Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › why do I feel this way?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

why do I feel this way?  

post #1 of 17
Thread Starter 
So many times when we attend a family celebration where gifts are exchanged I walk away feeling like we are thought of as cheap. No one has ever said this, but I just get that feeling. This last weekend for example, we went to DH's nephew's first birthday and everybody else brought $50 toys and we bought a DVD and pajamas. Both which matched the theme of his party!! (His mom didn't even want toys because I asked what she wanted and bought accordingly). Anyway, it just bothers me afterwards. When I first came into DH's family they weren't like this but they have all moved and now have a totally different social circle and now it's kind of like everybody has to outdo everybody else. Christmas is likely going to be the same way.

I put a lot of thought into our gifts and I often ask about the interests of the person that I'm buying for. We gave Dh's parents some decorations for a room in their home that they were re-decorating and that was 2 years ago and they're still hanging in the room and match perfectly with the decor and color scheme. (just an example) Also, DSIL asked for some very practical gifts for her birthday this year and even last weekend she was using them. I just don't feel that spending a lot of money necessarily equals a good gift.

The other thing is that there are 21 in our family much less friends parties that we attend each year and Christmas when we buy for everyone and that puts a huge dent in our budget. At $50 a gift we would be spending over $2500.00 a year just on gifts. That just isn't doable.

Why do you think I feel this way? I know that you all will understand here, but how do you make yourself feel better about this kind of thing??
post #2 of 17
WOW! I would so much rather have an item that I can use over & over again than something someone bought *just because*.
What one year old needs a $50.00 toy??? You were right on target with the PJ's & DVD since 1) they will be used and 2) they were what the child was into (theme wise).

Keep on doing what you are doing!!!
post #3 of 17
Oh, I bet that your family spends the year thinking, "I wish I could give as good of presents as threekstrio." Then, they figure they can't or don't want to put forth the effort or whatever, go out, and they spend 50 bucks.

They are probably jealous of your good gift giving.

And, I'm totally serious here. Sounds like you give GREAT stuff.
post #4 of 17
Quote:
Oh, I bet that your family spends the year thinking, "I wish I could give as good of presents as threekstrio." Then, they figure they can't or don't want to put forth the effort or whatever, go out, and they spend 50 bucks.

They are probably jealous of your good gift giving.
Exactly -- spending too much on a present is what happens when you're not thoughtful *enough*, or have left it till the last minute.
post #5 of 17
I understand the feeling on some level as I'm always making gifts (last year it was mostly scarves and hats, this year, bracelets mostly) instead of going out and "buying" things. Even when I do buy, alot of the time it's thrift store buys.

I think, especially since your gifts get used, that you may want to try to look at it and realize that your gifts are useful and a blessing. And those that think $50 gifts are wonderful...keep in mind that those gifts don't always get appreciated....nor are they still being enjoyed 2 years later...
post #6 of 17
s


everyone thinks i'm cheap, and they know it's because i'm poor. they can deal with it. if they don't appreciate my home-made bread and hand-knit scarves, they can give it to someone who will.
post #7 of 17
I love homemade bread and hand knit scarves!!! My best friend is making me a scarf this year and I am so excited. Those things actually take time and thought. You don't waste time knitting a scarf for someone you don't care about. I wouldn't feel bad at all. The little boy is going to wear his pjs and watch the dvd and forget about his other toys
post #8 of 17
It's the American Christmas machine mama! You are supposed to feel bad if you don't go into debt buying gifts! Commercialism baby!

This year we're giving each of our 10 nieces and nephews a crisp $10 to buy whatever they want rather than some useless junk they don't want. Besides it adds variety to their gifts! We don't know what our nieces and nephews want and I can assure you the 17yo would rather ahve a $10 than socks or a calender! LOL!
post #9 of 17
AuntLavender, your post reminded me ~ i want to add that i would rather receive nothing for christmas from someone (or better yet, only a heartfelt "Merry Christmas") than to have that someone go out and buy me something i don't want, need, or like, simply because they felt obligated to buy me *something*.

i hate that mentality ~ "buy buy buy for every single person in your life." blah.

