So last night I was having a discussion with one of DH's friends about this. Of course, his friend thought it was a little odd to nurse past three (although he never assumed that you switch to formula for whatever reason at some age, so that was nice). We got on the subject of the 10yo nursing, and he was saying that kids who nursed past XYZ age have mental problems, more or less. So of course, we hashed it out, and I used the opportunity to be a real lactivist (IRL, not online! w00t!) The basic outcome was that he believed the 10yo might have had issues with attatchment (seeing as most kids want to be more independent at that age) but that nursing, while he was not really comfortable with the idea at that age, was still a bonding experience (never once did he mention anything about it being sexual
) and that it was taking place because of any possible delays rather than being the cause of them. So while we don't quite see it the same, he was informed of WHO standards, my views on the basic biological need to nurse, and a few unknown health benefits. He's very supportive of bf as a whole (assuming bf as the norm, no mention of formula feeding) and now a bit more educated and open-minded. I'm sure when he has children of his own his wife will get plenty of encouragement.
Join Now
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
Recent Reviews
-
My mom gave me this for Christmas and I absolutely love it. Gorgeous illustrations and very sweet ideas inside. Plus it's just structured enough so that I can be creative about what I include...
-
This is the prettiest carrier, and fit my shoulders and figure (at 5'6") much better than the Ergo. I got it when my daughter was about nine months, two years ago - it doesn't appear to have...
-
This potty is great - excellent value & performance! (plus it's cute!) My 9 month old DS took to it right away. He is a big boy (30 in. tall - feet not quite on floor - & 27 lbs.) and this is...
-
This book feels good in your hands. The paper is heavyweight, and the illustrations flow perfectly.
-
To anyone looking for a carrier, BECO is the brand! I recently had purchased the Gemini, great carrier! It has everything you will ever need and want, its ergonomic, comfy, organic, made...
On the subject of the 10yo nursing kid...
post #2 of 14
8/10/06 at 3:51am
- thefragile7393
- Trader Feedback: +4
- Just keep swimming!
-
- offline
- 2,731 Posts. Joined 6/2005
- Location: Tucson, AZ
- Select All Posts By This User
Let me get out my Milk, Money, And Madness book on breastfeeding and see where I can find where in one culture (an island culture) kids nurse until they are 15!
post #3 of 14
8/10/06 at 4:11am
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by thefragile7393
Let me get out my Milk, Money, And Madness book on breastfeeding and see where I can find where in one culture (an island culture) kids nurse until they are 15!
|
love and peace.

post #4 of 14
8/10/06 at 4:34am
The majority of our population cannot even imagine a 3 yo nursing. They think it is way too old. A few years ago there was something in the news about a 5yo nursing still and people were having a fit over it. I happen to have known 2 women who nursed kids over 5. It didn't seem weird at all. They never nursed around me because nursing a 5 or 6 yo is much different than nursing a 2 or 3 yo. They don't nurse every day. sometimes just once a week...whenever they feel it is needed for comfort. My dd is 5 now and has been weaned for over 2 years. I couldn't picture nursing her...she is just so big now to me.
Now a 10 yo and most definately a 15 yo nursing will definately freak the majority of people out. I'm weirded out by the thought. I have a 10 yo. son. Just this summer my sweet little boy started growing up and noticing things like girls and bikinis.
There is a certain point where breasts are not a means of nutrition only comfort, which is fine for young children and sometimes absolutely needed. But as one matures breasts are sexual. Girls who are growing them think of them as their feminity and sexual being. Boys are aroused by them. Especially 15 yo boys.
Where is the island that the 15 yos nursing anyway??? I'd like to see some info. 15yos (both male and female) can be procreating!
:
Now a 10 yo and most definately a 15 yo nursing will definately freak the majority of people out. I'm weirded out by the thought. I have a 10 yo. son. Just this summer my sweet little boy started growing up and noticing things like girls and bikinis.
