Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Activism › Activism Archives › 3,240 civilian deaths and counting...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

3,240 civilian deaths and counting...  

post #1 of 16
Thread Starter 
From the Associated Press:

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmp...ing_the_dead_7

Quote:
BAGHDAD, Iraq - At least 3,240 civilians died across Iraq during a month of war, including 1,896 in Baghdad, according to a five-week Associated Press investigation.

The count is still fragmentary, and the complete toll — if it is ever tallied — is sure to be significantly higher.
So far, neither weapons of mass destruction, nor conclusive linkages between Iraq and Al-Qaeda have been found.

I hope that everyone that voted for the Supreme Court Appointee will think twice before voting for that lying sack of sh*t again.

Edited to add post #1100 in a series.
post #2 of 16
Aw, damn. I saw that you posted, and was hoping you'd brought some levity into Activism...but NO!!! You have to post about the death count of a bunch of civilians in some Middle Eastern country far away. For Pete's sake, they're just a bunch of FOREIGNERS, for crying out loud! Not even Western ones, for that matter. So why don't you let us get back to our Wheel of Fortune, already??
post #3 of 16
Thread Starter 
You are, if nothing else, predictable, NM. :

I'm not quite sure how those cartoons justify the American invasion of Iraq. Are you suggesting that it is the responsibility of the United States to invade every country that is oppressed by a totalitarian regime? By that logic, we should be drawing up plans to invade North Korea, Burma, the Congo, Iran...
post #4 of 16
Quote:
Originally posted by Hilary Briss
You are, if nothing else, predictable, NM. :

I'm not quite sure how those cartoons justify the American invasion of Iraq. Are you suggesting that it is the responsibility of the United States to invade every country that is oppressed by a totalitarian regime? By that logic, we should be drawing up plans to invade North Korea, Burma, the Congo, Iran...

I thought we were drawing up those plans? Pre-emptive strikes and all.

After all, we have the PNAC - we're leaders of the world dontcha know.


NM, doesn't it occur to you that we could have stopped the slaughter w/o doing more of it ourselves?
post #5 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Els' 3 Ones
Femme Flatlander
Awwright!!! That's another one for me...
post #6 of 16
Thread Starter 
Quote:
The justification comes that maybe now the hundreds of thousands of deaths on SH hands will now be stopped by the 3500 deaths of civilians.
Heavy sigh... no sense of irony.
post #7 of 16
It's horrible. The end doesn't justify the means. I wonder if all these dead people and their family and friends feel 'liberated'?
post #8 of 16
Liberated or not, this war was still wrong. Those cartoons are just awful btw. I would love to see one depicting the as of yet undecomposed bodies of all the people who died under the U.S. See how funny and righteous it is then.

Look at it this way:

If the U.S. military rolled into Iraq, took 3500 people (and more but we don't know how many), lined them up (women, children, babies, eldery, men... anyone) and then systematically shot them in the heads, how would you feel? Would you still feel happy for the people of Iraq and feel like the U.S. was right? That they were saviours?

But when they are "accidental" deaths they are ok? A bomb goes astray, it was a mistake and therefore the deaths of these people don't really matter. Afterall, no one had to look them in the face and kill them. The U.S. government has spent the whole war saying Saddam fought a dirty war. That he hid his people among civilians and that HE is the reason why so many civilians died. Well we all know war isn't pretty. We all know people die in wars. But shouldn't you be blaming the invader? After all they are the ones pulling the trigger and killing that two-year-old girl, that pregnant woman, that elderly man buying bread at the market. Just because it was done "accidentally" doesn't make it any difference from what Saddam did. Killing is killing.

Am I happy Saddam is out of power. Heck yes! Am I happy with the way it was done? Heck no! I personally feel that the U.S. government is no better than Saddam's. They are very careful to make sure everyone knows that it was Saddam's fault all these civilians died but they were the ones who chose to invade.

If those people were still alive and you asked them if they would be willing to die in order for Saddam to be overthrown, what do you think they would say? Would they willingly line up and let the U.S. and British forces kill them? I guess we will never know. Just as Saddam didn't give them a choice, the invaders also gave the people of Iraq NO CHOICE. Which puts them all on the same level, in my point of view.
post #9 of 16
Yeah it is predictable that many of us don't think that pre-emptive slaughter of thousands is a valid energy or foreign policy. It's called having a conscience, relentless in the feeling that we can't get around the fact that killing in order to bury the fact of our own government's part in arming tyrannical despots around the world to control them will always backfire and, is wrong; that killing for A LIE is wrong; and that war profiteering is not only wrong but illegal.

