Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › "Midwives" by Chris Bohjalian
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

"Midwives" by Chris Bohjalian  

post #1 of 41
Thread Starter 
Anybody read this? It was one of Oprah's Book Club books. I ran across it in my library and checked it out. I'm about halfway through and it is SOOOO good! Here's the summary for those who haven't read it:

Quote:
On a violent, stormy winter night, a home birth goes disastrously wrong. The phone lines are down, the roads slick with ice. The midwife, unable to get her patient to a hospital, works frantically to save both mother and child while her inexperienced assistant and the woman's terrified husband look on. The mother dies but the baby is saved thanks to an emergency C-section. And then the nightmare begins: the assistant suggests that maybe the woman wasn't really dead when the midwife operated:

Did she perform at least eight or nine cycles as my mother said, or four or five as Asa recalled? That is the sort of detail that was disputable. But at some point within minutes of what my mother believed had been a stroke, after my mother concluded the cardiopulmonary resuscitation had failed to generate a pulse or a breath, she screamed for Asa and Anne to find her the sharpest knife in the house.

In Midwives, Chris Bohjalian chronicles the events leading up to the trial of Sibyl Danforth, a respected midwife in the small Vermont town of Reddington, on charges of manslaughter. It quickly becomes evident, however, that Sibyl is not the only one on trial--the prosecuting attorney and the state's medical community are all anxious to use this tragedy as ammunition against midwifery in general; this particular midwife, after all, an ex-hippie who still evokes the best of the flower-power generation, is something of an anachronism in 1981. Through it all, Sibyl, her husband, Rand, and their teenage daughter, Connie, attempt to keep their family intact, but the stress of the trial--and Sibyl's growing closeness to her lawyer--puts pressure on both marriage and family. Bohjalian takes readers through the intricacies of childbirth and the law, and by the end of Sibyl Danforth's trial, it's difficult to decide which was more harrowing--the tragic delivery or its legal aftermath.
Narrated by a now adult Connie, Midwives moves back and forth in time, fitting vital pieces of information about what happened that night like pieces of a jigsaw puzzle into its complicated plot. As Connie looks back on her mother's trial, she is still trying to understand what happened--not on the night of the disaster--but in the months and years that followed. --Margaret Prior
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/037...lance&n=283155
post #2 of 41
I read it a while back and I thought it was awesome!
post #3 of 41
I really liked it.

Some members of the hb community were really upset about it, but I thought that it was well-written.

alsoSarah
post #4 of 41
I loved it, too. I can see why some would be upset about it, but I thought it was very moving.
post #5 of 41
My mom and I read that one a long time ago. It was the first I'd ever heard of homebirth, or midwives, believe it or not. Anyway, I thought it was a great story. I don't know whether it's all good about the "politics" of midwifery and natural birth and all that-- like I said, I read it awhile ago. But it was a darn good read that kept me up late.
post #6 of 41
I really enjoyed it - it's one of my favourite books. I know a lot of homebirthers hate it, but I don't share their view that it brands homebirth as dangerous and fraught with disaster.
post #7 of 41
I read it about eight years ago. Fabulous book.
post #8 of 41
Read it years ago and loved it. I was impressed with the male authors ability to write so well from the POV of a teen girl.
post #9 of 41
sounds absolutely awful to me no matter how well it was written - but then i had a true emergency c/s that i am still trying to heal from so it's just a terrifying subject to me - not an entertaining one.
post #10 of 41
I read the book and loved it, but I can understand why some would be concerned that anti-hb'ers would see it as affirming their beliefs. I think having were more hb novels out there, good and bad, would help.
post #11 of 41
I didn't read the book, but did see the made for tv (I THINK) movie. I believe it was the same name, but DEFINATELY the same plot.
post #12 of 41
I think he did an amazing job writing from the teenage daughter of a midwife. However, the ending really pissed me off, mainly because it portrays the old theory that homebirth mws are deceitful.
post #13 of 41
Thread Starter 
Don't give away the ending - I haven't finished it yet!!!! I'm 3/4 of the way through.
post #14 of 41
I felt kind of annoyed when I read the daughter's reason for her choice of profession. One bad experience out of how many births, and that's it?? NOT.
post #15 of 41
Quote:
Originally Posted by minkajane
Don't give away the ending - I haven't finished it yet!!!! I'm 3/4 of the way through.
sorry, I tried to word it without giving anything away. after re-reading it, I should have posted it as a spoiler.
post #16 of 41
I read it a couple years ago so the details are fuzzy but I really liked his writing. I just last week read another book by him: Trans-Sister Radio -- very interesting book about a woman who falls in love with a man who has already decided to have surgery to become a female and live as a lesbian because he always felt "he" was in the wrong body. Worth checking out.
post #17 of 41
Read it years ago and loved it also.
post #18 of 41
Quote:
Originally Posted by dziejen
I read it a couple years ago so the details are fuzzy but I really liked his writing. I just last week read another book by him: Trans-Sister Radio -- very interesting book about a woman who falls in love with a man who has already decided to have surgery to become a female and live as a lesbian because he always felt "he" was in the wrong body. Worth checking out.
Yes, I was just going to post this...I love all of chris bohjalians books...right now I am actually reading "before you know kindness" All of his books read the same for the most part, so if you like(d) Midwives, check oput his other stuff, especially WAter Witches....

About Midwives thoug, I felt very sympathetic toward the midwfe in the book - and I think Chris did too. I jst hated that it came out as I was plannig my first birth ((with a nmidwfe) and I had to keep defending my choice...
post #19 of 41
I'm the opposite - I didn't like any of his other books. I tried so hard to get into Before You Know Kindness and Trans Sister Radio, but ended up leaving them unfinished. The only other one of his books I've managed to get through is Buffalo Soldier (and I thought it was as dull as dishwater).
post #20 of 41
Thread Starter 

Spoiler

SPOILER WARNING!





I finished it last night. I honestly don't know how I feel about the ending, that last notebook entry. I'm conflicted between wanting to support the midwife for saving the baby and being completely appalled at what she hid from everyone.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › "Midwives" by Chris Bohjalian