
I suppose it's more reasonable to say "Most people will tell you that they need to be in a straight line (excepting the shamash, of course) but others hold that it's fine for the candles to be out of line as long as they're the same hieght. Still others hold that niether hieght nor line is important, as long as the shamash is easily distinguished from the others."

:
When I was in elementary school, one of our classes made channukiot one year. My mother walked into the classroom, pointed out all the ones without straight lines and said, "Did you know that you can't use these? The candles have to line up." Two of the town's three rabbis agreed with her, and many of us were bummed (myself included) to have to change our work.

Follow Mothering