or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Archives › Pregnancy and Birth Archives › Due Date Clubs 2004 - 2008  › June 2007 › Best/Healthiest Disposable Diapers
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Best/Healthiest Disposable Diapers

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
I plan on using CDs, but I want to have some disposables on hand as well. I really want to avoid "mainstream" disposables, b/c I am concerned about the chemicals in them. Any advice on which "natural" disposables work best?

-Amy
post #2 of 21
i think that 7th generation work really well, however they have the same gel stuff in them as the other guys. they don't have all the perfumes and chlorine bleach and such though...
post #3 of 21
Yup...a lot of the more "natural" disposables have many of the same "unnatural" ingredients. Plus the different brands can have VERY different "fits". It might be worth seeing if any of your friends (or other mamas in an AP or natural parenting group) might be able to give you one or two of the disposables they use so you can try them out on your little one before buyina whole box...some of those brands can be pretty pricey!
post #4 of 21
You must also consider your baby's unique chemistry. My son got a terrible rash from 7th Gen diapers (among other brands), but seems to do best in Huggies if he must be in a disposable.

Cloth diapering, for me, was much more a question of HEALTH for my child than any kind of environmental decision, though I think it landed on the eco-friendly side, too.

I might try those two part disposables I've seen at Whole Foods lately for this baby (because I prefer to use disposables during air travel and very long days out)--a re-usable outer and a flushable inner. Reducing even half the bulk of the diaper seems like an obvious plus to me.

We'll see how the new baby's bum compares to DS's! Sometimes, the choice is really not ours to make (unless you would subject your baby to a painful, red butt because you'd already decided on a diaper brand--but I bet you wouldn't! )

--willo
post #5 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by willoLevin View Post
...I might try those two part disposables I've seen at Whole Foods lately for this baby (because I prefer to use disposables during air travel and very long days out)--a re-usable outer and a flushable inner. Reducing even half the bulk of the diaper seems like an obvious plus to me.
Is this the "G-diaper"?
post #6 of 21
I have a friend who uses G-diapers when they are out and really loves them.
post #7 of 21
The whole foods I went to stopped carrying the 7th gen and the tushies diapers. All they had were the 365 brand and they SUCK. They leak, and not even out the sides, just straight through. bleh.
post #8 of 21
I've always liked the 7th Gen for the occasional sposie. I can't stand the smell of all the normal dipes! ICK! I've pondered the G-diapers but the pricetag has me holding back. We rarely use sposies anyway, so it hasn't made sense so far.
post #9 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by firefly mama View Post
I've always liked the 7th Gen for the occasional sposie. I can't stand the smell of all the normal dipes! ICK! I've pondered the G-diapers but the pricetag has me holding back. We rarely use sposies anyway, so it hasn't made sense so far.
Are there ANY "typical" grocery-store brand of dipes that DON'T have an added scent?
post #10 of 21
After a few minutes on Google, I think that the answer to my query is, "no."

Well, if I had any uncertainty about cloth dipes, it's gone. I won't use scented products on my infant, as I don't use them on myself.
post #11 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by ASusan View Post
After a few minutes on Google, I think that the answer to my query is, "no."

Well, if I had any uncertainty about cloth dipes, it's gone. I won't use scented products on my infant, as I don't use them on myself.
I am chemically sensitive, and I can tolerate Huggies, FWIW.

You will probably also find that store brands are less scented (maybe contain "masking" scents but not actual "smell me" scents)--certainly I tolerate them better than Pampers (totally "baby powder" scented!) or Luvs (vicious rash machines, for my son!)

--willo
post #12 of 21
It's funny...Huggies are the ONLY disposable dipes that don't give dd a rash or funny skin reaction! She has a few food allergies and we dealt with moderate eczema for about a year so we got to play "detective" a lot more than we really wanted to.

Even worse than diapers are those baby washes...we usually used either the unscented/dye free Aveno or the Target brand (same nonscent/nondye). One weekend visit we borrowed a little baby wash from a friends and I swear I didn't recognize dd! The smell is such an important part of "who" a little babe is and even at 5 months the fact that dd "smelled" like something other than herself really threw me.
post #13 of 21
We've been using disposables for the past few months, as the whole prefold/snappi/cover combo wasn't doable for ds anymore. I've never tried Tushies, but heard they leaked a lot. I like 7th Generation and Huggies...they are definitely better than the generic drugstore diaper. Now, neither of those are particularly 'natural,' but for a short time I wasn't too concerned.

I don't get those G diapers...can you really flush a whole diaper (minus the cover, I know) down the toilet???