I personally don't have the luxury of falling back on some party line dwelling and harping on Clinton's sex scandal, his policies, etc, when THOUSANDS are currently suffering not by Saddam's hand but our own hands...INCLUDING our own soldiers whose skills and loyalty were betrayed by being falsely led to war. And I feel I must do all I can to prevent it from happening again...as I think an awful lot of folks who post here may feel also.

We have to be able to talk about it, to mourn what were once decent vital, ever-evolving and growing values strongly supporting our diverse and creative culture, that are now being perverted into some kind of rigid quasi-puritan morality, false and tainted by greed and the need to feel righteous and superior over others who then by definition must be inferior, so what does it matter about their quality of life? Call many of us crazy, permissive and amoral...we don't equate lies relating to sex with premeditated murder of innocent people for profit and world dominance.

Yes, being human, being compassionate, trying to keep our sanity in times of danger, when our very thoughts threaten the goals of dominance and control, and we have been called traitors; having individual mind rather than hive mind, it IS predictable. Yes it is human nature in fact, that we desperately connect and share information, prove it true or false, research it well, to educate ourselves, one another and open our minds to the truth, even when it is hurtful and painful to our hearts and minds.

Why do we bother?...History will judge us all....and not least of all, our children will have to deal with those orphaned, maimed and whose mental innocence was permanently violated by US atrocities commited in our time. If we don't try now to address this dis-ease in our government (which may well reflect the dis-ease in ourselves and our culture that needs attention), well, our kids may never know again, the relative difference in how it was pre-2000, and how it is now. Or would those who want this administration to succeed in dismantling the Constitution, prefer a revolt by the poor, by those who are trodden by the results of bad policies, by those who are angry and will, perhaps if forced by desperation, fight back? It has happened before, it happens in the third world all the time. And it is much worse in its horror...because it is us choosing sides. I am not advocating it at all. I am not drooling in anticipation. But I tell you now...that it could happen and is so much more dangerous.

And if it happens...will that be because of the Clintons? or is the fault of Dems, Greens, Republicans, Christians, Muslims, Pagans, Jews?...or will we see it as all our HUMAN responsibility to one another: our duty and opportunity to make sure that everyone's basic access to needs met, is open and reachable, even if assistance is needed for some to access resources... everywhere on Earth so that we can avoid more violence? Or is that someone else's responsiblity?

I can only hope that those who feel compelled to join a flock tended and cultivated by the wolf in gentle shepherd's clothing at the helm of our ship of state, will come gently in the end, to the understanding that we, who had courage from the beginning, opened our minds to the truth not to be right but to address that truth that change always exposes, even though that truth caused so much pain to us. I have that much faith and trust and compassion, and wish others ease of awakening rather than the jolt and pain that I and probably many experienced in awakening to the truth of what is going on in America and therefore the world. I can only hope that when that time comes, that we can embrace one another without recrimination for insult/injury done, and with deeply sincere balm to soothe any pain caused, and welcome with love.

I KNOW how much the truth hurt me, but I was willing and trusted that it would be better in the long run to know sooner than later...and I suspect that it has hurt many others too, to choose to know now, hopefully before it is too late.

Yes, it may be predictable that this forum is full of thinking humans who find fellowship and shelter in one another's thoughts and sharing, in this horrible and dangerous storm attacking our way of life. It is predictable that we find comfort, and are encouraged and spurred forward to right action; that we express frustration and anger and don't receive certain types of information graciously and reject what feels untrustworthy. We have seen too much and CAN'T go back and be good, docile sheep because we have seen the wolf exposed through some tears that are beginning to unravel the gentle shepherd's clothing. He is leading the flock to the brink of oblivion. We will not follow the flock over the edge. It is a free will choice.

We don't all believe that obliteration of all life on this planet, is just okay because it is God's will or because we "read the end of the book". I personally have taken a religious vow to use my gifts and talents to prevent, from within my power, any further harm to Earth and all her life. I didn't want this war for that reason alone at the base of any other reasoning. I don't want any further attack on innocent people to be an acceptable way to send a message to another government...because what goes around, comes around and therefore, it can happen here too (and has) and I believe we have worshipped the death god here enough of late. -And also because the only message that comes through to the people attacked is that their attackers don't care at all about their suffering; just that the message of might making right gets through. That is the message. Not that democracy is good; not that Jesus loves them; not that they are liberated.

