Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Concerns about Public Library's Summer Reading Program
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Concerns about Public Library's Summer Reading Program  

post #1 of 22
Thread Starter 
A little background on my family:

We already know that we will homeschool, even though oldest child is not yet 3. I feel like we already homeschool, so I see what will come later as an extension of what we already do.

We live in a small community that is not very progressive, in virtually every way. Overall, though, we feel good about our decision to move back here (dh's hometown) because dh can make a good living and be self-employed, the cost of living is really low, the pace of life is nice and relaxed, and our kids really know the people with whom they interact on a daily basis (local shopowners, library staff, etc.).

We attend storytime at the public library every week, and it is a good program. Typically, it consists of songs, a story, then a craft project related to the story. Storytime goes on hiatus for the summer, and in the same time slot is the "summer reading program." I'm hesitant to participate for two reasons: 1) Instead of the usual 12-15 kids, I've been told there will be 50+ each week; 2) We signed up today, and apparently the program includes not only a weekly story and some special events (magician performance, etc.) but prizes given each week based on the number of books read. The folder we were given today includes little forms that we're supposed to fill out for each book ds reads. DS has LOVED books from an early age (would sit on our lap reading for an hour at 10 months) and I hate to introduce some stupid school-like reward system for what he naturally loves to do.

The only reason I took him to register is that he is really upset that we've had a few weeks without storytime. Taking him to the library 1-2 times a week provides lots of fun/learning, but not an opportunity for deep interaction with the library staff and the songs/craft projects he loves to do there. DD (14 months) also really enjoys the structured program.

I'm thinking about taking him every week but not tracking his reading. I wonder if hearing the weekly announcement of prizes will be something he'll tune into, though. Probably I just need to talk with the staff and see if there is a way we can pick and choose the parts we are comfortable with (maybe staying for part of each session?). I'm sure the staff will look at me like I am from outer space for seeing any negatives in this.

I would love any thoughts on my situation. Thanks!
post #2 of 22
FWIW, I read voraciously as a child from well before school-age. And my view of summer reading programs then was that the prizes (which I often won, even with restrictions such as my mother limiting me to chapter books in 1st grade to be fair to the competition) were icing on the cake.

The summer reading program at our local library includes prizes for reading, according to the following scheme:

either per books read (or read to child)
or per 20 minutes of reading (or being read to).

I enrolled DD when she was 1. We didn't do it last summer, but probably will this summer. The culimnating prize is a cheap-seat ticket to a professional baseball game. DD really likes baseball, so why not? It doesn't sway her enjoyment of books either way.
post #3 of 22
well we were "sure" we would homeschool when our two were that age adn then came ds3 adn ds4 and we were totally overwhelmed. ds1 spent two years in a charter school before we ultimately decided on homeschooling (this is our second year and we LOVE it). That being said, I don't think the library problem is too much of a problem, especially with kids that young.

Be thankful that the library ALLOWS you to go to storytime with mixed age children and more than one child. Here they make you have ONLY the kids that fall into the age range and one adult per child. My four have virtually NEVER been able to participate. I can't even take the 3yo when my older two are in their one day a week homeschool enrichment program because baby is not welcome. and that is among ALL of the FOUR nearby library systems. There are lots of homeschool challenges like that. We can't participate in this and that because we have the older child present (children's museum won't let little ones be unattended but won't allow big ones in the same rooms as little ones and i won't leave big ones unattended...blah blah). sometimes I start a mini-revolution but usually it just makes me look cRRRazy!!! not that I care LOL

now we participate in the programs for the crappy prizes and the family bonding time and the little party over books...why not?? at least it is FUN and DIFFFERENT and about READING.....there's lots of crap out there and in arizona when it is 115 degrees, there is not much else to do

now as far as the prizes and the record-keeping....why do your kids even have to KNOW you are stamping their sheets or writing the titles of the books down? we just read as normal and i made a little pile of the stories and transcribed them onto all four of their sheets later. all they knew is they EARNED baseball tickets. they probably thought WON baseball tix. they felt proud. they had a good time. i don't think it changed their mind about reading at all. they just went on as normal but got a few prizes when tehy went to the library that week. like they get balloons sometimes at trader joe's or they get a sticker from a cashier at the post office, etc.

i hope that helps.......
post #4 of 22
There was a good thread about this last year, Enjoy!

