Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › Why not a student advocate?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Why not a student advocate?  

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 
In jails and mental hospitals, the inmates are given a packet which describes their constitutional, civil, legal and other types of rights. Why not in our public schools? (Student handbooks of rules and responsibilities are not the same.) Also, jails and hospitals employ impartial advocates for the inmates. (I don't know how impartial they really are, but they are not paid by the jail/hospital. They are paid by the state.) Inmates can direct all concerns, questions and grievances to these people. Again, why not in our schools? In school, a student can only complain to the teachers, principals, or counselors - all employees of the school.

When I was in school I was told things like "The constitution is only for those over 21" and "We don't listen to complaints about the school." This information is, of course, wrong and I think it's sad that people don't stand up for the rights of students the way they do for other involuntary consumers.

What do you all think? Do any of your schools employ an impartial advocate/ombudsperson?
post #2 of 3
Just looking through this forum and saw this post. Just what I've been thinking about. I just was complaining about my new teaching job and how unfair some of the teaching practices are and no one seems to care. Even the students don't really care if it's fair or not. I'm trying to figure out why I'm the only one it seems to bother, I was also wondering why we don't have a student advocate/ombudsman... There is one for undergrads in college, but then they're 18 and up. It seems like the k-12 students are so convinced that they have no rights that they wouldn't even use an advocate if they had one.

I think it's all just indicative of how our culture treats children. They have fewer rights than prisoners. (not that I want to open that can of worms either.)

I thought that maybe I could act as a volunteer ombudsman at my school, but the administration won't listen to me either! Now I'm back with my head in the sand just trying to encourage those in my classes to think for themselves... and if there's time I'll show them how to do some math too. Some days I spend every spare minute trying to talk to the principal and it's like talking to the wall. Every time I mention that a student says or feels a certain way he just says not to believe anything they say!!!! And this is not a regular public school. It's a state run free tuition boarding school for very bright juniors and seniors. You'd at least think they would be given some credit for being able to think! I'm appalled by the adults at the place. I'd quit in a second if I didn't already adore my students and want to help them so much.

okay, there's one more rant of my chest today.
post #3 of 3
Well, one person who can fulfill that role is the parent or guardian of the child.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at School
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › Why not a student advocate?