Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › a pincher's remorse
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

a pincher's remorse  

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
Hi there wise mamas,

My dd, age two, has a tendency to pinch other toddlers on occasion, or to pull hair. It's gotten lots and lots better; I realize that this is age-appropriate; I am not worried. I try to prevent this kind of behavior by helping her to be well-fed, well-rested, recently pottied, etc., and if I sense that she is likely to act aggressively, I try to stay one step ahead of her and calmly physically intervene, saying "I'm not going to let you hurt Mary." Etc.

For the last month or so, she has been actively trying to process these episodes afterwards. Often, the first thing out of her mouth upon waking is, "No pull hair! Open hand! Ow! Hurts! No! Not do it!" She'll run through the whole script 2-3 times, with lots of dramatic emphasis, gesturing, and animation. She has this intense need to talk about it, when it has happened, but also just in general (when there is no specific incident she's referring to). I am certainly not intending to guilt-trip her, and I leave the hair-pulling etc. behind, just as soon as it is over. I would never bring it up later that day, or the next day -- but she almost always does.

I guess I am wondering mostly how to respond when she brings this up. I've tried just affirming what she is saying (it is, after all, an almost perfect imitation of what her papa and I say! ), but she looks at me sort of searchingly, like there is something else I ought to be saying. I'm just not sure what she's going through, exactly, or how to guide her.

Any thoughts?
post #2 of 7
I think it's great that she's so actively processing this and discussing it with you! Just keep smiling encouragingly and continue giving her the affirmation. Maybe the searching look has to do with an expectation of more rules? Maybe she's aware that there are more but she can't remember and is looking to you to supply them? You might ask 'cause you never know!
post #3 of 7
OK, she knows what not to do...

...Have you tried telling her what to do instead? It could be that's what she's looking for.
post #4 of 7
Sounds like she's communicating that she's getting it! That's awesome! I'd respond by agreeing with her, "You are so right, baby."
post #5 of 7
My "nosy" mother (gotta love her) was reading this post over my shoulder and burst out laughing, saying "you used to do that!".

She says that I've been a perfectionist and very hard on myself since day one, and did things like reherse the day (or reherse things I knew were "wrong") as well as practice walking, jumping, talking etc. over and over before I put them into practise.

I agree with the pp about maybe needing to know what to do. She is rehersing what not to do and obviously trying to get the day off on the right foot so to speak, but perhaps she needs something positive to put in it's place? Like, "No pinch... hugs for everyone!" And give big hugs and laugh. Just an idea, good luck mama!
post #6 of 7
Thread Starter 
Thanks, everyone, for your thoughts. I think it's a great idea to give her something *to* do instead. I should have thought of this... but the pinching, hair-pulling, etc., often seems so random, that I've had a hard time suggesting alternatives that will "honor the impulse." (What IS the impulse?! kwim?) But it *does* seem like she might be asking for an alternative, and I should give her one, even if it's general, like the pp suggested: Hugs for everyone!

Thanks also for setting my mind at ease a little.... I'm pretty sure I do have a mini-perfectionist on my hands, but that certainly comes naturally.
post #7 of 7
My dd1 is a verbal child, that's how she processes things, out loud (and sometimes VERY loudly!!) Could this be your dd too?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › a pincher's remorse