Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › hates to use the potty
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

hates to use the potty  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
My 3.5-year-old has been going through a "thing" for the last four months now where she seems to just hate using the potty. I'm wondering if anyone else has experienced the same thing.
She learned how to use the potty and stopped wearing diapers almost a year ago, and had even started going by herself. Then we made a big move--changed states, houses, and daycare places this past February. The daycare wasn't a good place, and she started pooping/peeing in her undies pretty regularly, which makes total sense to me. It was a difficult transition, and this was one of the ways she manifested feeling stressed by it.
But we got her out of the old daycare, found another place which she loves, and by all other indications, she seems pretty happy. She's eating really well (which is always a big indicator of her emotional well-being), sleeping well, seems generally happy.
So it no longer seems to be a "transition" issue. She really just seems to hate using the potty. I will see her doing "the pee-pee dance" or clenching up like she needs to poop, and I'll ask her to come to the bathroom with me. No dice. She SWEARS she doesn't need to go, refuses to make a step toward the bathroom, etc. It seems like the only time she ends up going in the toilet is when I physically carry her to it and place her on it.
And I can't always be right next to her to make that happen, of course. So for months now, I (or my dh) have been cleaning up poop and pee. We've tried to be so low-key about it--"accidents happen," or "oh well, next time we'll use the potty, right?--but we're not making any progress. I'm getting so sick of the smell of poop! We're at the point where she's generally wearing diapers again, and regularly soiling them, which she seems fine with.
When I ask her why she won't use the toilet, she says she doesn't want to. She doesn't seem particularly afraid of it or anything, so I don't understand why.
Has anyone gone through something like this? Is there an approach we could be taking that would be more productive or healthy? The last thing I want to do is make her feel bad, or pressured, but my frustration level is really starting to build.
post #2 of 6
That sounds so frustrating. It must be difficult because she was using the toilet regularly for a while. I have an almost 4 year old who has shown no interest in the potty, ever. But that's a totally different situation. It sounds like maybe it's just a habit for her now? Too much work maybe? I don't have any advice, just wanted to offer :.
post #3 of 6
To be honest, I'd offer her the choice of diapers again. I expect it's a bit of habit and a bit that this is the last thing that she can control (like eating, you really can't control her bowels, can you?!) Was there anything connected to the old daycare related to pottying issues?

I would tell her that it's too much work for you and dh to clean up pee and poop all the time. So, she can have the choice of either wearing diapers or wearing undies if she promises to TRY to go potty once an hour when the timer rings. If she chooses undies but won't go potty when the timer rings, then I'd very calmly put her in diapers and say "oh, it looks like you're choosing not to go potty. If that's the case, we need you to wear diapers so we don't have to cleanup. we can try again tomorrow."
post #4 of 6
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the responses. At this point, she often chooses to wear diapers instead of undies. I thought this would be uncomfortable to her, or would carry some sort of stigma, but I was quite wrong. Tonight, she asked to wear the "new diapers" she and dh had bought when they went to the grocery store together, as if they were an exciting new purchase. Sigh...
post #5 of 6
I would definitely take any power struggle out of it.

I'd give her diapers for a while and try not to show disapproval or disappointment.

Sometimes its the dynamic between child and adult that keeps these issues going. If she's struggling against your will, then make it not a struggle, deflate the energy around it. If she's truly not liking to use the potty, maybe she needs a break. I know that feels like backward motion, but really maybe its just a break. She will give up diapers, really. Right now, it sounds like she's feeling like she needs a break. Maybe she needs to feel babied again for some reason. Maybe she's going to have a developmental milestone soon and its scaring her (this sometimes causes regress) or using all her energies. It's okay really. DS1 was still peeing his pants through 4.5. DS2 is 3 and pees on the potty everytime but has never pooped on it, always in his pants, and refuses to wear a diaper. My neighbor has a son that was perfect from 3-4 and then began peeing his pants regularly from 4-5. Then he stopped again. These things are never really the big issues we sometimes make them out to be. And she will keep getting older. She'll turn 4 and then 5. This will be something that you think back on as a quirky period in her development.
post #6 of 6
My DD had real power struggle issues with the daycare staff over potty, and she was actually throwing tantrums because they were her forcing to go every 30 minutes! It started to interfer with potty time at home, and I demanded they stop forcing her. I also told DH to lay off totally. He was the main focus of her potty tantrums at home. Then I put her old potty chair in the playroom and aloowed her to make her choice about where and when she would go. Zero power struggle. She was back on the potty without tears in less than a month. SHe still only uses the daycare potty twice a day, and this really freaks out the staff, but I am REALLY adamant they follow HER lead. HTH
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › hates to use the potty