of 18
After I named my daughter, a beautiful Sanskrit name which SHE loves, I had EVERY single person in my family call and ask me to change it because we hadn't done the birth certificate yet...

GRRRRR....I know what you are feeling!
post #4 of 18
s people are so rude and insensitive. My mum made it clear she didn't like DSs name and to this day (he is 4) only calls him by his nn I imagine we'll likely get some comments again this time depending on which name we go with.

What is important is that you and DH love their names, of course its impossible not to feel upset and emotional especially having recently given birth. Personally I LOVE your twins names.

s try not to let it upset you
post #5 of 18
Double posted
post #6 of 18
I LOVE the boys names!! I am all into unique names! and they are great!! and sooo cute!

We have kept the name from our parents also. I am big into not wanting a name that will obviously cause my child ridicule in school, but my hubby and cousin are 'great' at letting me know if a name could be potential hazard..lol

I run my names by hubby then my best friend too.

For a while we were looking at naming him Griffin Dore (yes i am a HUGE harry potter fan! ) and at one point my mom said oh i'm sure you've picked Griffin with his horrid tone in her voice and look on her face : . I told her well now that was just rude. My kids, my choice!

And of course lets not even go with the reason my MIL doesnt know is cause with #1 she called him by name every second and I felt like..look this little person is not even here yet...when pregnant i feel (selfishly) that he is MINE all mine..no one else has any right to do or say or anything to him...so it drove me nuts!! had #1 name picked out way before even preg (reguardless of sex) and i had almost changed it in month 8 cause MIL calling him by name..

But hey...it's all good now ...#1 and #2 are named and here ....#3 named..but WAITING....

ps..rant all you want!!!
post #7 of 18
I love your boys' names!!!!!

People are just totally insensitive. My MIL & FIL threw a fit at DH after DD was born, because all I did was sit in the recliner and didn't entertain them. I had horrible PPD, and DH told them they could only come over for a little while--not all day, and they yelled at him for that too. Luckily, he told them off and said he had to take care of his family whether they liked it or not.

I'm sorry your family and friends are shoving their feet in their mouths. I think they are beautiful names. We never tell names either, because when I was pg with DD, I mentioned one of my favorite names to MIL, and she reacted poorly. I will never do that again! If she pulled something like yours did, WATCH OUT! Mama bears are not fun to deal with, LOL!
post #8 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by radicalmama
After I named my daughter, a beautiful Sanskrit name which SHE loves, I had EVERY single person in my family call and ask me to change it because we hadn't done the birth certificate yet...
Yup, I know what you mean. We also picked a Sanskrit name for our dd, which we all love. But we didn't get the comments you did. More along the lines of "but what are you going to call her?" From strangers we would get long silences and then comments like "Is that a family name?" :

We didn't share names before the fact with dd and aren't sharing this time around either. Part of it is Hindu superstition, but a lot of it is just practicality... no need to get started on the negative comments *before* the birth.

Not that this will stop us from picking another Sanskrit name for this next one
post #9 of 18
That is absurd!

I would have thought your strategy is a good one. I myself cannot help but talk about names, and then I do get totally confused by people's reactions.....

For them to comment after the fact? RIDICULOUSLY inappropriate. I would tell them so too! Let their feelings get a little hurt and maybe they'll get their head out of you know where so they don't do this to others....

XOXO
Beth
post #10 of 18
Thread Starter 
I did say something to my friend, but I'm not so good at being bold with my comments (I don't think it's nice to be rude, unlike her, who obviously has it coming anyway). I just said, "that's really not very nice" and so she tried to backtrack out of it by saying "it's a nice name - just very beautiful, too beautiful - so I couldn't see calling him by his full name (like when angry and you pull the full name thing on him)." I'm like, well, I obviously like the name and I'll deal with that if it's an issue (which of course it's not).

I was asking dh last night if he heard the comment FIL made about only liking 3 of the 4 names and he said yeah, and that FIL also told him that he was talking to his brother (dh's uncle) and he likes our first names a lot but not their mn's. Okay, he can have this opinion - I'm not faulting the uncle b/c he didn't make these comments to us - but WHY does FIL feel compelled to share this with us? Ironically dh said that FIL even defended us and said that he didn't have to like the names b/c it wasn't up to him. Hmm. But then he makes HIS comment. It's all just really weird. This has made me remember that after having dd2, I told a friend what we had named her (first & middle) and she said, "oh, you should have used her mn for her first!" Okay... I guess that was supposed to be a complement. Brings me back to that "what is wrong with people?" sentiment!
post #11 of 18
People can be so rude and insensitive, especially to a postpartum woman. I don't know why people feel the need to always give their imput in a matter where it is not solicited.
Hugs to you.
post #12 of 18
my dad did that to me. Before Obie was born, he told me that I was not to name our baby Obediah because he absolutely hated that name. I said "well, I'm glad it's not your decision." he said he liked the name Ben (which was on our big list). I also mentioned that he could be tactful instead of mean and he said he assumed I didn't want him to lie.

fast forward to the day of his birth. We name him Obediah Matthew and he says, "so how is little Matt doing?" my step-mom appropriately scolded him .

