Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › How would you respond??
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How would you respond??  

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 
I'm not sure where to put this exactly but wanted some objective opinions to see if I am overreacting.

Over a month ago my daughter was diagnosed with MRSA. It was innocent enough...it had looked like a zit for a few days and then one day it was all swollen and infected looking. I brought her in and they made the diagnosis. This isn't a post regarding that per se.

I immediately informed her brownie troop...that she had been with the day before...so that they would be aware just in case another girl happened to show such a benign symptom since it has the potential to become serious.

My daughter was treated for it and it appears to be gone. Once the diagnosis was made we took extra precautions in keeping the sore covered and washing hands etc...

She went to a brownie meeting two weeks later without incident. Then today I got an email...almost a month after the fact...stating my daughter could not return without a doctor's note. Needless to say I was taken aback because no one has even talked to me for two weeks to inquire on her condition. If they had they would have been informed that the doctor considered it cleared up. Second this is not something that is passed in the air unlike many other things. I might have seen the concern while it was open and draining but that hasn't been the case for about a month because it healed a few days after treatment started. In my daughter's case the affected area was on her bottom so no one could have had any contact with the sore itself and I had it thoroughly bandaged and sealed so she couldn't even get to it lol. Add that to panties and clothing.

What made me so irate was the fact that I had spoken with the doctor about transmission. He saw no reason to keep her away from people. He, of course, stated in our home we should be careful and take extra precaution with washing of hands etc...FTR my dp, myself and my young son show no evidence of catching it from her. I had researched the disease and asked tons of questions so she wouldn't give it to someone else. I mentioned it to the troop out of concern for their kids. Why in the @*!! would they feel they needed to go to the council office and take such drastic measures and worse yet on an old problem. One that isn't even an issue anymore. Am I overreacting? Would it have killed her to call me last week and ask if it was gone? Would it have killed her to do the research about the disease to learn how it is transmitted? The only thing we can figure is that perhaps my daughter touched something that an infected person touched right after they had touched an open sore and that it got in through my daughter's nose. She had no cuts or wounds, much less in that area, for the infection to start.

I will get a doctor's note because I already talked to the office and they think it's ridiculous but will type me up one but I am just so angry. It makes me want to say next time we have something that could be contagious I won't let you know. Bear in mind I was not aware at the time they were exposed and it took a week for the culture to come back positive. I had never even heard of MRSA. Should I have let some other poor mother not get their child treatment because they thought it was nothing? I thought I was doing people a favor but I guess I've learned I shouldn't. I just really think they should inform themselves about something before getting all paranoid because clearly if they knew anything about this they would have had nothing to fear.

So how would you respond? Throw the doctor's note in their face??
post #2 of 14
kinda just sounds like they are covering themselves. i would just provide the note and not think another thing about it. it doesn't sound to me like they are judging you or your daughter in any way.
post #3 of 14
Thread Starter 
I guess that's what I feel like they are doing. Judging me. Like I have to prove what the doctor already told me with a note...as if my telling them that wasn't enough. Then further to think that I would knowingly put their children at risk. It's like they don't believe me and need the doctor's note to prove I am not lying. Strep is contagious as well as is chicken pox. Do people have to bring in notes from their doctors stating their children are no longer contagious??
post #4 of 14
Unless it was legally required, in the future, I would not give any advisories. I'd probably look around for a new group too, did they send a get well card?
post #5 of 14
I used to work in a doctor's office.

I would have been happy to write a note that not only cleared your daughter to participate, but that also provided a little information and education to the people requiring the note. I did so a couple of times in the past on a variety of issues.

It's a means of educating people, and also helping the patient.

I think you did the right thing, informing them even if you didn't *need* to necessarily. I think there has been a lot of hype and hysteria regarding MRSA in the media lately (and also some well deserved attention); probably they are just concerned for their safety, as well as the general safety of the children. I doubt it is malicious; more than anything they are just probably not well informed and need some info and guidance on MRSA infections and how to deal with them in the future.
post #6 of 14
If you had asked me before I read this thread, I would not have known what MRSA was. If you Google MRSA, some of the hits that pop up right away make it sound scary -- it is potentially life-threatening and it seems like it could spread from person to person. Probably the Brownie leader just doesn't understand everything there is to know about MRSA, and her actions were not meant as anything personal against you or your daughter.

