Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Circumcision and...Lit class?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Circumcision and...Lit class?  

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
I am still quite new here (well, I've lurked for years, but I just started posting again), but I want to share this story. I'm taking a Literature class this semester, and we recently read a short story about a sweet, placid little country town. It opens up with a beautiful morning, crisp fall air, and happy children playing outside. By the end, this perfect town - children included - has convened for a yearly meeting and chosen to stone a perfectly innocent woman. They draw a name, and then they kill the person. This is modern day - at least fairly - they have a post office and cars and electricity, of course. Anyway, it's a tradition in the town, and although there are a few dissenters, the majority believe that their crops will fail and terrible things will happen if they don't sacrifice someone each year.

So, this opened up a discussion in my class about culture and tradition and how it can evoke intelligent, typically kind people to commit unspeakable horrors. Many people discussed examples from other countries/continents of present day real examples of this phenomenon. Others expressed relief that they live here in the US where such things NEVER happen. So, of course, I had to point out that they do happen - we cut apart the genitals of baby boys for no reason other than culture (and misinformation) every day.

It was an interesting discussion. I expected some disagreement - and got it - one person even later complained to the professor. However, others spoke up in agreement, and the professor agreed that it is, indeed, a legitimate example.

I never thought I'd be discussing circumcision in Lit class!
post #2 of 16
"The Lottery" ...such an interesting little story that sparks great debate in class. It's good to hear that younger generations (is this a college class?) are catching on to this. They are the future parents!

If I return to the classroom (Im an English teacher- SAHM right now), I will be teaching that story again. I probably can't bring up circumcision in my classroom tho; I can just imagine the phone calls!!!
post #3 of 16
Awesome. What a great way to get the message out, to the age group that really matters.

Thank you for displaying such courage.
post #4 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by sandals View Post
"The Lottery" ...such an interesting little story that sparks great debate in class. It's good to hear that younger generations (is this a college class?) are catching on to this. They are the future parents!

If I return to the classroom (Im an English teacher- SAHM right now), I will be teaching that story again. I probably can't bring up circumcision in my classroom tho; I can just imagine the phone calls!!!
I dunno.. If you bring it up with other examples, or bring up FGM (and hope that someone asks about a circumcision comparrison) you could possibly do it..
post #5 of 16
Cultural myths are broken every day by our choices and our voices. Thanks for speaking up.

Pat
post #6 of 16
I may try it. Perhaps a list of "traditions" that seem to reflect the story in the USA or ask the class to help generate the list.
post #7 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by sandals View Post
I may try it. Perhaps a list of "traditions" that seem to reflect the story in the USA or ask the class to help generate the list.
Great idea!! You could make a handout with a list of things and some blanks at the bottom for them to fill in.. So that they both get an idea of things that are both unjust and unquestioned, and the process that you undertake making those injustices right.
post #8 of 16
Awesome. I respect you for being able to discuss circumcision in your classroom setting with people you will see time and again. That takes courage.

I try to do this about circ and other topics I am passionate about, (hunting, vegetarianism, animal rights, etc) and I am always apprehensive in intimate settings.
post #9 of 16
Very interesting....listening to that story sounded SO farmiliar and I just realized that I saw a movie about it once.

That is a good comparison!
post #10 of 16
Very gutsy and awesome of you to bring up circumcision in lit class! Way to go.
post #11 of 16
I always bring up circ in my general biology (9th grade) when we do "ethics". I give them some info. and then ask them point blank "Does anyone have the right to tie down another human being and cut them up? yes or no." They always say "no". I've never had any parent complain, yet.
post #12 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by jee'smom View Post
I always bring up circ in my general biology (9th grade) when we do "ethics". I give them some info. and then ask them point blank "Does anyone have the right to tie down another human being and cut them up? yes or no." They always say "no". I've never had any parent complain, yet.
Awesome!!! I think teachers are in a great position to make an impact on children. I truly believe that the next generation (my ds) that circumcision will not be considered routine anymore.
post #13 of 16
and to all teachers and students who mention the harm done by circumcision in their classes! That's a wonderful way to inform the next generation.
post #14 of 16
Quote:
Originally Posted by jee'smom View Post
I always bring up circ in my general biology (9th grade) when we do "ethics". I give them some info. and then ask them point blank "Does anyone have the right to tie down another human being and cut them up? yes or no." They always say "no". I've never had any parent complain, yet.
AWESOME!!!!
post #15 of 16
I was just thinking that a military draft is sort of like a 'lottery' in a similar sense, eh?

Jen
post #16 of 16
I've been back in school for a week now and already in both my english class and in my psych class twice now, we have brought up circing. Of course, I was the one to bring it up, not my professors, the first time, but my psych prof did bring it up again during the second class. On top of that, I am doing a presentation the week after next on the psycho-social development of infants-2 year olds and am trying to work it into that too....
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › Circumcision and...Lit class?