Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Toddler and tv - please help!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Toddler and tv - please help!  

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
Ds1 hardly watched any tv as a young toddler, maybe just a Sesame Street now and then while I recovered from a night of no sleep. By the time he was 4 or so he had a few favorite DVDs (Thomas or Baby Einstein) that he would watch every now and then, and I was fine with this. I've always been an "everything in moderation" kind of gal.

Well, since ds2 was born he has been exposed to tv, just through ds1 watching it. I don't know if this is the cause, but now he is 2.5yo and begs me nonstop for tv. And when he's having a hard time, like being tired but won't go down for a nap, putting on the tv is the only way to keep my sanity. Like today. I have been trying to put him down for a nap since noon. He begs me to go lay down, we nurse while I fight off his pinching and hitting, then I finally can't stand it anymore, we get up, play, and then start all over again. I know he's tired, but it's been two hours and he just won't fall asleep. So after another nursing session that made me actually scream, I finally gave up and let him watch the video he's been asking for all day. And now he is happy as a clam on the couch. But until the tv went on he was whiny and clingy, throwing toys, hitting ds1, and wanting to nurse every 5 minutes.

I don't want to use the tv so much, but I am just at a loss with him. He is just all over me when he is upset, and nothing I can do helps until the tv goes on. I can't just sit with him all day while he works through it because my older son is here too, and he wants me to play with him, or read to him, and I have to fix lunch and the such. Plus there's the issue of clinging on to what is left of my sanity.

It doesn't help that we specifically didn't go to the local homeschool park day today because we were late getting ready and I figured we would only have a half hour before having to leave for ds2's nap. So we stay home, and now he doesn't nap. And now we can't go anywhere or he'll fall asleep in the car.:

I'm frustrated about the nap issue, but I am really upset that tv is the only thing that comforts him when he's tired or upset. I try to read and he just knocks the book away. I try to dance with him and he screams no. I try to go for a walk but he refuses to let me get his shoes on, and even if I do, he'll just whine and cry for me to pick him up and nurse the whole time.

I don't know what to do. I don't want to get rid of the tv altogether, because even though we only watch a little, we enjoy the little that we do. Dh and ds1 really enjoy watching PBS documentaries together. And baseball. And dh and I live for the opportunity to watch a movie after the kids go to bed.

I just feel really sad that I have a toddler who is hooked on the tv.
post #2 of 11
Ugh, that sounds tough.

TV is weird, huh? DD is 2.5 and only watches a little TV. But sometimes she'll get it in her head that she wants to see a show or DVD, and if I say no for whatever reason (we're about to do something else, she already watched TV that day, etc.) she will just *crumple* like she does in no other circumstance. It's so strange, because she's otherwise not like that at all.

She is not particularly tantrum prone right now but this one thing can really set her off (esp. if she's tired). TV must have a really strong pull!

I do my best to distract her in these situations, but it's HARD. I'm practically standing on my head by the time I get her to stop crying. Sometimes when I'm at my wit's end (I am preggo and sometimes just too tired to deal) I do wind up giving in, and like you said -- then she's happy as a clam.

Hopefully some other mamas will have some good suggestions, I will be watching this thread. Hang in there!
post #3 of 11
well, I have a 2 1/2 year old toddler who is absolutely addicted to the television too. My older ds never watched tv until he was older. He is now 4 1/2 and enjoys a movie now and again, but could take it or leave it. My younger ds begs to watch tv and movies all day long. He also was exposed at a younger age than my first ds, and I think that has something to do with it. I don't think small children should watch any tv at all. That being said, I let my little ds watch 2 half hour caroons on public tv in the early morning. Sometimes my dh will put on a kid movie in the eve (sometimes, not often). My little guy is so unhappy in general, 2 is such a hard age for some, and he just dislikes everything, so I feel like a little tv saves our sanity. As for the begging for tv and movies, it really drives me insane too. Not really any advice, but I feel your pain. Maybe you could put him in the tub? Put music on, or a story on cd to listen to?
hang in there mama
post #4 of 11
I suggest you look into a sterosystem put at the head or foot of his bed with a delta sleep CD like Dr. Jeffrey Thompson's Delta Sleep System.

It might help him lull his brain. He's seeking the ability to move his brain waves into other states and TV is the easiest way for him to move them and sustain them.
post #5 of 11
Get rid of the TV, now. At least unplug it and put it in a closet so that it's not easy to get at. You will find a way to adjust. Neither of your kids need to be watching it at all.

There will be a period of adjustment but you will figure it out. Kids lived for zillions of years without TV--yours can too. Spend as much time outside as possible and they will find plenty to occupy them.
post #6 of 11
Is it possible to disconnect the TV from the antenna or disconnect the cable? Where we live, because of the mountains there is no reception, so in order to watch regular TV you have to have cable or something. We hate regular TV, so the only things we have are a few educational dvds we have purchased and a Netflix subscription.

