Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › liquid vs. powder laundry det.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

liquid vs. powder laundry det. - Page 2  

post #21 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leta View Post
Liquid detergent was developed for exceptionally hard water. Liquid will dissolve even in cold, hard water. Powder is always cheaper than liquid.

If you have good water, save your money and buy powder.

I have a really good powder laundry/dishwasher/toilet cleaner/diaper pail detergent recipe if anyone is interested.
Im interested!!
post #22 of 33

Are powdered detergents OK for "HE" machines??

A possibly stupid question...does it make a difference whether you have a front-loader or top loader? We use 7th gen HE liquid, and I'm trying to make our own detergent instead. I'd prefer to use powder, but just wasn't sure. Thanks!
post #23 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leta View Post
I have a really good powder laundry/dishwasher/toilet cleaner/diaper pail detergent recipe if anyone is interested.
Yes, please!!!
post #24 of 33
all small and mighty is at sam's its about $8 for a pack of three bottles... pretty good pricing.. i know cuz i was at sams today
post #25 of 33
2 four lb. boxes Baking Soda ($1.87 @ Wal*Mart)
4 four lb., twelve oz. Boxes of Borax ($2.67 ea @Wal*Mart)
4 three lb., seven oz. Boxes of Washing Soda ($2.87 ea @ Wal*Mart)
8 twenty oz. Containers of generic OxyClean ($1 ea @ $1 store)
8 bars shredded, ground Fels Naptha Soap ($1.50 ea @ SuperOne)

This makes a plastic five gallon pail full, which lasts our family of four about a year. Feel free to adjust this recipe to an appropriate amount.

This is appropriate for front loaders. Use the one ounce OxyClean measure as your scoop- you don't need much. This does not suds, so don't expect it.

We successfully used this in a dishwasher, a half full OxyClean scoop per load with white vinegar as the rinse agent (a la JetDry). We also use white vinegar as fabric softener.

We have really, really good water, so I cannot vouch for how well this will work if you have hard water.

The hardest part of making this is grinding the Fels Naptha. I cut it into chunks and then grind it into powder in a food processor. You need to do this in a well ventilated area, because the dust will make you cough when you open the food processor cover. Alternatively, you could grate the Fels Naptha on a cheese grater, but that will not get the soap powder fine and it will take forever. This is why I make so much at once, because dealing with the soap is a PITA and this way I only have to do it once a year.

If you are making a lot at once, it's nice to have two people, one to pour the powders into the bucket while the other person stirs with a broomhandle, so everything is well mixed.

This can also be used to keep odors down in a diaper pail, to clean a toilet bowl, and as a base for all purpose cleaner (put a scoop in a spray bottle, add a dash of Dr. Bronner's, some tea tree oil [or just use TTO Dr. B's] and a glug of white vinegar, then fill the bottle up with warm water to dissolve the powder and shake well. Be aware that this can streak if not dilluted enough.)
post #26 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by streuselmama View Post
A possibly stupid question...does it make a difference whether you have a front-loader or top loader? We use 7th gen HE liquid, and I'm trying to make our own detergent instead. I'd prefer to use powder, but just wasn't sure. Thanks!
The Tide HE we use is powdered.
post #27 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiffany_PartyOf5 View Post
and its much easier on the arms since our detergent is up high.
Thanks, that's a good point - we have a stacked washer/dryer combo and stoe everything on top of it - which normally means the detergent gets left in the middle of the floor (which also makes the floor get yucky) because it is hard for me to lift it up and down.
post #28 of 33
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leta View Post
2 four lb. boxes Baking Soda ($1.87 @ Wal*Mart)
4 four lb., twelve oz. Boxes of Borax ($2.67 ea @Wal*Mart)
4 three lb., seven oz. Boxes of Washing Soda ($2.87 ea @ Wal*Mart)
8 twenty oz. Containers of generic OxyClean ($1 ea @ $1 store)
8 bars shredded, ground Fels Naptha Soap ($1.50 ea @ SuperOne)
I make natural laundry detergent as well. I do not recommend using soap in your recipe. Soap leaves a residue (soap scum) on diapers, mama pads, etc. causing them to eventually absorb less. There is a difference between laundry detergent and laundry soap. This recipe is for soap, but detergent is usually recommended for cloth diapers. Also, as Leta said, don't pay extra for the oxy-clean name. Dollar Tree has a sodium percarbonate for $1.
Warmly,
Aimee
Crunchy WAHM to Aiden 11/30/05
post #29 of 33
I wash in cold water primarily and I find liquid does a better job. Often times the powder does not melt all the way.

I only use liquid.
post #30 of 33
I make my own, too, and I use Kirk's Castille instead of Fels Naptha (which is a little too harsh for my family). And I make a smaller amount at a time in my food processor. For diapers, I use baking soda and tea tree oil in the wash, vinegar in the rinse, no build up or stinkies.
post #31 of 33
I prefer powder, because it's less messy. However, my next container of laundry detergent is liquid, because I discovered that the powdered detergent I had been using (Sears brand) contained a particularly environmentally irresponsible ingredient, so I bought the Costco brand liquid. I refuse to spend more money than I have to on laundry detergent.

Since I have a front-loader, my detergent choices are limited (I tried using regular detergent at first when I still had some left over, and I was always having problems with excessive sudsing no matter how little detergent I used). I wish the Costco powder in the huge bucket were HE compatible!
post #32 of 33
We use Shaklee powder. It is highly concentrated so it does dissolve very well. For our front loader it uses a little less than 1/8 of a cup for large loads and I use less for smaller loads.

It is phosphate free so it helps keep our clothes longer. T-shirts seem not to fade etc. It is also biodegradeable.

Its good for septic systems. We have found a large box lasts us about almost 180 loads so it is about .12 a load for detergent. When we were using other brands based on the amount needed it was about .26 a load. It seems like your paying more because when you buy such a big box its about $25, but it lasts a long time.
post #33 of 33
I make my own liquid and I love it... It costs me about $2 to make 2 gallons.
Quote:
The hardest part of making this is grinding the Fels Naptha. I cut it into chunks and then grind it into powder in a food processor.
Put the Fels Nafta in the freezer for a few hours then use a knife to cut it. It cumbles into smaller pieces then. Weird but effective.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Frugality & Finances
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › liquid vs. powder laundry det.