Mothering › Forums › Archives › Pregnancy Archives › December 2006 › what are you doing about soy?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

what are you doing about soy?  

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
Are you avoiding it? Limiting it? Eating it without concerns?

Ever since reading those Mothering articles a while back, I've really reduced my soy consumption. Now that I'm pregnant I'm trying to reduce it even more, but I still have some now and then. I'm curious to hear your opinions on soy.
post #2 of 12
I have to admit, I haven't been watching it as closely as I did before getting pregnant. I'm vegetarian and went through a few weeks of veggie aversions so I was just kind of eating whatever didn't make me hurl. Now that my appetite seems to be getting back to normal I will probably go back to limiting it. It's hard though. Some soy products are just good!
post #3 of 12
I completely avoid it. During the past year I've been charting and I've noticed that I have really short luteal phases (8 days) when I've had soy and normal ones (11 days is normal for me) when I haven't.

Because of concerns about the phyto-estrogens in soy, I'm avoiding it entirely until the 2nd trimester, or later.

Being a vegetarian makes this a little more complicated, but I'm finding other ways to get my protein. Although it is distressing how many products now have various soy derivatives in them...I have to be an avid label reader.

HTH,
post #4 of 12
I"m nursing a baby that has allergies to dairy, I have to use soy milk (rice milk makes me sick) other than that, I don't really use soy products.
post #5 of 12
not currently pregnant, but www.hpakids.org has great articles on soy and other holistic stuff

Can't drink rice or dairy? what about almond milk?
post #6 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by Attached Mama
not currently pregnant, but www.hpakids.org has great articles on soy and other holistic stuff

Can't drink rice or dairy? what about almond milk?
Is that a good source of calcium?
post #7 of 12

My "book" on soy

I struggled with this big time.

I tried to go cold turkey about a year ago and for 2 months I had ovulation bleeding, which I've never had before. I felt terrible. I know my body relies on it now. I also went off soy cold turkey with my second pg, which ended in miscarriage (not saying that was the reason, but you never know). So I feel like just in case, I can't take the chance of going off like that again.

So, I don't go haywire on it, but I do have one soy product a day. I really believe it's the processed soy that gives lots of problems, like soy burgers. I try to eat edamame and soy milk as it feels good to me, and I do indulge in a veggie sausage patty a few times a week with breakfast.

I would encourage anyone who's looking at reducing soy who also eats soy "meats" to check out www.quorn.com. They have excellent soy-free meat substitutes.

I also feel that the jury is still out on soy. There are great benefits and some studied risk. I have lots of heart disease in my family and I feel soy perhaps may help me reduce my risk. While there are lots of claims about the ill-effects of soy, I don't feel confident in the amount of research or who is doing the research to completely alter my diet to completely avoid soy. I don't think that my soy consumption would influence my son to be feminine or gay, as I don't believe that it will influence my girl to start her period at 6.

So, for now, I enjoy it as I like without too much worry. I believe everything is fine in moderation. If I excluded everything that might be potentially harmful from my diet, I'd be anorexic!
post #8 of 12
I also eat soy product allmost every day. But not more than one serving a day as for example: soy yogurt, tofu or soy cheese. I'm a vegan and I really like to eat yummy, so... But I'm trying not to overreact.
post #9 of 12
No soy here. I had a progesterone defecincy so I stay away from anything that is estrogen, phyto-estrogen or anything close to estrogen.
post #10 of 12
I apologize in advance for sounding ignorant, but...

I knew soy wasn't good for babies, but this is news to me that it is bad during pregnancy, when trying to conceive, or all the time as some posts seem to suggest.

Again, sorry if ignorant but ... what about people in countries that eat a lot of soy as part of their diet (southeast/asia for example)?

Is there something about the soy products we have access to here that makes it different? highly processed, genetically modified, etc?

This is very interesting to me...i would love some more info. I am a vegetarian and I eat some soy, probably a couple of times a week...
post #11 of 12
I haven't been limiting it, but I don't have soy all that much to begin with...maybe 3 times a week? Mostly it's just soy milk. I really love edamame, too.
post #12 of 12
I have anaphylaxis to dairy and soy products and allergies to peanuts, red meat and corn syrup.
Obviously I do not eat soy products ever but I also limit them for my children. I believe that anything in large quantities especially high allergens is a bad idea. I would recommend limiting your intake on soy dairy peanuts and corn (i think there are others as well) and just rotating when you are eating them. THis will make it less likely for your baby to have allergies. I am sure there is lots more info over on the allergy forum.
I am not an expert, that is just my personal experience.
Nicole
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: December 2006
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Archives › Pregnancy Archives › December 2006 › what are you doing about soy?