Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › appalling advice
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

appalling advice  

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I recently gave birth to ds#2 who (as per my instructions) has remained intact. when the nurses at the hospital learned I would not be circing him I got conflicting advice. one (and the one i trust the most) said that she was happy I wasn't putting him through that (me too!) and that regardless what ANYONE says it doesn't need any special treatment and not to pull back the foreskin (which i already knew and thus why i trust it ) another told me that his ped would retract his foreskin at his first peds visit and I should continue that at every bath. (my response: she had better NOT and I surely will not retract my sons foreskin...EVER) yet another nurse told me that until he's *about 4 or 5 or so* I wouldn't need to do anything but once he hits the *magic* age I needed to start retracting it to clean under it.

his dr (thankfully) told me not to retract it...that he would do so himself at his own pace and quite like the vagina was a mostly self cleaning organ...once he hit puberty he would need to rinse under the foreskin at every shower but by then he would have retracted it himself.

I think its disgusting people are telling me to do something so invasive to my own ds. that would be like telling a mother of a girl she needs to stick her finger in her vagina at every bath. :
post #2 of 4
Quote:
Originally Posted by CalebsMama05
that would be like telling a mother of a girl she needs to stick her finger in her vagina at every bath. :
post #3 of 4
Quote:
Originally Posted by CalebsMama05
that would be like telling a mother of a girl she needs to stick her finger in her vagina at every bath. :
You're right about that. That's how I compare it too. If anyone was putting their finger or another object inside of a little girl to "clean her" they would be thrown in jail so fast their head would spin. It wouldn't matter if they were trying to do a good thing or if they were misinformed. It would be considered rape.

But ripping back a boy's foreskin, causing tears, bleeding, infections, and who knows what else? Absolutely ok and even advisable. : Totally disgusting. Doctors who rip back foreskins should be charged with rape. I wonder what would happen if parents started pressing charges??? I know if it happened to my son, I would be calling the cops from right there in the doctor's office. And if the doctor tried to say, "well, I'm a medical professional and I know what's best", I'd be pulling out the AAP statement which says NOT TO NO MATTER WHAT. And then I'd be taking photographs and documenting the pain and damage my son endured.

It's about time that doctors quit assauting little boys. And it stinks that parents are going to have to go this far to make it stop. But I truly believe that unless we make a huge fuss, it's going to continue.
post #4 of 4
That's how I think about it--if the doctor want's to do something to DS penis, would I let him do the same to DD vagina? The answer is useally absolutly not!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › appalling advice