Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › homework issues
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

homework issues  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
My eldest son (8 years) is in 3rd grade and we still have nearly daily dramas about homework (procrastinating start and "dawdling" while finally at it). I've tried different things to make it easier on both of us, for example start at a designated time and limit the time spent on homework. Yet, the "remind - nag, nag - shout" spiral occurs too often for my taste (and shouting is definitely not my idea of teaching responsibillity for your share of work).
So, I am ready for many suggestions on gentle discipline and homework - thank you!
post #2 of 6
Sorry, I can't help with advice. I just wanted to ask if there are any consequences at school (other than lower grades) for failing to complete homework. My crew (3rd, 4th, and 5th) have to miss recess and go to the 'homework room' to work on things they fail to do. If they finish early, they still have to stay inside and read.
post #3 of 6
I would just have him experience the natural consequence, whatever the teacher's policy on no hw happens to be. If things are like what the above poster said, and he loses his recess, then I'm sure this problem at home will end soon. I would maybe write a little note to the teacher telling her what is going on at home, that you know he did not finish his hw, and that instead of punishing him at home, you are having him experience the natural consequence.
post #4 of 6
The natural concequence of not doing homework depends on the child. Some kids are bright enough for homework to not really teaching them anything. Mindless repetition. For others it is that they don't aquire the necessary understanding of the subject at hand.

Anything else, including routinely lowered grades, are imposed, possibly but not necessarily logical, concequences.

Does he struggle with his homework or does he just find it tedious?
post #5 of 6
Moved from Preteens and Teens.
post #6 of 6
I have a son who likes to do homework, and another son is just beginning to even get homework. So I don't have much experience with resistance. Once in a while if they are tired or something, I guess.

My philosphy about homework is that it is their responsibility to get it done. Not mine.

My role is to provide:
- an orderly, non-distracting homework space
- adequate time in the schedule
- company and support
- help them with organization and remembering stuff

By company and support, I mean that I am around while they do it. I'm cooking dinner, or folding laundry, paying bills, or working on my own homework. I'm not learning over their shoulder micromanaging. If they ask for help, then I help. If they turn it into a fight, I stop helping and state clearly that, "I will be available help when they are ready to work."

I usually ask what their assignments are, and I check to see that they have remembered all of them. I don't check over the actual work, unless they ask me to.

The few times they have decided not to do their homework, I have calmly stated that I'm not going to make them do it, but they need to let their teacher know the problem, and accept whatever consequences might occur at school.

The ONE time that my son decided to go to school empty handed, he explained calmly to his teacher that the homework was not helping him to learn anything, so he wasn't going to do it. The teacher traded his homework for a page from a higher grade level. Surprisingly, both of them were satisfied with this solution.

Honestly though, few kids want to face their teacher empty handed when they are supposed to be turning in homework.

Only based on your very short post, I wonder if you are letting it be *your* responsiblity to see that the work gets done? And I wonder if your son is depending on you to push him? If you stop pushing, and let him decide whether to do it or not, is there any chance that he will become more self-motivated in time?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at School
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › homework issues