Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Do I expect to much?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Do I expect to much?  

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I have a 4 1/2 dd and just had a baby boy in Dec. 06. Things have been going well up to this point but seem to be losing my patience with dd on a regular basis now. She can't seem to do any simple task, like putting on her shoes or cleaning up a toy, without my asking her 5 times because everything is a game, or she tells me 'just a minute'. And I'm usually busy with baby or getting other things together so I'm not always right there helping her. Do I expect to much or should she be able to follow my simple requests most of the time without taking FOREVER to do it. By the time I can get her to listen I have asked her to do it 5 times and eventually end up yelling at her or taking something away from her.
I'm feeling very guilty right now because I feel annoyed by her, is this all normal or do I expect to much from her?
post #2 of 5
i think she should be able to do things like that, but thats just me : working in a daycare, ive seen kids are a lot more capable than we think.
post #3 of 5
I don't think that you are expecting too much. That being said, your house sounds just like ours (except the baby isn't here yet). Bf's daughter is about 4 1/2 and she is exactly the same way. She's rather be coloring or playing than putting on her shoes or cleaning up a mess. The kid has developed very selective hearing in the last six months.

We've found that we have to give her two or three warnings about what is going to happen next. We tell her that in ten minutes it is time to put away toys and start getting on pjs. Then we give her a five minute reminder. Then a one minute reminder. Then there is still a chance that we will have tears or tantrums when the time actually comes. But it seems to help a little.

I hope you get some good responses. I'll be watching this thread.
post #4 of 5
Your having just had a baby means the whole family is still in a period of adjustment. Dd may want/need more help than you feel capable of giving. Comparing a chid in daycare with one at home who has just been displaced by a new baby is not a fair comparison. Yes, children can do many things if they need to, but that is not neccessarily what is best for them. Encouraging independence is great but so is nurturing. Dd may want extra help for reassurance at this point.

Personally, I found age 4 to be much more challenging than age 2, and I didn't have a new baby in the mix. My ds became much more independent in the sense of wanting to be in control of himself and what he did, not in the sense of wanting to do things by himself.
post #5 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by 4evermom View Post
Personally, I found age 4 to be much more challenging than age 2, and I didn't have a new baby in the mix. My ds became much more independent in the sense of wanting to be in control of himself and what he did, not in the sense of wanting to do things by himself.
My youngest turned 4 in October, and I'm experiencing the same thing with him. My big challenge with him is getting ready to go anywhere...he takes *forever*. At the same age my oldest (now 6) was getting ready pretty much by himself. It took a little prompting to keep him on task, and there were things he needed help with, but he basically did what he needed to do. DS4, however, is constantly dawdling. I remind him to get dressed, and come back to find him tumbling on the bed or playing with the water in the sink. I've been spending more time than I care to admit yelling at him (as well as taking things away, putting him in his room, etc.), and then this week it hit me that regardless of what I would like, he is just not going to be that focused at this time. I've resigned myself to having to spend more time keeping him on task. He hates for me to do things for him (i.e., dress him, etc.) so if I'm standing right there I'll say "here, put on your pants, or I'm going to put them on for you" (or whatever). If he doesn't respond in a few seconds, then I move to start doing them for him and he will usually do it then. It's a royal PITA, but things are a lot more calm. And I'm noticing that he is getting better, bit by bit, because he knows that's what he has to do, anyway (at least, that's my theory ).

Another thing I've been doing is just calmly enforcing consequences. He will dawdle indefinitely over his dinner, so I started telling him "dinner is over when the big hand is on the 5". I give him warning reminders and he knows how to watch the clock. Once the time comes, I calmly take dinner away and if dessert is being served that night, he doesn't get any if he hasn't finished (by "finished" I mean "eaten a decent amount", I don't necessarily require that he clean his plate). I will also give him leeway if I can tell he's been making an honest effort and just didn't quite finish, so he knows it's not quite so much about the time, but the effort. He put up a big fuss about this at first, but I just calmly told him that dinner time was over and next time not to spend so much time playing with his fork (or whatever). Now I'm noticing that he still tends to dawdle some, but a reminder will put him back on task moreso than it had been. I'm relieved of the frustration of watching him waste time (well, to some extent I am...I'm still trying!) because I know that when the time is up, he's the one that deals with the consequences and I'm not going to be held hostage in the kitchen forever. And those consequences aren't me yelling and screaming, or taking away every toy he owns, or putting him in time out for 6 hours because I keep adding on more time, or whatever. (I've never *really* put one of my children in time out for 6 hours, but once when I was out of control and one of them wasn't listening, I kept adding time on until I got to some ridiculous point and realized that, duh, what I was doing wasn't working .

Regarding cleaning up toys: for a long time now, I will tell my boys, "if you don't want to clean it up, I'm happy to do it for you". They know that this means the toy will be going away for a while, as that's what happens when Mom cleans them up. I rarely have to clean up toys, but I did recently have to clean up Legos. They're currently sitting on a shelf in my bedroom.

I know the last thing you want right now with a new baby in the house is feeling like you have to spend more time enforcing things, but I've found that overall I spend less time, and the time I spend is more calm.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Do I expect to much?