i think it's fabulous you're letting them choose their own gifts.
post #10 of 17
Thank you for this thread! I was feeling bad about the things I have made and you reminded me that all of my time hasn't been wasted!
post #11 of 17
You know my mom never gave us lots of gifts and I've done the same with my children and I think it makes me feel insecure giving gifts. Therefore I'm constantly thinking is it enough. For example I have bath pkgs for my children's teachers and I'm constantly thinking I need to make sure they know I don't think they smell. overanalyzing it's a gift. :rofl I think your present was awesome. A lot of times I just give the dvd or the pjs not both.
post #12 of 17
I would never buy a 50 dollar toy.... toys are one of the easiest things to get cheap (meaning there are lots of sales/clearances/discounts). I can easily spend ten bucks on a great toy thats of a 20 or more dollar value. I think the DVD and pjs are a great gift. Expensive toys for a one year old is riduclous IMO. Its not like they care...they're amused with anything.
post #13 of 17
I love getting clothes for DS when an occasion pops up (Christmas, birthday). It just means less I have to buy for him. DVDs are good ideas too, as well as books. I love to read, and I hope to instill that love in my son as well. Plus, those are gifts that are USEFUL and not just plastic to junk up the living room, playroom, etc.
post #14 of 17
Since I graduated from high school I have struggled financially, and at first I thought I was horrible for giving gifts that were inexpensive or home made, but as time went on I got better and better at finding things that my family would want and use, and I look back at the gifts I recieve and a lot of them are sitting in storage or gone because I didn't use them. Most of the gifts I give are gifts you use up (like food or beauty products) so I know they are not sitting around cluttering my family's homes.
My favorite example is my nephews. As the first two grandchildren on both sides of their families they are absolutly spoiled. Every year they have an enormous birthday party, and three Christmas parties! They have every toy they could imagine and a bunch I bet they'd never thought of. After babysitting them several times I realised that they don't even play with them! So, in an effort to keep the toy room under control at my sister's house, and to give a gift I think the boys will actually use, I gave them board games. They love them, and my sister says they play with them all the time. At $5 apiece for two games I didn't break the bank and they were the boys' favorite birthday gifts this year.
For Christmas I'm making two small toys for each boy that I know they don't have, but can use in a lot of ways. I've made a set of bean bags for each boy (10 total) and I spy bags. All with materials I already had. I don't feel guilty about being frugal anymore because I know I am giving gifts that are enjoyed and meaninful. In comparison to a gift card or an unwanted gift that was expensive I feel great about my gifts!
You should too! I wish everyone gave gifts with so much meaning!
post #15 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by AuntLavender View Post
It's the American Christmas machine mama! You are supposed to feel bad if you don't go into debt buying gifts! Commercialism baby!
!
That sums it up for me. We stopped giving gifts a few years ago. Hated the cost, hated the exchange, hated it all. Now we concentrate on the Christ Mass and we love the holiday! We spend money on a gift for a child on the giving tree at church. We have a 4 yr old and a 1 yr old we buy for. (Both ages of my girls). It bothers some people but what really gets them is we dont want gifts given to us either. I am sick of chemical laden perfume soaps, shirts for dh that dont fit or he dosent like, expensive chocolate that is not fair trade etc....

If we go to a holiday whatever, we will bring a bottle of wine or something if we know the hosts will enjoy, or a bag of fresh roasted coffee or tea that dh did himself. I also include my homemade bannana bread or italian cookies I made. Havent had anyone complain yet. And whoever does, we will skip their thing the next year! For teachers etc I have a cookie can filled w homemade goodies or I give them a giftcard to the teachers' store. We also tip our mailman every xmas, our waste guys, and who ever else we see all the time who will always go and do an extra favor or whatever.
post #16 of 17
Amy - I'd LOVE to know how you get people not to give you gifts!! I can't seem to do it. When I've presented the idea, they (my entire side of family, as well as ex's HUGE family that still buy us presents) interpret it as we're too poor to buy many presents for others, and they feel sorry for poor, pitiful us, so they're going to spend lots of money on meaningless, unpractical gifts for us. As if we'd be living on the sidewalk if it wasn't for bag full of dollar store crap they sent (for each of us, that is : ). It really REALLY bothers me!! My brother, for example and his wife are sickeningly materialistic... I really feel if they want to buy something, at least just buy for the kids, my brother and I are grownups, and don't need to be buying present for each other anymore. So when he pestered and pestered what I wanted, I finally told him some nice Smartwool socks. He said this wasn't a "good enough" request, since it was practical, and I should be requesting something that was more personal (what? a spa package?). Good God! I just don't get it!

How can I get across that we are not poor, we just choose to spend our money on meaningful things, or save it for buying a house, education, etc. And how can I let them know I really don't appreciate their little pity party, without getting banished from the family?? UGH! Sorry for the vent. Ex's folks are coming next weekend to bring a butt-load (sorry for that word, I can think of no better way to describe) of crappy presents.
post #17 of 17
Julie, can you come to my house for xmas?? We would love to have you guys!!

I think your brother and sil are also my brother and sil. IT took a few years in the process but it is finally sinking in- WE DONT WANT ANY MORE STUFF!!!!!

We are not poor by any stretch of the imagination in love and in $$s. Whenever someone has asked me what I want for xmas, I say "I already got it this year. We are so blessed." I finally had to tell DSIL, we dont need anything, if we want something we go and get it. I also said a few years ago I did a mass declutter and 90% of what went out the door was stuff gifted to us by many people. It leads me to believe gifts I have given are also in many closets stuffed somewhere. Thats a huge waste IMO and I know also yours!

Another reply I have had for people asking why we are not receiving- we sponsor a charity. Take the money you would have spent on us and pick one as well. I would hate to take away from someone out there who wont get anything.

good luck and stick to it!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Frugality & Finances
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › why do I feel this way?