Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Help me convince my bf
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Help me convince my bf  

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 
My bf and family (baby's dad) is very mainstream (and honestly, I used to be, too...you ladies converted me ). I know there's no way that I can convince him to do a homebirth with this baby. I'm planning on a natural hospital birth (if such a thing is possible), and am hoping that if all goes well with this one (and why wouldn't it?), I'll be able to convince him of a homebirth the next time around.

It's going to take alot. He's certain that it's some barbaric practice that it long out of date. He's also positive that something is going to go wrong that we're going to want to be at the hospital. So where do I start with this guy? Anyone know of some resources that I can use to convince him?
post #2 of 19
The way I see it is, you're the one doing all the work, so why should you have the birth he wants instead of the one you want?

If simply telling him this is what you want and it's important to you doesn't work, I would get a bunch of midwifery and natural birth books and read him quote after quote after statistic until his eyes glaze over.
post #3 of 19
i would find a midwife that you like and trust and bring him along to an appointment. sometimes they just need to see a midwife in person to realize that it really is not a wacko thing to have a homebirth
post #4 of 19
Check out the library for books on birth. I know there are some really good "natural" birth books, but I can not think of the names. If he is not into reading them, you read them and talk through them as you go (but in a "WOW! Listen to this!" way not in a "You need to know this" way). That is what got my DH so into HB. By the time I was done, he had been educated without him ever even knowing it!
post #5 of 19
Don't forget to keep mentioning all the "bad" stastics about hospital birth. It will plant a seed in his mind that hosptials may not be such a great place after all, and he will be more open to other suggestions. Anyway, it shouldn't hurt.
post #6 of 19
Show him how much work midwives have to do to get certified. Here's one school, there are subpages showing how many hours of coursework they must do and how many births they must attend in an apprenticeship. I explain to people that it's as much work as med school, just a different model, and that helps them understand that midwives aren't just random people who wander into your house and catch the baby:

http://www.birthingway.org/

ETA: why wait for your homebirth? I just had my first at home and honestly I think first-timers have even MORE reason to go with midwives at home than anyone else. We tend to take longer, for one thing, and it's better to be at home in a relaxing environment with attendants who aren't watching the clock. I almost certainly would have had an induction, section, or both in a hospital simply because I was at it for a long time. All 9 lbs 4 oz of my daughter was born at home after a very long second stage by hospital standards, and I know a number of homebirthers who were at it substantially longer than I was.
post #7 of 19
Tell BF that if he gets pregnant, he can choose what is most comfortable to him, be that HB or hospital. And you will respect his wishes, because you know it will be important to him.

Also, if he comes up with vague statisitcs, I mean opinions, then ask him specifically "Exactly how/why is it safer/more dangerous...? Please give me some real facts, not your opinion here." If he actually has to do the work to research his issues, he will find out the truth on his own, which willl be much more real and valid to him. Ad give him some books to read, telling him he can rediscuss it after he is finished. And definetely take him to the mw consultation, they deal with this issue all the time.
post #8 of 19
Knowledge is power. Rent some homebirth videos, buy some books and ask him to read them. I don't have any other suggestions, but I'm sure someone here will! GL!
post #9 of 19
Why should you convince anyone? You're having the baby, it's up to them to show hospital birth is safer!

You will birth this baby only once, don't sacrifice it for other people's feelings. I mean it.
post #10 of 19
yeah that- how far along are you now?

I had my first baby in a hospoital.

Good for you
post #11 of 19
Thread Starter 
Just a quickie post before I go to work: I'm 20 wks.
post #12 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by mandib50
i would find a midwife that you like and trust and bring him along to an appointment. sometimes they just need to see a midwife in person to realize that it really is not a wacko thing to have a homebirth
I agree- have him write down a list of all his concerns and "what if" questions and ask them to her. My boyfriend got on board 100% after he met and talked with our midwife.

I was 20 weeks when I switched to a homebirth midwife too! Best of luck.
post #13 of 19
My friend and her husband took a Bradley class, with a person who apparently has quite a slant towards moving couples from hospital to birth center or homebirth -- apparently the questions and "defending yourself against the hospital" data was really impactful, and it worked on her husband, and they switched to a homebirth practice at 35 weeks.

Before we got pregnant, My DH was skeptical, but I did tons of research on our local options, and presented my case (this is the kind of birth I want, I dont seem to find data on local places that will support me in that...), Then, after meeting with the homebirth midwives that we ultimately chose, and hearing her stats, reviewing the research himself and reading through the Thinking Womans guide to a better birth by Henci Goer (Midwife suggested it to him), he got on board all the way.

We've got a lot of mainstream friends, so it isnt the easiest choice to make b/c lots of people look at us with wide eyes, but as long as DH and me feel good about homebirth, I dont see why anyone else's opinion matters.