Ds is now potty trained though - YEAH!!!
post #14 of 21
I bought a whole slew of MotherEase cloth diapers, but still aren't using them because they're so big and gapey on her legs. Still!

I use 7th Generation. I love them.
post #15 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mere View Post
I don't get those G diapers...can you really flush a whole diaper (minus the cover, I know) down the toilet???
I think there is a thin layer (like a flushable rice paper liner, maybe?) that can be flushed with any solids on it. That is the part that seems helpful to me.

(TMI follows DS just doesn't have very well-formed poop, even though he's a big ol' 3 year old who eats all solid food. We've talked to the doctor about it. We've tweaked his diet. It just seems to be his digestive system. If I don't use a lift-out liner with him, I can't shake all the poop into the toilet, and I really object to people poisoning our groundwater with human feces in the trash. I hate to be one of them!!!

I understand that there is a tear-off portion (the flushable poo-catcher) of the disposable portion (probably contains some gelling chemicals?) of the G diaper, if that makes sense!

I haven't tried them yet because the largest size would likely be too small for my 3 year old (who, by the way, claims he will start using the potty in June--God willing!) I'm willing to pay a bit more to try them for our backup system for the new baby, because at least I will know I'm starting at the small end of the size range! Any part that is re-usable seems like a likely environmental savings to me.

Aside from those who live in SEVERELY water restricted places (and washing diapers is supposed to be about equal to the same number of toilet flushes for a "trained" kid/adult), I just don't buy the idea that washing something re-usable can be as wasteful as producing so much stuff to just throw away after a single use. Doesn't compute! (I do use more hemp than cotton because of the massive chemical/water issues with conventional cotton crops.)

--willo
post #16 of 21
There are often threads about the g-dipes in the Life with a Babe forum...some people seem to adore them and others don't in terms of fit and function. And the feedback from plumbers seems to be a bit mixed too...apparently some plumbing can handle the load and others simply jam up in fun and exciting poo related ways. There's a lot of "small print" in the packaging I guess (I haven't purchased any so don't know first hand) that alks about what can and can't be flushed!

Here's what the company has to say... http://www.gdiapers.com/
post #17 of 21

gDiapers

I'm a very recent gDiapers convert. We started out with cloth, but DH never really got on board, and we kept getting leak after leak, so we went to 7th Generation. My father sent me a link to the gDiapers. We tried them out and I really like them! The covers are nice and bright. The liners snap into the covers and stay put. The flushable is like a really big maxi pad. It doesn't have a smell. It does have some sort of polymer to suck up the moisture, but it's not as noticeable as in a regular disposable (Huggies, Pampers). You rip one side of the flushable, dump out the cottony inside, then you break up the inside with the swish stick and flush. At the end of theflush, you add the outside of the flushable. There's a Yahoo group devoted to it: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/gDiapers/

You can even compost the wet flushables (poopy ones must go down the toilet). There are people who have issues with their plumbing, but most people seem to be OK.

Sorry to butt into the conversation!
post #18 of 21
Regarding flushing g-diapers or even the flushable cloth diaper liners that I love...

How often does your toilet clog from your usual "activities"?

If you have a toilet that requires a pump-assist (like in some basements), you shouldn't flush a g-diaper, a flushable liner, a tampon or anything else except human waste and minute amounts of toilet paper. My parents had this in their last basement bathroom, and it worked fine, but it was definitely more sensitive than most other toilets I've ever used. (Ask me how much tp my DH uses... Grr.)

Toilets vary considerably in their likelihood to clog. The one plus to our old (pre-water limits) toilet is that is flushes like a champ and clogs less than most of the newer, "fancier" toilets I've used in my parents various homes an elsewhere. I would like to get a water-rationing toilet to replace it someday, but not until we've added a second toilet somewhere else in the house--just in case!

--willo
post #19 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by ASusan View Post
Are there ANY "typical" grocery-store brand of dipes that DON'T have an added scent?
Huggies Supreme are what we used for DD - they are the only mainstream disposable we found without scent, that didn't leak gel, and that didn't cause skin reactions with my highly sensitive skinned DD. Wegman's brand also has no scent, but I don't like the fit.
post #20 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by wombatclay View Post
It's funny...Huggies are the ONLY disposable dipes that don't give dd a rash or funny skin reaction! She has a few food allergies and we dealt with moderate eczema for about a year so we got to play "detective" a lot more than we really wanted to.
Yes. This is exactly what we found as well, and the main reason we used Huggies supreme. Eczema can be a real pill. :
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: June 2007
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Archives › Pregnancy and Birth Archives › Due Date Clubs 2004 - 2008  › June 2007 › Best/Healthiest Disposable Diapers