Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Just found out...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Just found out...  

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
...my best friend was in the trial for the new HPV vax. Scarey!
She emailed me saying that I should be sure to get it (she's freaked cause her SIL just got dx with lymphoma so she is going on about keeping myself healthy and avoiding cancer....). I emailed her back saying um, did you forget I dont vax?? And that it really would be silly for me to get it since I am married and know, without a doubt, that niether of us is sleeping around. I mean, what's the chance that I would get it?!? Anyway, I also told her about all the adverse reactions already and that there is no way I am going near that vaccine! It just surprised me that she participated in the trial.
post #2 of 11
post #3 of 11
Someone I know from another board was in the trial too. To each their own I guess.

Quote:
And that it really would be silly for me to get it since I am married and know, without a doubt, that niether of us is sleeping around. I mean, what's the chance that I would get it?!?
Your chances are as good as anyone else. HPV is not only sexually transmitted and sometimes it lies dormant for years. That is yet another risk of the vax, it is admittedly more dangerous if you have HPV and you may have HPV and nto know it.
post #4 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by bebesho2 View Post
Your chances are as good as anyone else.

That simply isn't true or supported by the evidence. Is it possible that she may contract some form of HPV that causes cervical cancer? Well, maybe. It is not, however, even remotely possible that her chances are just as good as the prostitute on the corner.

Quote:
HPV is not only sexually transmitted and sometimes it lies dormant for years.
But see, all the evidence says that genital HPV is sexually transmitted and possibly vertically transmitted from mother to infant during childbirth. If you have any evidence to the contrary, please show it to me. I mean, anything. People here keep telling stories about their friend who had HPV when she was a virgin, but no one I've ever met has ever had HPV without any sexual contact whatsoever. We don't know for sure if these women were molested as children, engaged in sexual behavior aside from intercourse that would allow them to become infected or if they may possibly have contracted it from their mothers. You don't catch cervical/genital HPV from shaking hands with someone. You don't catch it from sharing a drink. You don't catch it from a toilet seat. You don't catch it from blood transfusions. So before people keep repeating that cervical cancer-causing HPV can be contracted without having sex, you have to tell us how. It would be the first disease I know of that's spread in some mysterious way that no one has yet identified. In reality, we do know how HPV is spread. It's an STD. You get it from having sex with an infected person. If you want to say that isn't true, you have to prove it.

I'm not trying to sound mean or pick a fight. Really, I'm not. I just keep seeing the same double standard around here. When someone doesn't vax and supports non-vax, we tend to accept that practically anything they say must be true. Then when someone supports vaxing and does vax, we tear them to shreds over things that are totally provable. It can't be this way. It ruins our credibility and doesn't contribute to honest and thoughtful discussion. If we are going to make claims around here, we need to have evidence to back them up. Otherwise, we're just as bad as the CDC, telling us to vax because they said so.
post #5 of 11
Plummeting-I was diagnosed with HPV some years back-before the vaccine. While in a monogomous relationship for many years with no reason to beleive my DH was other than monogomous. The information available was VERY different than what you find all over the internet now. The discussions were different too. I had freaked at first but the midwives did not see it as just an STD. Transmission information was readily available all over the place. Then Gerdasil came around and it was the new big STD. I know someone personally who was diagnosed pre any sexual contact. Also, a relative had one partner ever-always protected... Abstinant for several years, with regular paps due to a problem-she was diagnosed with 3 strains.

I will try hard to dig up what I learned a few years back-it all disappeared when gerdasil came to play. Coincidence? I no longer have HPV btw. I dug up so much information and read soooo much back then.

I may have an old post somewhere with the OLD information. Yes it can be an STD but is not ONLY transmitted that way. I had read hot tubs were a common place for transmission, let's see if that information is still available.
post #6 of 11
Bebesho2, I had HPV, too. I had it 7- oops, 8 now! -years ago. I also did a lot of research into it. Eight years ago, long before the advent of Gardasil, the information said it was transmitted via skin to skin contact in the genital region. My dad had the internet as soon as it became available. I've been using it since you had to pay per minute. I definitely knew what I was looking for. I found enough info to wait it out, against my doc's advice. I was right, it went away on its own.

Besides, what you're saying (that they stopped saying HPV was easily transmissible once a vaccine became available) doesn't even make sense. Now that there's a vaccine, they should be trying to convince us that HPV is very easily transmissible, not the opposite. If they had evidence that you could catch HPV w/o having sex, they'd be telling us about it, not hiding it. The less safe people feel, the more vaccine they sell.

