Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Vaccinations Archives › HIB and Prevnar › Why do docs seem to always reccommend the HIB
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Why do docs seem to always reccommend the HIB  

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
It seems from most posts I read that when you say you will not be vaxing, the doc always says, "well I really think you should consider the Hib."

So, why such a push for the Hib? Any thoughts?

Thanks
post #2 of 26
I was wondering that too....my doctor recommended the Hib and Prevnar. What gives?
post #3 of 26
The pedi we had when we first decided not to vaccinate told me that hib was the one he would strongly recommend. He had been a ped for 20 years, and he said it's the one vaccine that he's witnessed working. He said he'd seen a decrease in meningitis cases after the vaccine was introduced. This pedi is one that was highly respectful of my choice, so no flames, please. I know nearly every doctor has just one vaccine that they swear by. But, even if the Hib vaccine is effective it still does not address the increase in other types of meningitis post-hib vaccine.
post #4 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjarvis View Post
It seems from most posts I read that when you say you will not be vaxing, the doc always says, "well I really think you should consider the Hib."

So, why such a push for the Hib? Any thoughts?

Thanks
Not my old ped; her push was DTaP. Some people have dogs, some have cats. Some docs push HIB, others DTaP, or Prevenar.
post #5 of 26
Because when a child does develop Hib meningitis, it's a very serious disease and because any mention of the word "meningitis" is an easy sell to most parents.
post #6 of 26
[hysteria] Because meningitis is really really scary and bad! [/hysteria]
post #7 of 26
ONe of my good friends (who selectively vaxes...NOW) her ped pushed her into HIb and Prevnar too. Those are the only ones that she suggested.
post #8 of 26


Utter the word "meningitis" and the arm gets offered up immediately.
post #9 of 26
Thread Starter 
So all out of the doctors hopes for compliance on at least one vaccine to get injected? Or do you think the docs really think this is an important vaccine that is effective?
post #10 of 26
I think they really believe it's important & effective. It's not only the seriousness of invasive disease but also the issue of antibiotic resistance.
post #11 of 26
Is hib abx resistant?
post #12 of 26
Just my opinion, but I am thinking that most docs today don't have any "real time" experience with most of the other VPD's they vaccinate for. Hib is something they can regurgitate with recent history, even though it is rare, and never has been an epidemic anywhere! This vaccine wasn't even around when my first two children were born, (in 1984 & 1987) so there wasn't any "fear mongering" necessary.

And think about it, only the children with complications are most likely the ones who will be seen by a ped/ and /or the hospital. Those who get sick and get over it with no complications are not going to be recorded, in most cases.
post #13 of 26
the HIB vaccine was developed becuase it was a standard infection in the US that was killing many infants on the navajo reservation.

now to understand the context for this, you need to understand that this rez has one of the lowest living standards in the entire US and very little medical care at all. very few doctors care for everyone on the rez (it's a big one) and every kind of social ill runs rampant there.

so, instead of spending any money to actually increase the standard of living there, they (the CDC) asked the drug companies to develop a vaccine. which does protect many children from death. (and it way cheaper and easier than actually helping people on that rez)

so if you have a very poor standard of living, eat mostly gov't surplus food, formula feed, don't have running water in your house or heat in the winter, many children, poor access to medical care, live around much alcohol and drug abuse and other sick people, for sure get the HIB vaccine.

and yes, from what i have read it's one of those infections that only became deadly after the introduction of antibiotics.

bacterial menegitsis is nothing to sneeze at, it can be deadly to children. but viral is more common and easier to deal with and rarely fatal. (my stepdaughter had it)

we refused HIB becuase we don't have any risk factors for it.
post #14 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by suschi View Post
And think about it, only the children with complications are most likely the ones who will be seen by a ped/ and /or the hospital. Those who get sick and get over it with no complications are not going to be recorded, in most cases.

Kind of like docs/nurses who fear homebirth because they only see moms/babies with complications that were involved with a homebirth...because the ones without complications were...at home, and never went to the hospital .
post #15 of 26
i recently read an article where a study had definitively linked the meningitis vaccine to Guilliane-Barre Syndrome (the flu vax was recently linked to this too). It said the risk was low, but meningitis was very serious, so you should definitely get the shot anyway.
post #16 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjarvis View Post
So all out of the doctors hopes for compliance on at least one vaccine to get injected? Or do you think the docs really think this is an important vaccine that is effective?
I think they believe it's important and that if they tell people it's to prevent meningitis, people will get it. I think most docs think all or almost all of them are important, but they're going to have a hard time selling pertussis, diphtheria, polio or chickenpox to a lot of people, for various reasons. A meningitis vax is an easy one, though.
post #17 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamakay View Post
Is hib abx resistant?
Yes, but it's a bigger issue with S pneumo.
post #18 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
the HIB vaccine was developed becuase it was a standard infection in the US that was killing many infants on the navajo reservation.
Where do you find this information on how and why the HIB was developed?

How do you also find info saying that if you breastfeed, not in daycare, etc. that you are low risk for HIB?

Also, does the Prevnar vax cover S pneumo?

Thanks again
post #19 of 26
you could google it, i believe that i read it in aviva romm's book "a thoughtful parent's guide to vaccines." but i could be wrong. i might have found it online somewhere.

it's just common sense that a breastfed baby has a better funtioning immune system, and is at lower rick for most communicable diseases. (though there are loads of studies that show this too... you could try pubmed)

i don't know anything about prevnar... sorry.
post #20 of 26
Does anyone know if there is any financial ties to these vaccines. I wonder if doctors get large kickbacks from these two being that they are not part of the "mandated" vaccine schedule. I thought I had read this before. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Oh, when I say kickbacks, I mean "medical conferences" in which the pharmaceutical companies send doctors to places like the Carri bean along with their entire family. I have witnessed this because my neighbor is a doctor.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HIB and Prevnar
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Vaccinations Archives › HIB and Prevnar › Why do docs seem to always reccommend the HIB