Good luck!!!
post #14 of 19
My DH didn't want anything other than hospital, but he didn't mind a midwife IN a hospital. So i found a MW at a birth center. And over time, after coming to appointments and asking questions, he decided that the BC would be OK. This time, he is teetering b/t BC and HB. I think over time he will agree w/ the HB. A far path from the hospital only attitued w/ #1.
post #15 of 19
Get him to read The Thinking Woman's Guide to a Better Birth by Henci Goer. Show him this study:

http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/conte...7505/1416?ehom

Meet with a MW and let him ask any questions he might have.
post #16 of 19
Also, this book by Henci Goer is great, and very scientifically based if that might appeal to him. Obstetric Myths Versus Reasearch Realities, but really I second the suggestion to meet with a midwife and have him direct his concerns to her. Many people have an image of a midwife as being kind of uneducated, and a few minutes of question and answer often can clear that up.
post #17 of 19
you can still hav e a hb this tyime. contact a hb mw. now.
post #18 of 19
I agree... why do the hospital now? Show him the info you have, and explain to him that YOU want to do a homebirth. It's not too late to switch providers... not until the baby is out.

My DH is very skeptical of just about anything natural/alternative (but was all for bf'ing until the child self-weans ). When I first suggested the idea of an out-of-hospital birth, he said "Absolutely NOT". Wouldn't even discuss it!

I did my research online, found tons of links on homebirth safety, etc. (that's the main thing he was worried about - the thought of losing his wife and first child). There are plenty of studies showing that homebirth is SAFER than hospital birth, so start there. I also found links to pages that had alot of the common hospital practices (like episiotomies) and why you don't want them. I explained that I was not comfortable in a hospital just visiting someone else, let alone birthing in one! He read the info I sent, and finally agreed that homebirth was a safe option.

Next, I took him with me to interview the midwife. Choices are limited here, but thankfully we do have a good one available to us (we're in an illegal state, but I'm 15 minutes from the state line, and my midwife has a birth house there - really close to my house!). We met over lunch and DH was able to ask questions. She explained some of the emergency type things she's capable of handling and has handled in the past. She told stories of complications that had occurred and how she dealt with them, with mom and baby being perfectly fine. Some required hospital transport, but most did not. After meeting and talking with her, DH felt that she would indeed be capable of dealing with complications that could arise in childbirth, and he agreed to using her instead of going to the hospital.

I ended up birthing in a hospital anyway, since my baby decided to come at 29 weeks. But with the education I'd given DH about natural childbirth and hospital interventions and such, DH was better able to support me in the hospital setting, including helping me avoid medication which he knew I wanted to do (even though he originally thought I wouldn't be able to handle the pain without drugs!). He was my rock in the hospital, and was on the phone with my midwife asking her questions and such. He was still skeptical of the midwife, but he was skeptical of the doctors/nurses too, and the midwife made more scientific sense! The nurses hated him because he was advocating for me and would NOT budge.

Needless to say, it was no question that we'd be planning an out-of-hospital birth with the midwife this second time as well. DH even saved the money from the first one (since I went early, I never had to pay for her to go on call), so we'd have it for this one.
post #19 of 19
Homebirth Safety Resources
The following are resources MDC members found helpful for convincing family members of the safety of homebirth:

Articles & Links:
British Medical Journal study
http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articl...ogyinbirth.asp
http://gentlebirth.org/archives/prntshar.html
http://www.homebirthdallas.org/HANDWebResources
http://www.texas-midwife.com/ishomebirthsafe.htm
http://gentlebirth.org/archives/prntshar.html
http://www.geocities.com/Wellesley/5510/studies.html
http://home.earthlink.net/~eaglefalc...irthoprah.html
http://www.homebirth.org.uk/homebirthindex.htm
http://www.healthychild.com/database..._like_home.htm
http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articl...irthchoice.asp
http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articles/gracious.asp
http://www.birthpsychology.com/violence/odent1.html
http://www.acegraphics.com.au/articles/wagner01.html
http://www.birthpsychology.com/birthscene/otoday4.html
http://www.changesurfer.com/Hlth/homebirth.html

Books:

Immaculate Deception by Suzanne Arms
Special Delivery by Rahima Baldwin Dancy
Birth at Home by Sheila Kitzinger
The Cultural Warping of Childbirth by Doris Haire
The Home Birth Book by Charlotte and Fred Ward
Natural Childbirth the Bradley Way by Susan McCutcheon-Rosegg
Active Birth by Janet Balaskas
Birth Without Violence by Frederick Leboyer
Birth Reborn by Michael Odent
The Birth Partner by Penny Simkin
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Homebirth
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Homebirth › Help me convince my bf