I imagine that I have spoiled yet another thread here. So I guess that before this one gets pulled pending review, because of any further discomfort I will conclude that this post will be removed if necessary. See I CANNOT and will not, as a human, as a woman, as a mother...stand by like a good sheep, while the body count for both Americans and Iraqis rises, without a care from our government, who LIED to go to war....and say NOTHING carefully so as to not offend...it's impossible for me. I refuse to say that everyone is right...because we SEE they are not. I cannot respect what has brought us to, and is attempting to keep us in this place. I am working and will work everywhere to remove the dis-ease brought on us; to remove the scales from the eyes of those who will not see, because the price of my silence; the price of delusional thinking is too high. None of our children or Iraqi children...or any children should pay. And if we keep on this tragic path, they will.

NO wrongs can EVER make a right and human might cannot make anything truly right...only right humane thought leading to right humane action makes right...from this point on, from you and me.

If the people lead, the government MUST follow...Joyce in the mts.
post #10 of 16
Both Hilarys have valid issues.

Or look at all the unexploded cluster bombs still in Iraq, Afghanistan and for that matter Vietnam. Eventually it will all balance out I'm sure.

I think the potential for post- SH pro-Islamicist govt. is very high.
post #11 of 16

One very simple point...

Snip of a letter I sent to 'everybody'....


Quote:
Today, the Bush administration is shifting the emphasis it placed on the reasons leading to the war. While playing down the weapons of mass destruction claim, they now stress the goal was to free the Iraqi people from the “clutches of Saddam”. I ask then, why was this the ultimatum given to Saddam Hussein by George Bush: "The time for denying, deceiving, and delaying has come to an end," he said. "Saddam Hussein must ‘disarm’ himself. Or, for the sake of peace, we will lead a coalition to ‘disarm’ him."

George Bush did not submit a resolution to the UN demanding basic “freedoms” for the people of Iraq. If this war was about freeing people from the “Clutches of Saddam” should not our ultimatum have been: The time for violating human rights has come to an end. Saddam Hussein must begin to follow the standards of the “Universal Declaration of Human Rights” or we will lead a coalition to free the people of Iraq…?
Does that make sense folks?

We were duped, and the right is 'spinning' now. It's pathetic really. All those who said 'trust your government' 'have a little faith in your govrenment,' 'the government knows things we don't,' are now saying well they lied but it's ok because....?!

War's have legalities, we had no 'legal' grounds (what so ever) for invasion based on human rights violations alone. This nation was told Saddam Hussein posed a 'clear and present' danger to the citizens of the United States. It is becoming 'clear' that was not the case.

*Id be the first to endorse UN resolutions granting "everybody in the world" basic human rights, but we are not there yet as a nation*
post #12 of 16
Thread Starter 
Special thanks to Joyce for that very thoughtful and thought provoking post.
post #13 of 16

interesting website related to this post

http://www.iraqbodycount.net/bodycount.htm

Puts the numbers higher than those reported by the AP.
post #14 of 16
Joyce may I send a few close friends your words? I was moved to tears reading your post. I pulled so many quotes to comment on in this post that I was practically quoting everything.

Unbelieveably resoundingly true for me too Joyce. Are you considering a run for political office because I'll come work for you.

Quote:
We have to be able to talk about it, to mourn what were once decent vital, ever-evolving and growing values strongly supporting our diverse and creative culture, that are now being perverted into some kind of rigid quasi-puritan morality, false and tainted by greed and the need to feel righteous and superior over others who then by definition must be inferior, so what does it matter about their quality of life?
YES!!! The loss of America as furthering some ideal is palpable...it is extinct like so much other life under the current regime in the US and many many others in American history...and YES NM around the world too there are evildoers, both individuals AND governments.

The reason I can't equate death with death is that as a SUPERPOWER we MUST assume a greater share of moral responsibility toward others less empowered (be it by the grace of God or the devil or our own machinations) than we are.

The world watches us and those inclined toward greed and love of power cannot help but be learning from our current actions in the world...while mothers (and fathers) weep and speak up and act in opposition to these loveless and self-serving acts by all those in positions of power who seek to RULE above all else.

When will our government work for peace? When there is no profit to war, to individuals and to corporations.
post #15 of 16
If anything that I say, feels good to you...share it.

I am too chicken to ever run for office.

Sometimes I just feel as if I am going to burst open if I don't say what is in my heart and mind.

If what comes out helps others to frame their ideas, then it's worth making myself vulnerable to ridicule or criticism.

Thanks for all the kind words and know that I feel that as more of us really reach down and say what needs saying, ask the hard questions and speak out fearlessly, that we SHALL overcome....

...sooner than later...Joyce in the mts.
post #16 of 16
War may have killed 10,000 civilians

On a more somber note...

T
Joyce, if you ever do run for prez, you've got my vote...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Activism Archives
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Activism › Activism Archives › 3,240 civilian deaths and counting...