Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › home school -vs- home business
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

home school -vs- home business  

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
I am not currently homeschooling, so I am asking this question for a friend.

My friend homeschools her two sons at home, ages 13 and 7.

She has taken the older boy to a group to share instruction duties with other mothers. They meet periodically, and her son receives instruction in history, math, computers, English and writing with different mothers who specialize in that subject matter.

My friend has been doing this for six years. She knows these mothers and they know her. She is comfortable with them. She trusts them.

Suddenly, a couple of weeks ago, a official came from the city and said that some complaints had been made as to an unlicensed home business being done at her address. Apparently, someone had seen many cars parked outside her home and children going in to her home. The official demanded to be allowed to enter and the owner of the home refused. The official said he would be back with a court ordered subpeona to allow him to enter. He was looking for evidence of business being conducted and $ exchanging hands. $ does pay for the books and materials, as $ would for Girl/Boy Scout activities and 4-H.

A home business would have to register and pay business taxes to the city; there would be a hearing held, and all of the neighbors would be notified and advised to attend. The area could be rezoned, which could affect property values.

That is where it is now.

This is in Los Angeles where illegal home businesses flourish; a friend of mine in Orange County has a neighbor who sells used cars from his home, and parks the cars up and down the street every day, even when the street is supposed to be swept. I have seen houses around here advertising for psychic readings and botanicals. I have a neighbor who has a garage sale every day. I have other neighbors who care for children for $ without a county permit.

Has anyone ever had this problem?

If so, what did you do?
post #2 of 8
I dont have any answers but I live in OC too and I know lots of people who do business from their homes without a permit....it sounds like some neighbors got a little too nosy and called the authorities : I'm sorry your friend is dealing with this.....
post #3 of 8
Why don't they just say they are a homeschooling co-op and money is not exhanged. But why would it matter anyway? Its not a business.

Nice neighbors.:
post #4 of 8
I have no advice -- I don't even live in the US -- but ugh! for your friend.

LA is in California, right? Don't you technically have to be a private school there to homeschool? Maybe there's some kind of problem that way.

She did the right thing not letting them in. I hope this all just ends here. Ugh.
post #5 of 8
Thread Starter 
Thank you.

I do not know if she has a private school affidavit, but the neighbors complain about the 40+ children who arrive for lessons periodically. I can find out; as a matter of fact, these are due in two weeks. The mothers share tutoring duties and only ask for reimbursement for material copying and ink.

As I said, in Los Angeles, anyone can open a business selling oranges on the corner or freeway exit. I like laws to be evenly enforced, I do not like to be strong-armed with simple things like this.
post #6 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by miriam View Post
I do not know if she has a private school affidavit, but the neighbors complain about the 40+ children who arrive for lessons periodically. I can find out; as a matter of fact, these are due in two weeks. The mothers share tutoring duties and only ask for reimbursement for material copying and ink.
It sounds like they should be ok legally, but 40+ kids is a LOT. I can kind of see the neighbors' point. Could they seek out another place to meet (like a church or community center?)

ZM
post #7 of 8
Hmmm. I haven't been in this situation, but I'm one to "fight fire with fire", as the saying goes.

I wonder if she would do well to meet with an attorney and have them file a cease & desist order, citing that she is being persecuted for lawful behavior. Homeschooling is legal. Gathering in her private home is legal. As long as the parking isn't a chronic problem (i.e. cars parked illegally at each meeting), she's really not doing anything wrong, is she?

There are many reasons why groups of people gather regularly: bridge club, book club, highschool float building and prom meetings. The only difference is that these activities tend to happen in the evening, after "regular business hours". Is throwing a Tupperware party - or any other type of home catalog party - in your home illegal? That's a business venture, but I'm sure there is no law against it... what if somebody threw such a party once a month, inviting a sales person from a different company each time? It might annoy the neighbors, but I doubt it would be illegal. (I'm really just rambling at this point.)

Anyway, I suspect that, if the city (or county) received something proactive from her, they would back down. And, if not, I doubt it would last long before the court.
post #8 of 8
Thread Starter 
I understand the mother has notified the CHSDF for help. I have never really know them to do much but collect $ membership, but I hope it helps.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › home school -vs- home business