There is a certain point where breasts are not a means of nutrition only comfort, which is fine for young children and sometimes absolutely needed. But as one matures breasts are sexual. Girls who are growing them think of them as their feminity and sexual being. Boys are aroused by them. Especially 15 yo boys.
Where is the island that the 15 yos nursing anyway??? I'd like to see some info. 15yos (both male and female) can be procreating!
:
post #5 of 14
8/10/06 at 8:51am
I know what you're saying momof, but in some cultures breastfeeding and breasts honestly do not have a sexual vibe like they do in the West. In some cultures they think Westerners are perverted for having a fetish for what is baby food (while hiding bare legs at all costs.) It's not wrong that we get turned on by breasts, but not all cultures feel or are socialized to feel that way.
post #6 of 14
8/10/06 at 11:52am
- nakagain
- Trader Feedback: +23
-
- offline
- 640 Posts. Joined 2/2004
- Location: at home!
- Select All Posts By This User
At work the girls were talking AF and I of course piped in and said "I don't remember, I really haven't had AF for over 6 years"
THese gals..most pre marriage and kids were amazed and asked me why. When I mention I'm nursing my 19 month old their eyes bugg even more and luckily one of the girls has a sister who nurses her 3 year old so when the gross "once they ask for it the should be done" started I luckily had some help on why I'm still nursing.
I'm not sure I changed any minds but at least I educated them a bit.
THese gals..most pre marriage and kids were amazed and asked me why. When I mention I'm nursing my 19 month old their eyes bugg even more and luckily one of the girls has a sister who nurses her 3 year old so when the gross "once they ask for it the should be done" started I luckily had some help on why I'm still nursing.
I'm not sure I changed any minds but at least I educated them a bit.
post #7 of 14
8/10/06 at 1:11pm
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Momtwice
I know what you're saying momof, but in some cultures breastfeeding and breasts honestly do not have a sexual vibe like they do in the West. In some cultures they think Westerners are perverted for having a fetish for what is baby food (while hiding bare legs at all costs.) It's not wrong that we get turned on by breasts, but not all cultures feel or are socialized to feel that way.
|
post #8 of 14
8/10/06 at 2:00pm
- TigerTail
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Bon Viveur
-
- offline
- 9,368 Posts. Joined 12/2002
- Location: I'm finally here!
- Select All Posts By This User
Has this become an urban legend now or something? The last time we heard from RespondentMom I don't remember anything about him being ten; I'd like to see an article where SHE says so instead of 'about' him doing so (but if he is, I'd wager it's an attachment issue alright, since they took him from her for heaven's sake! (who else was here back in the day with a kid who nursed a similarly long time?
we should have a reunion. Me, Firemom, who else?)
we should have a reunion. Me, Firemom, who else?)
post #9 of 14
8/10/06 at 3:00pm
- Firemom
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 1,226 Posts. Joined 11/2001
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Select All Posts By This User
I missed something here. A 10 year old nursing?
Being that I nursed my daughter until she was close to 6 years I can't imagine a 10 year old nursing.
Respondentmom's son weaned a few months shy of his 8th birthday. She was at my house and we celebrated his 8th birthday. He weaned a few months before.
I guess it is possible for a 10 year old to be nursing somewhere in this world, but my dd is going on 10 years and is showing signs of puberty. I just can't imagine her wanting to nurse.
Being that I nursed my daughter until she was close to 6 years I can't imagine a 10 year old nursing.
Respondentmom's son weaned a few months shy of his 8th birthday. She was at my house and we celebrated his 8th birthday. He weaned a few months before.
I guess it is possible for a 10 year old to be nursing somewhere in this world, but my dd is going on 10 years and is showing signs of puberty. I just can't imagine her wanting to nurse.
post #10 of 14
8/10/06 at 3:03pm
I have a 7 yr old and honestly cant imagine nursing him at that age
:
:
post #11 of 14
8/10/06 at 3:34pm
Me too....He's almost 70 lbs!!