Quote:
To evaluate the transmission of genital human papillomavirus (HPV) through the floor and seats of humid dwellings, samples were collected with a toothbrush from the floor and seat surfaces of humid dwellings; showers, saunas and dressing rooms. The survey included 3 bathing resorts, 1 indoor swimming pool, 2 schools and 2 private homes. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify the human beta-globin gene and HPV DNA. The results for HPV DNA amplification were confirmed by Southern blot hybridization under low stringency using a probe mixture of HPV types 6, 16, 18 and 31. beta-globin could be amplified only from 3 sample taken from a dressing room of and indoor public swimming pool. No HPV DNA-positive samples were found. These results indicate that transmission of genital HPV infection via floor or seat surfaces in the above dwellings in general or family use is highly unlikely.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/q...&dopt=Citation

None of the scenarios you've described prove that HPV is transmitted via hot tubs or toilet seats or whatever. You said you were monogamous for many years. Was your DH your only partner, ever? Were you his only partner, ever? You yourself said infection could lie dormant for years, so why would you assume that you both came to the relationship without HPV? Even if you were both virgins, had you both had no sexual contact whatsoever? Even if you had both had no sexual contact whatsoever, you don't know that neither one of you contracted it from your mothers. Vertical transmission is probably possible.

For your friend, again, vertical transmission is probably possible.

And with your relative, well, so they had one partner and they used protection. Condoms don't prevent HPV infection. They reduce the risk, but the nature of the disease means they cannot always prevent infection. So, was their partner a virgin before the relationship? Had neither of them ever had any form of sexual contact before the relationship? And again, vertical transmission is probably possible. You mentioned the whole years of abstinence thing, but you know it can lie dormant for years without causing symptoms.

It's not unusual for high-risk types to cause no problem for 20 years, then suddenly the woman has dysplasia. This isn't evidence that the infection is new, only that it is newly detected.

There is proof that people can carry HPV DNA on their fingers. So it would be possible for someone with HPV to touch their infected genitals, not wash their hands, then touch someone else's hands, transferring the virus. However, in order for that other person to become infected, they'd have to then go home and touch their own genitals with their dirty fingers AND they'd have to have enough of the actual virus on their own hands to cause infection, which is incredibly unlikely, but not impossible. So I guess I could shake hands with someone, then go home and change my Diva cup w/o washing my hands (eeeewwww! Wash your hands before doing things like that people!) and infect myself. Does that really make HPV something other than an STD? But that hardly means I'm just as likely to catch HPV as the barfly who sleeps with everyone that comes along. Remember, your original post was that DocsNemesis, who is in a monogamous relationship, is just as likely to catch HPV as anyone else. That's hyperbole.
post #7 of 11
Thread Starter 
Oh-just wanted to add-my dh never had ANY sexual contact before he met me, so if anyone was giving it to someone else, it would be me. I had my first son before I met him after a one night stand (with a condom btw, they arnt always effective!). Anyway, unless dh got it from his mom, no way is he transmitting it to me Even if I thought I were at risk, I wouldnt be getting the vax though.
post #8 of 11
HPV is the same thing that causes warts on your feet and fingers, so yeah it's everywhere, but there are SO many strains. I thought only the cervical cancer-causing strains were "STD's". People who have warts on the feet don't have genital warts . . . even though they do have a HPV strain.
Afterall, everyone who ever got a wart growing up would be at risk for cervical cancer coz they all have a strain of HPV, even my DH, it just depends on the strain.
post #9 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by oneKnight View Post
HPV is the same thing that causes warts on your feet and fingers, so yeah it's everywhere, but there are SO many strains. I thought only the cervical cancer-causing strains were "STD's". People who have warts on the feet don't have genital warts . . . even though they do have a HPV strain.
Afterall, everyone who ever got a wart growing up would be at risk for cervical cancer coz they all have a strain of HPV, even my DH, it just depends on the strain.
I have a feeling it might be some sort of interaction between a few different strains, too, that might play into who actually develops abnormal cells.
Just my own speculation, though.
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by oneKnight View Post
HPV is the same thing that causes warts on your feet and fingers, so yeah it's everywhere, but there are SO many strains. I thought only the cervical cancer-causing strains were "STD's". People who have warts on the feet don't have genital warts . . . even though they do have a HPV strain.
Afterall, everyone who ever got a wart growing up would be at risk for cervical cancer coz they all have a strain of HPV, even my DH, it just depends on the strain.
But we aren't talking about those forms of HPV. Obviously, the strains that cause plantar warts or warts on your hand are not sexually transmitted. What we're talking about specifically are the types of HPV that cause cervical cancer and genital warts, because 4 of those types are what Gardasil is supposed to prevent. So while it's true that some forms of HPV are not sexually transmitted, it isn't relevant to the conversation, because we are talking specifically about the types that Gardasil was created to prevent. It's generally accepted around here that when we have a conversation about HPV and Gardasil, we're talking about genital infection, because that's what Gardasil is for.
post #11 of 11
Keep in mind, I am posting from work. So I am not gonna answer certain questions here, right now.

Basically, my point is it can also lie dormant, so you are at risk even in monogamy-do not think 8 years of monogomy and protection mean you will not suddenly be diagnosed-kwim?

I won't go over transmissision information until I have my links and facts. I have it all at home-SOMEWHERE. I freaked when I was diagnosed. I did. I was misinformed. I got informed and learned how common strains are and how there is little known about transmission except it IS easily transmitted various ways. So we will just have to disagree there. My concern is our girls will be labeled if the yhave it.

I really need to post abotui this from home, so I can go into depth.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Vaccinations
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Just found out...