Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › *Sigh* She circ'd
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

*Sigh* She circ'd  

post #1 of 13
Thread Starter 
A few weeks ago I asked for some info from all of you to persuade my friend not to circ the little boy she was due with on July 10th. We visited for a while shortly after that and got to talking. I gave her the information and told her everything I knew. We are both huge animal lovers and used to work together in a shelter. We're very against declawing cats. So, I told her that circumcising is akin to declawing. It is permanent damage and it is painful. Neither a baby nor a cat can defend itself. I thought this helped open her eyes. It seemed to anyway. Well, her baby was born yesterday and was circumcised today. I heard this from a friend as I haven't been able to make it to the hospital yet to say hi, and I don't think I can bring myself to do so now. I think I would break down and cry as soon as I saw that sweet little boy. I think a lot of why she decided to circ is her bf. He's not even the father ad shouldn't get to choose something as important as this!

In any case, thank you everyone for the information. Luckily everyone else I know is pregnant with girls at the moment. I feel too defeated to try to persuade someone else just yet. And I thought I had it in the bag with the whole declawing analogy. How can she think it's wrong to declaw a cat but not wrong to remove part of her son's penis? Ugh.
post #2 of 13
:

Every time I know someone who is pregnant and I am unclear as to how they feel about circ, I pray they have a girl....
post #3 of 13
I'm sorry.
post #4 of 13
I'm so sorry this happened. I have been there and know what this is like. Its heart wrenching. Hang in there.
post #5 of 13
: I'm sorry.
post #6 of 13
Thread Starter 
Thanks everyone...it is definitely easier when friends have girls
post #7 of 13
Sorry

post #8 of 13


I'm so sorry for that little boy.
post #9 of 13


Keep on intactivating though. You never know how many people you will reach.
post #10 of 13
I don't know how someone can see the logic of one but not the other. Cat's toes have distinct functions and cause dreadful pain when removed. Prepuces have distinct functions & cause dreadful pain when removed. Cognitive dissonance indeed.
post #11 of 13
I wouldn't go, send her a polite card and wish her well. The distance sends a message. I think it's coddling them, essentially saying "there, there... it's okay" is what sends the message that while you're extremely against it, you're condoning it if she has another. I'm sorry, but this just makes my blood boil! All this information and they do this to conform to society or appease a gutless male (dh/dp)!

I'm soooo glad you're against circ and declawing!!! We took in a stray cat half a year ago or more and he's declawed at the front. I tend to pity him in that sense like I would seeing a circ'd baby/child.
post #12 of 13
Thread Starter 
It's so great to get all the encouragement. I haven't called her yet to congratulate her on her new son. I just can't understand why someone would want to take a perfect little baby and mutilate him. He is no longer whole and that is so distressing. She hasn't called me yet and only sent me an email with pictures of Baby Anthony, so I think I'll keep holding out. I am leaving the country on Thursday anyway, so I'll have a couple weeks to reflect without feeling like I have to speak with her just yet.

I do have some good news, though. My mother raised my brother and I very mainstream, yet she has been so receptive to everything in how I have been raising DD. She is slowly but surely becoming an attachment grandma. This weekend I mentioned how sad I was for little Anthony and explained why. She agrees with me 100% even though my brother was circ'd! How amazing is that? I guess it just makes me hopeful.
post #13 of 13
I am sorry your friend didn't listen. I really hate that women are supposed to have independence and be equal to men but still bow to their men over this. I really think I would have NEVER NEVER NEVER allowed my child to be hurt like that, ever if my DP wasn't intact.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TirzhaZ View Post
I This weekend I mentioned how sad I was for little Anthony and explained why. She (mother) agrees with me 100% even though my brother was circ'd! How amazing is that? I guess it just makes me hopeful.
My mom is exactly the same way. She said they were told it had to be done when my brother way born. She is completely supportive about this and a lot of other issues and I am happy to have such an open minded person for my mom!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › *Sigh* She circ'd