I realized with my dad, being a conservative dairy farmer, he was embarrassed because he considers it to be a hippy name and doesn't want to tell family. my brother's kids are Echo, Rye, and Amele` so I think he's waiting for the John and Richard to come from me. too bad for him!

Sarah
post #13 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamatoady
I realized with my dad, being a conservative dairy farmer, he was embarrassed because he considers it to be a hippy name and doesn't want to tell family. my brother's kids are Echo, Rye, and Amele` so I think he's waiting for the John and Richard to come from me. too bad for him!
I was under the impression Obediah is a Biblical name...not quite hippie, if that makes him feel any better
post #14 of 18
We only told folks our second choice names for this reason. I didn't want someone messing with our child's name if I was really in love with it. No one heard the "real" names until they were born.
post #15 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamatoady
my dad did that to me. Before Obie was born, he told me that I was not to name our baby Obediah because he absolutely hated that name. I said "well, I'm glad it's not your decision." he said he liked the name Ben (which was on our big list). I also mentioned that he could be tactful instead of mean and he said he assumed I didn't want him to lie.

fast forward to the day of his birth. We name him Obediah Matthew and he says, "so how is little Matt doing?" my step-mom appropriately scolded him .

I realized with my dad, being a conservative dairy farmer, he was embarrassed because he considers it to be a hippy name and doesn't want to tell family. my brother's kids are Echo, Rye, and Amele` so I think he's waiting for the John and Richard to come from me. too bad for him!

Sarah
Good grief. Obediah is a good Hebrew name. It's a book in the Bible, for heaven's sake. And I'll bet there were a bunch of farmers named that about 200 yrs ago (I mean that as a compliment!). My mom just laughs and says all our kids (Nathaniel, Susannah, Abigail and Luke) would be at home on a stagecoach. But hey, old-fashioned names are coming back in!
post #16 of 18
Wow... I'm sorry you've experienced this. I for one think you gave your boys GREAT names. We're using the same strategy (don't tell till after the birth)--it has always worked for us. But we've chosen our most unusual name so far this time, and I've been worrying that we'll get a reaction like you did.
post #17 of 18
Well, I can't say that I'd name a child Obadiah, but that's because a) we live in Amish country and b) my husband happens to be of Pennsylvania Dutch descent (by which I mean, we have a very, very, very common last name... if you're Amish, Mennonite, or just happen to live around here). Obadiah Ourlastname would be immediately, constantly, and consistantly mistaken for an Amish kid. That didn't stop us from naming BooBah after Mike's grandmother (who was, in fact, Amish and had a very Amish name), but it is why we tend to use her Hebrew name rather than her English one, even though the English name is first on her BC.

LH-- People are jerks and idiots. I haven't always liked babies' names, but I stopped making comments after my niece (who has a "ghetto" name, and yes, I still feel sorry for her; the poor kid *loathes* it, and I know what that's like) was born. I would certainly never make a comment like that to a grownup who wasn't someone for whom I felt somewhat responsible. When BeanBean was born, we got a lot of rude comments about his name. I had it worse than Mike; because Mike is white and fairly "straight" as these things go, people assumed that he had "allowed" such a name for a reason, and were more polite when they asked him about it. I am not white, and I look very young for my age (at least, that's what I've been told) so people assumed that I made it up (I didn't) and were downright obnoxious about it. One of Mike's friends gave me the funniest look and said, "Where the hell did you come up with that name?" When I said, "It's Hebrew," he totally shut up, as did everyone else to whom I "explained." It was almost worth the irritation just to see the way that their jaws slammed shut when I said that it was Hebrew!

People have asked about BooBah's name (the Hebrew name, which is the one we use except when we're doing the irritated, full-name, "get over here right now!" thing ), but have generally been more polite than they were when BeanBean was born. (Perhaps I look "old enough" to be her mother? ) Noone has asked about Bella's name at all; at least two famous people have had names pronounced identically to hers, and there's a lovely, nerdy reference for the geek crowd. People have heard it before, but it's not super common so they just say, "Oh, that's beautiful!" It's funny how things change...
post #18 of 18
People can be so insensitive. My mom has made some comments about one of our likely girl's names that are based on prejudice - her German-Jewish snootiness about a Yiddish name. Luckily she gave me such a very bad name that I don't feel obliged to listen to her at all!

That being said, we are having the awfulest time choosing a girl's name. We narrowed it down to 2 and I find I'm not crazy about either of them. I know once the baby is born it will be her name and we will forget all our prior associations and just love it, but ever since i was a little girl imagining what I would name my children I never imagined they would be names like these: Shana and Penina (Penny for short). This baby is going to be born any day now and if it's a girl we don't know what we'll do. At least the boy's name was easy. I had no idea how difficult it would be compromising on this with DH!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: April 2006
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Archives › Pregnancy Archives › April 2006 › What is wrong with people?