Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Weisbluth - good guy or bad guy?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Weisbluth - good guy or bad guy? - Page 3  

post #41 of 46
Please be gentle with one another, we all have differing opinions, and while Mothering does not endorse or approve Weisbluth, it is permitted for discussion as long as we don't resort to snarkiness, namecalling and baiting behavior (see the UA)

TIA for your cooperation,

Kelly
post #42 of 46
Moved from Nighttime parenting to Books and Media.
post #43 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by ACsMom View Post
A friend of mine, who is pretty down with AP, recently recommended this book to me.
Same with me, when I was a new mom, so I took their advice and bought the book figuring it was something that would work with cosleeping breastfeeding AP tyhpes. Also because my husband was stressed out by the sleeping situation. Definitely not a good idea, not a loving way of doing things as far as I am concerned. He did allow you to rock your child or nurse her to sleep, but then you were supposed to move her to the crib and leave her there, not going back at intervals to soothe as you might with Ferber. So it is true CIO which can be damaging. Children have different personalities and there are some you can just lay down in a crib or on a bed and they will fall asleep. And there are some for whom that will never work.

I tried to figure out why my friends liked it, and when I think back on their recommendation, it was that they liked understanding how much and why their kids need sleep. I think feeling like you are doing something for their good, even if they don't like it and cry, makes it easier to go through with it, but I think it differs from tantruming situations where you don't want to give in and let them have whatever they want. I tried it for awhile, and I feel that it hurt my child and our relationship. I would nurse my daughter to sleep in my bed and then move her into the crib. Sometimes she would stay awake and sometimes not, but she usually woke up after being placed in the crib. She would cry until she vomited sometimes. I stopped doing it once she vomited into the crib as I was lifting her into it.
post #44 of 46
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BelovedK View Post
Mothering does not endorse or approve Weisbluth
Ah. That's what I was looking for. That statement along with all the other replies have definitely given me a good review of this book, and I want to thank everyone even though the discussion got a little dicey...
post #45 of 46
wow! I was just at the pediatrician today, talking about sleep issues for my 10 month old.. he was very enthusiastic about Weissbluth. I had never heard of the guy, but figured I would just get the book on Amazon... after I checked in with MDC. So glad I did......
post #46 of 46
Thread Starter 
Ah, yes, I remember this thread! Well, I'm happy to report that my now almost-3 year old is sleeping much better, without Weisbluth's help, thank you very much! We got through it, we did.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Weisbluth - good guy or bad guy?