http://www.mothering.com/discussions...ibrary+reading
post #5 of 22
I don't mind those programs at all. I don't tell my kids about them. They just get the prizes. We do the Pizza Hut Book-It thing. We do library summer reading programs. We did a reading club. My kids just think they are getting personal pan pizzas, little trinkets, a ton of free books, whatever. I don't change the number of books they read for those programs in any way. I just count their normal reading. Since they meet the requirements normally it's not prize contingent upon reading for them.
post #6 of 22
When I'd sign up for those summer reading things, I generally just wrote down whatever was in the bag of books to be returned to the library that week. For me, those things were always just a way to see "hey, cool, I read X books recently" Of course, I never did understand about the prize systems and things. Hmm, maybe if I'd been paying better attention I could have had more junk in my bedroom.
post #7 of 22
I signed dd up for it, but she's too little to "get it" and that's okay. Our library has a summer reading program for adults too. Adults write down the title of the book they read, the author, and get entered into a weekly drawing. I read anyway and I read to dd anyway, so I thought what the heck. When dd is older, I don't think I'll focus on the prizes though. Hopefully she'll want to read because reading is fun.
post #8 of 22
ITA Raven!! I was reading chapter books by second grade and could finish a Stephen King book in a few days in 4th grade. I loved the summer reading programs I was reading regardless ao the prizes were just a bonus.
post #9 of 22
At our library, a prize is given regardless of the # of books you read. All you do is sign up and then come 1x/week to the library. It's a dorky plastic price which usually ends up broken in the car but...

Perhaps talk with your librarian about what you are uncomfortable about. Maybe they don't need to see a tally.

FWIW, if your child already likes to read then the prizes are unlikely to change that love in such a short time, especially when you explain to your child WHY the library offers such a program (to get kids who DON'T love to read the chance to try it). It might be a good conversation about how all families are different...
post #10 of 22
My dd just signed up for it today. She loves to read so for her, as PP said, it's icing on the cake. She has already read two books today before we brought the form home and marked off two spaces.
post #11 of 22
I was a voracious reader as a kid and still have happy memories of the summer library program - usually reading didn't merit the kind of prizes/recognition in my childhood that other stuff like sports (which I wasn't good at) did, so I think I got a happy glow from it actually being valued in a 'conventional' way, even though I would have read about 15 books a week all summer anyway. If the prizes are junky I wouldn't be thrilled though - I got books, and kept some of them for years.
post #12 of 22
We avoid it. Last year I decided to sign them up and this is how it went.

DD set her goal at 8 books to be read from the end of June until the beginning of August. Since we do school during the month of July and she has several summer activities then she read 5 of those books by the end of June (knowing she wouldn't have as much free time in July). When we went in to have those books checked off the librarian told her she *really should raise her goal* and DD did. Then she barely made her goal and felt really stressed about the whole thing. : The prize was a free book so she really wanted to get it!

DS had his goal set for him by the library since I am reading to him. That would have been fine except they assume picture books and the goal was 25 books! We read chapter books wouldn't have gotten anywhere near that. I ended up adding in really easy books so we could reach the goal. Then we were sick the last week of the program and they wouldn't give me his certificate when we did make it in! : Luckily DS didn't care but I was pissed!

We are doing the scholastic program; no pre-set goals and I'll supply a prize when I feel like it
post #13 of 22
our library is doing the same thing. We are participating but not filling out the reading program book for stickers or the end prize.
post #14 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by 3momkmb
We are doing the scholastic program; no pre-set goals and I'll supply a prize when I feel like it
What's the scholastic program?
post #15 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by shaywyn
What's the scholastic program?
http://www.scholastic.com/summerreading/index.htm
post #16 of 22
Oh gosh I love the summer reading program! I have such good memories of getting my Dairy Queen coupon from when I was a kid--I was a kid who loved to read anyways so this was just something fun to do in the summer. My kids both enjoy it and we have always participated, it's just FUN, nothing more.

It gives my dd (8yrs) a chance to set a small goal (usually about 20 books or so) and meet her goal.
post #17 of 22
If your oldest is almost 3 (mine is too!), I doubt he'll really understand much of the prize system. DD is more interested in the people and books.
post #18 of 22
My little one usually participates because he loves to earn the prizes. He's a voracious reader and easily finishes the program just a few weeks in.

We don't diligently keep track, though. Since I know he's read for hours and hours, I just have him color in each little picture (it's a print out with lots of little drawings to color, each representing 20 minutes of reading - you don't have to keep track of which books, etc.) before we make a trip to the library. That way, it's not hanging over his head all week. He doesn't think about how long he's been reading, or whether his books "count" (in our smallish town, only books that are in the library's system "count" - I figure, though, that with ILL, we could get ANY book through the library, so they all count!).
post #19 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by marilynmama
It gives my dd (8yrs) a chance to set a small goal (usually about 20 books or so) and meet her goal.
Zowee, that's a small goal??!! My 7 1/2 yo gets through one book a week, max.

Miranda
post #20 of 22
Thread Starter 
THANKS everyone for the feedback. I read last year's thread and it contained a lot of food for thought.

I think we'll try it and see how it goes, but I won't involve ds directly in the "rewards" aspect of the program.

Because we lack the kind of cultural resources found in larger areas, I do think I want to use this as an opportunity to stay plugged into the community.

Thanks for your thoughtful responses!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Concerns about Public Library's Summer Reading Program