:
:
post #12 of 14
8/10/06 at 7:14pm
- Meredith&Alexander
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 500 Posts. Joined 5/2005
- Location: Keller, TX
- Select All Posts By This User
Well, when I had a newborn I couldn't imagine BFing a 6 month old, and certainly not a robust almost-3-year-old. It's all relative to me.
- frontierpsych
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 6,397 Posts. Joined 6/2006
- Location: Where the other 4999 Bensoners are...
- Select All Posts By This User
Yeah, my main point was how glad I was that he didn't automatically believe there was something sick or sexual about it, which is more than you can ask of many people when you talk about nursing a 4yo!
post #14 of 14
8/10/06 at 9:07pm
- thefragile7393
- Trader Feedback: +4
- Just keep swimming!
-
- offline
- 2,731 Posts. Joined 6/2005
- Location: Tucson, AZ
- Select All Posts By This User
Okay found my link!
Milk, Money, & Madness: The Culture and Politics of Breastfeeding, by Naomi Baumslag MD & Dia L. Michels
Chapter 1, Customs around the World, page 35:"In the Solomon Islands, breastfeeding continued until the children were fifteen. Cultural attitudes, more than any stadard for infant nutrition, generally tend to dictate how long women breastfeed."
Milk, Money, & Madness: The Culture and Politics of Breastfeeding, by Naomi Baumslag MD & Dia L. Michels
Chapter 1, Customs around the World, page 35:"In the Solomon Islands, breastfeeding continued until the children were fifteen. Cultural attitudes, more than any stadard for infant nutrition, generally tend to dictate how long women breastfeed."
This thread is locked
Currently, there are 1578 Active Users
(162 Members and 1416 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › Need to vent to a supportive group 2 minutes ago
- › How is your baby sleeping? Any suggestions welcome! 2 minutes ago
- › 3y/o DAYCARE POTTY PROBLEMS :/ 7 minutes ago
- › The ONE Thread Feb 5 - 12 7 minutes ago
- › Anyone not telling family?? 9 minutes ago
- › Need help dealing with special needs neighbor 13 minutes ago
- › Feb 6 Weekly Chat 13 minutes ago
- › 10-15 Minute Cleaning Sessions (New Thread) 13 minutes ago
- › Where's your uterus these days? 15 minutes ago
- › weekly chat feb 6-12 16 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › The First 1000 Days: A Baby Journal by MrsKatie
- › Beco Butterfly II Carrier by capucine
- › Fisher-Price Precious Planet Froggy Friend Potty by pickle18
- › Embrace: A Pregnancy Journal by mama kk
- › Beco Baby Carrier Gemini by 2jmama
- › Bummis Super Whisper Wrap by sweetBBkendall
- › BabyHawk Oh SNAP! Baby Carrier by 2jmama
- › Raising Abel by lauren
- › Keter 115-gallon Capacity Super Composter by MonarchMom
- › Gaiam Pencil Skirt by Melanie Mayo
View: More Reviews
Recent Articles
- › Contest Terms and Conditions -... by Cynthia Mosher
- › Contest Terms and Conditions - Sasquatch... by JenniO11
- › Teach Your Children Spanish With Little Pim by John Martin
- › How to Start a Social Group by Cynthia Mosher
- › Boba Carrier 3G Giveaway Contest Rules by MDCLurker
- › Best of Mothering 2011 Official Rules by MDCLurker
- › Babywearing Basics by Peggy O'Mara
- › Groups Guidelines by Cynthia Mosher
- › Sex Talk Forum by almadianna
- › Nfp Or Fam Methods While Breastfeeding by JMJ
View: Recent Articles | All Articles
Home | Reviews & More | Forums | Articles | My Profile
About Mothering | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Mothering is powered by Huddler Families | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
About Mothering | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Mothering is powered by Huddler Families | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map