Because DD only has a few dvds to choose from, when she really wants to watch something for some reason (maybe she's sick, maybe she needs a distraction, maybe she's trying to calm down and can't figure out how to do it, I don't always know) she can choose from her dvds. Because they are old and boring, however, under normal circumstances she would prefer to do something else. If we had a constant influx of new programming I am certain she would be addicted to the TV. But this way, she is able to regulate better and we don't have to get into a battle about the TV, cause its just not that interesting.

When DH and I want to watch something, we order it through Netflix. They have a big selection of documentaries. Occasionally we will get a "family" dvd and have a special night of popcorn and rootbeer floats. The only thing is that you wouldn't be able to get baseball.
post #7 of 11
I know several people who have done what Bellingham Crunchie has done with great success. DD has never watched tv but she did get used to turning it on in the morning for noise. Drove us batty especially since she always found the religous, right wing shows (we are atheist, lefty people). So I unplugged it for a week and she stopped. For things like this, I think it is like anything else unhealthy. If I eat too much sugar, I completely quit for a few weeks and then slowly add a little bit back in.
post #8 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by fuller2 View Post
Get rid of the TV, now. At least unplug it and put it in a closet so that it's not easy to get at. You will find a way to adjust. Neither of your kids need to be watching it at all.

There will be a period of adjustment but you will figure it out. Kids lived for zillions of years without TV--yours can too. Spend as much time outside as possible and they will find plenty to occupy them.

:
post #9 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by fuller2 View Post
Get rid of the TV, now. At least unplug it and put it in a closet so that it's not easy to get at. You will find a way to adjust. Neither of your kids need to be watching it at all.
Seems harsh. What if other members of the family enjoy tv/dvds and watch without problems? Why penalize the entire family?

I'm not really a huge TV person, myself... but I don't think "abstinence only" is the best solution.
post #10 of 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by chinaKat View Post
Seems harsh. What if other members of the family enjoy tv/dvds and watch without problems? Why penalize the entire family?

I'm not really a huge TV person, myself... but I don't think "abstinence only" is the best solution.
You have a good point, there. I wasn't thinking about the rest of the family.
post #11 of 11
Well, I'm not sure that the two are necessarily related. It sounds like he's going through a rough time, and you might be too... and TV is the one thing that kids can usually do independently and without a lot of demands from them (as long as you keep the video on, LOL).

I can understand your desire not to have him watch it all day long... I don't put a lot of limits on what my DS does (I guess you'd say I'm pseudo-consensual living), but I do have a couple of rules about the TV. After 8, there is no TV... otherwise he'll watch it until midnight and never go to sleep (I have to work during the day, I can't nap like SOME 3 year olds can ).

I am not a huge fan of my DS watching TV, and there are a ton of things I do so that it's not our big fallback. My DS needs things to do, sometimes, which involve him sitting down and being calm... TV is one, but we also read, draw, play with play-doh, those sorts of things. If you leave those things out where he can see them, he'll want to play with them more often, too. Don't know if that helps any.

Most of all, maybe temporarily just relaxing about it all would help the most. Sounds like you're having a hard enough time without a lot of pressure on yourself or him, right now. Maybe now is not the time to fight the battle too much.

Getting out of the house for a while also does wonders for this sort of age, in my opinion. Much as I hate McDonald's I do frequent their PlayPlace thingies sometimes. And I even buy DS a little snack there if he wants it. : Those places can keep DS busy for quite a while.

Then there's the zoo... we go to the zoo when it's cold and we hang out at the indoor attractions, like the reptile house and jungle.

Those are two places where it won't be as stressful to go, maybe, with 2 little guys, because even if one has a meltdown or something it's no big deal (want to guess how many people are at the zoo on a 30 degree day? LOL).

As far as the nap thing, personally, I would not have a "nap time". It sounds like his needs are changing... let him lead the way. There is nothing worse than trying to get someone to go to sleep when they are not ready.

My DS recently became hooked on the TV too (he's 3). I think part of the problem is that it's wintertime... it's hard to provide stimulating activities during winter, you're indoors a lot, there's not always a lot to do. That might be part of the problem with his clinginess and high maintenance behavior too? So, try to just go easy on yourself... when it warms up a bit you can let them tear around the park every day.

Another poster on MDC posted that their TV is in a big wardrobe thingy with a door... I think that is nice. Part of the problem with TV is that it's usually a prominent thing int he living room, so it's the first thing kids and adults usually think of, ya know?

Go easy on yourself, mama. Hugs from me. It's wintertime, you have 2 little guys, just do the best you can.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Toddler and tv - please help!