Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Breastfeeding, Formula, and Guilt
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Breastfeeding, Formula, and Guilt  

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
This article was pointed out to me by a friend online and I knew I had to share it here. It's a great piece on whether women should feel guilty for using formula.

http://www.sleepingbaby.net/jan/Essays/guilt.html
post #2 of 20
What a wonderful read! Very, very well written.
post #3 of 20
good article!
post #4 of 20
I like Jan
post #5 of 20
Great article! I love Jan's slings, but had no idea she was such an eloquent writer.
post #6 of 20
outstanding! I love Jan...she makes the best slings around! thanks for sharing.
post #7 of 20
That was so well-explained. It really bugs me when misinformation is spread so mothers don't have to feel guilty.
post #8 of 20
That was great!
post #9 of 20
Wow, what a nice artical, thanks for sharing
post #10 of 20
thank you for sharing, I enjoyed this read!
post #11 of 20
So well said, thanks for sharing.

On a different board right now, I've been lurking in a thread which touches on women who weren't able to breastfeed, etc. and it just makes me sad - several of the UTBF mothers harbor such anger and resentment towards "breastfeeding advocates," even though the stories they're sharing so clearly paint a different picture .... one where doctors and nurses unwittingly sabotaged the bf relationship; where the mothers ended up supplementing early and reel off a litany of other things which were imposed upon them, all as a result of a lack of knowledge, lack of support .... but it's the bf advocates' fault, not the doctors or nurses or a poorly trained LC .... As far as the moms are concerned, the docs pushing ff etc. were 'saving' them from a failing bf relationship, not hammering the final nail into a coffin that was already built through lack of education/support.

A couple people have tried to point out the places where the UTBF moms' bf was sabotaged, and people are being careful about not pointing out that *if mom had read the bf books she's talking about, she would have been watching for signs of whether baby was hydrated well enough etc.* --- and instead, pointing out where staff could have implemented finger feeds, cup feedings, etc. etc., or where the LC should have been brought in, or etc. --- but what the moms keep coming back with is, "Oh, but all the bf advocates say that 98-99% of women can bf, but that's just not true, I couldn't bf and listening to bf advocacy meant that my child suffered in the interim."

I just don't understand why it gets blamed on lactivists (who clearly weren't in the picture at all, except as nebulous judgers in some of the moms' heads) - when in reality, it's obviously a case of uninformed and unsupportive HCPs all along the line, and a lack of follow-up support for the bf mom when she arrives home too. How is someone who says, "Breast is best," or "Most women can breastfeed, if you have problems, ask for help" but has NO impact on the medical care the moms receive, before/during/after birth -- responsible for medical interventions which sabotage bf?? :
post #12 of 20
Thanks for posting this. I was actually just thinking today about how so many of my friends say that my breastfeeding exclusively for so long makes me seem 'better' than them although I've never said a word about it to them.

It hurts to know that a decision they made makes them feel 'threatened' by me and my decision. I have nothing to do with their decisions not to breastfeed or continue doing so. I wish they would read articles like this : and take responsibility for their decisions instead of telling me that I am making them feel inadequate...
post #13 of 20
Quote:
No doctor would tell a woman that she shouldn't bother quitting smoking while she's pregnant
actually, I do know a couple of girls whose doctors advised them to KEEP smoking during the first trimester (!) because it would put more stress on the baby to quit cold turkey than to gradually phase smoking out. They made them feel like it was no big deal to smoke while pg. I'm talking early 1st trimester, where there's no way that the baby has developed a dependence on nicotine but is certainly being harmed by the toxins floating around in their bodies. Idiocy.

and honestly, I'd prefer to see someone smoke during and after pregnancy and breastfeed than quit smoking and feed formula. sigh. good article though.
post #14 of 20
Good article! I also like what this article says about guilt:
http://www.fresnofamily.com/articles...urlanguage.htm
post #15 of 20
A good read. I'm very surprised at how many people choose formula for selfish reasons. I always thought breastfeeding was a given, so when I discovered some people don't for no particular reason, it shocked me. I have a friend who has never once tried to latch her son on, and just fed formula from the get-go. She was actually trying to convince me to formula feed when I was having troubles getting DS to latch (he still doesn't, but I'm pumping!) and she basically said, "Formula is so good now-a-days. It has all sorts of vitamins!" Like... umm... it has those vitamins because it's trying to mimic breastmilk! And it so obviously isn't the same. It doesn't even smell or look the same!

Anyway, yeah, good article. Jan seems like a great lady. I've been to her site lots for the tutorials!!
post #16 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by bri276
actually, I do know a couple of girls whose doctors advised them to KEEP smoking during the first trimester (!) because it would put more stress on the baby to quit cold turkey than to gradually phase smoking out. They made them feel like it was no big deal to smoke while pg. I'm talking early 1st trimester, where there's no way that the baby has developed a dependence on nicotine but is certainly being harmed by the toxins floating around in their bodies. Idiocy.

and honestly, I'd prefer to see someone smoke during and after pregnancy and breastfeed than quit smoking and feed formula. sigh. good article though.
I used to chat with a mom who's dr told her that stopping smoking would be to hard on her and the baby so she smoked all the way thru the pg and as far as I know is still smoking
post #17 of 20
Quote:
and honestly, I'd prefer to see someone smoke during and after pregnancy and breastfeed than quit smoking and feed formula.
and honestly, this sounds so stupid to me. can you please explain your reasons as to why you say that?
post #18 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by bri276
and honestly, I'd prefer to see someone smoke during and after pregnancy and breastfeed than quit smoking and feed formula. sigh. good article though.
I'm pretty sure smoking during pregnancy is far, far more dangerous to the baby than formula-feeding after the pregnancy.
post #19 of 20
Wow, that's a great article! Thanks SO much for posting this!
post #20 of 20
Well said!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Breastfeeding, Formula, and Guilt