I know that in my kids school if a child is diagnosed with strep throat, for example, they need a doctor's note before coming back to school. It's standard procedure -- it isn't meant to say that a parent would purposely endanger other people's children.

The response of the doctor's office seems a little weirder to me. Why would they balk about writing the note?

I think the problem is there are people (like me) who don't know about certain illnesses, then they google it online and think, "OH, no!" without having a full understanding.
post #7 of 14
GSs are pretty strict when it comes to liability issues, and this likely was one. Yeah, it took a little while. But it likely took the leader some time to figure out what she was required to do. Especially if she has a life outside of "Brownie Leader."
post #8 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by em&namama View Post
I guess that's what I feel like they are doing. Judging me. Like I have to prove what the doctor already told me with a note...as if my telling them that wasn't enough. Then further to think that I would knowingly put their children at risk. It's like they don't believe me and need the doctor's note to prove I am not lying. Strep is contagious as well as is chicken pox. Do people have to bring in notes from their doctors stating their children are no longer contagious??
to answer your last question, yes. i recall having to do that many a time (bring a note to the school nurse to be put in my health file - like after having strep throat, etc - and also after being cleared for an injury and could resume participation in sports, etc...) when i was a kid/teen.

it really isn't a judgement thing - it's just a cya/liability thing on their part. it seems stupid b/c it is after the fact, but they evidently just need "doctor's word" on file.
post #9 of 14
I haven't ever had to bring a note or known anyone who had to bring a note.
post #10 of 14
I think it rather unsupportive and unkind of the troop leader to not call and inquire about your daughter's well-being. That would have been the kind way to go forward.

That being said I don't think it at all uncalled-for for them to want a doctor's note clearing your daughter for a return to functions. Most people are not aware of MRSA and if they are it can strike immediate fear in people. You had spoken to your doctor about transmission precautions, but all of these other parents didn't have a chance to do that. They have had no real way to allay their fears about this and since you did tell them about it they deserve the chance to have those fears allayed.

Just take it as an opportunity to educate them. Make copies of the note from the doctor for all of the parents (or don't and just do the second part). Second, print out some info from the web about MRSA so that the parents can learn from the situation and hopefully next time not have to worry so much about it.
post #11 of 14
I am curious, has anyone here ever had to bring in a doctor's note saying their child was recovered from illness.
post #12 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by SusannaG View Post
If you had asked me before I read this thread, I would not have known what MRSA was. If you Google MRSA, some of the hits that pop up right away make it sound scary -- it is potentially life-threatening and it seems like it could spread from person to person. Probably the Brownie leader just doesn't understand everything there is to know about MRSA, and her actions were not meant as anything personal against you or your daughter.
2nd. Probably the Brownie leader did not know either until another parent informed her which is why there was a delay. And to answer another poster's question - I have never had to bring in a doctors note for myself as a child or one of my children saying the illness was over. But I guess I am not surprised that is a requirement in some places.
post #13 of 14
thanks for answering the question. I am wondering if it is a girl scout official position.
post #14 of 14
Thread Starter 
no I don't think it's an official position

I called the council today and the leader did not give all the information to the council such as how long ago this came up etc...

The woman at the council admitted she didn't know about MRSA and had tried pulling up info via the internet and it was varied...which doesn't surprise me. The point is that the leader didn't have much info and caused a panic due to ignorance. Once the council knew more they were fine. She even commended me for bringing it up since most parents wouldn't have and by making parents aware I could have prevented another child from getting serious even though it never came to that anyway. She called the leader and told her my daughter was fine.

The leader did call me and I told her what upset me was the simple fact that she hadn't called for an update and that she left out vital info when addressing the council. Decisions shouldn't be made out of ignorance. I did forward her a link to the CDC about the condition so hopefully she is more knowledgeable now. What's weird is that so many people hadn't heard of it. I homeschool and my kids are young and the other moms in the troop fall into the same category but you would think the council would have been aware especially since there have been outbreaks in this area. My kids go to the public school for speech and they were fully aware of it and knowledgeable about the infection but it wasn't an issue with them because she was being treated and it was on her bum and covered.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › How would you respond??