Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › NYT Sunday Magazine article -- formula to fight obesity
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

NYT Sunday Magazine article -- formula to fight obesity  

post #1 of 11
Thread Starter 
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/05/ma...tml?ref=health

Quote:
Michael Cawthorne, director of metabolic research at the Clore Laboratory at Britain’s University of Buckingham, argues that if we act early enough, we may be able to program babies’ metabolisms to provide permanent resistance to excess pounds. He and his colleagues are trying to develop a baby formula with an astonishing property: to turn newborns into those enviable people who can eat what they want without getting fat.

As far-fetched as this sounds — another British biochemist has called it “science fiction” — it is based on emerging knowledge about how appetite and metabolism are regulated. The hormone leptin appears to act very early in life to program the hypothalamus, a gland in the brain that helps keep food intake and energy expenditure in balance. By influencing the set points at which the hypothalamus suppresses hunger and stimulates calorie-burning activity, leptin may increase the body’s long-term tendency to use up calories rather than conserve them as fat.

Cawthorne would supplement infants’ formula with leptin during the period in which their metabolisms are being calibrated. He speculates that this kind of treatment “will help people cope better with an abundant food environment.” Experiments with animals provide support. A study led by Cawthorne’s associate Claire Stocker found that rat mothers given leptin during pregnancy and lactation produced offspring that were resistant to obesity. “The science is too immature to apply to humans yet,” says Sebastien Bouret, a developmental-programming expert at the Saban Research Institute of Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, “but it’s a very promising field of research.”
Oh, yeah, THAT'S a good idea. NOT.
post #2 of 11
TY for posting this -- I just came across the article myself and have been cogitating on how to respond.

It is truly frightening to me that someone thinks it is important to "fix" a baby's metabolism by monkeying around with its hormones. It's even more disturbing that this guy and the author are basically advocating that step as a first-line preventive measure against obesity.
post #3 of 11
Isn't leptin in breastmilk? the ingredient that is supposed to make breastfed babies less likely to be obese in later life?
post #4 of 11
That is just creepy and wrong!
post #5 of 11
:

I have no words right now...
post #6 of 11
Let's experiment on human babies without their informed consent! What a fantastic idea.

Let's forget the logical idea that cow's milk is designed to make a calf quickly bulk up to 300 pounds.

Let's ignore the fact that common sense suggests that this might have something to do with dairy-based infant formula feeding being linked to higher obesity rates than breastfeeding.

No, that's too simple, and scientific experiments are so much flashier.:
post #7 of 11
That is truly horrifying. So basically now they're trying to push miracle weight management chemicals on babies? Um, how about raising a child to have a healthy attitude toward food instead of saying (which SO many parents do) "Finish everything on your plate or no dessert." Or maybe encouraging kids to *not* sit in front of the TV all day and maybe run around outside a bit or get involved in other physical activities? I'm no skinny mama by any means, but for god's sake, it's important that I can own it and know that for me, it's because I'm pretty lazy and like cupcakes too much

We all KNOW intellectually how to maintain an "ideal" weight, whether we do so or not. So maybe we should be trying to raise children who understand and are responsible for their bodies instead of trying to find ways for them to get around eating well and exercising... So sad...

Oh, and can I also add, if they actually *do* develop this "miracle formula" to manipulate children's natural metabolism, I'm sure we all know what that will do for breastfeeding rates. If moms think X formula is her kid's ticket to the skinny life, I'd be willing to bet that most of them won't even consider breastfeeding. :Puke
post #8 of 11
Why can't they just advocate feeding babies the way nature meant? After all, it's how we've made it this far...
post #9 of 11
I wrote a letter to the editor. It's short, so maybe it won't be ignored. I think they'd be more likely to publish a letter from someone with medical/public health initials after his or her name, though.

I could see some women I know going for this formula, definitely.
post #10 of 11
Even IF it worked and kids "could eat whatever they want and not get fat" that's not healthy! I'm willing to bet heart disease and cancer and all number of "fat people" illness would increase tons in skinny people. Idiots! :
post #11 of 11
So when do we all get NYT articles. We've FOUND the perfect formula to fight obesity.....and cancer, and diabetes, and a whole host of other health problems. It's called human milk. Sheesh.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › NYT Sunday Magazine article -- formula to fight obesity