Mothering › Forums › Archives › Dads › Papas where are you?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Papas where are you? - Page 3  

post #41 of 46
Hi guys.

The forum has stayed under moderation and will continue to stay under moderation for the time being until we can resolve the moderation concerns. For now (and yes, it has been a long "temporarily" situation, I know ) it seems to serve the forum for the better. Why? Because Papabliss is our single moderating papa and his time available to contribute here is precious and limited. We cannot ask for more that daily moderation would require. That said, we are open to volunteer papa moderators but we will only consider someone with a presence as a sincere member and who has demonstrated diplomacy and exemplary membership in posting.

Why are we moderating the posts? Is it because "The guys are not trusted to moderate themselves"? No. The initial moderation was placed due to posts being off topic for the forum. We wanted our father members to step further into the community and post to other forums for topics that have a specific forum for their subject. The Rules and Guidelines I posted at the top of the forum seemed to help that and you guys post pretty topic specific here.

But the continued moderation is because of women posting here more than men. We agree with you. This is intended to be a forum for fathers to discuss their fathering. It is not a forum for women to come here to post things like "What sort of razor do you guys recommend I buy my dh for Xmas?" and "My partner is a lazy @#^*&! and I'm fed up. What do you think I should do?" Such posts, and the mass amount of them that were getting posted, are the amin reason for the moderation. And it continues to be an issue, despite the Rules and Guidelines clearly stating what it does. Many of the posts made to the forum by females are from new members so it's not really a matter of contacting posters one by one to let them know their posts should go elsewhere. It's an ongoing issue, hence the ongoing moderation.

Who is moderating the threads? I and other MDC administrators. Perhaps we are not staying on top of the moderation and your posts are being delayed. I can understand why this would hinder participation. I am going to discuss the issue with the administrators and see if we can place another moderator just to watch for off topic posting. If we can do that then perhaps we can remove the moderation.
post #42 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cynthia Mosher View Post
Hi guys.

The forum has stayed under moderation and will continue to stay under moderation for the time being until we can resolve the moderation concerns. For now (and yes, it has been a long "temporarily" situation, I know ) it seems to serve the forum for the better. Why? Because Papabliss is our single moderating papa and his time available to contribute here is precious and limited. We cannot ask for more that daily moderation would require. That said, we are open to volunteer papa moderators but we will only consider someone with a presence as a sincere member and who has demonstrated diplomacy and exemplary membership in posting.

Why are we moderating the posts? Is it because "The guys are not trusted to moderate themselves"? No. The initial moderation was placed due to posts being off topic for the forum. We wanted our father members to step further into the community and post to other forums for topics that have a specific forum for their subject. The Rules and Guidelines I posted at the top of the forum seemed to help that and you guys post pretty topic specific here.

But the continued moderation is because of women posting here more than men. We agree with you. This is intended to be a forum for fathers to discuss their fathering. It is not a forum for women to come here to post things like "What sort of razor do you guys recommend I buy my dh for Xmas?" and "My partner is a lazy @#^*&! and I'm fed up. What do you think I should do?" Such posts, and the mass amount of them that were getting posted, are the amin reason for the moderation. And it continues to be an issue, despite the Rules and Guidelines clearly stating what it does. Many of the posts made to the forum by females are from new members so it's not really a matter of contacting posters one by one to let them know their posts should go elsewhere. It's an ongoing issue, hence the ongoing moderation.

Who is moderating the threads? I and other MDC administrators. Perhaps we are not staying on top of the moderation and your posts are being delayed. I can understand why this would hinder participation. I am going to discuss the issue with the administrators and see if we can place another moderator just to watch for off topic posting. If we can do that then perhaps we can remove the moderation.
Thanks Cynthia

There are a few different forums that are on Moderation, Activism, Q&S among others...
post #43 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by miamidad View Post
Papai, I'm with you on this , lets make it happen, enough of this crazy search of a million posts all over the internet , lets have all the dads stop by here.
I have this thread in my sub list. Nice to see the activity here!

On moderation: Why not a tribe for papa's? There are regional tribes that seem to develop their own culture and new threads on specific issues arrise... like what razor should I get for DH?

A papa's tribe could allow a matrix of conversations to occur, over time, with out heavy moderation. I think we could self-police by positively reminding others what material is/is not suitable for a Natural Family Community.

Hey... that is a strong concept point, too... community. Editing and restricting posts from women directed toward men even prevent a conversation from occuring. If a tribal area was the location... a new thread could be used and then this conversation might occur. Heavy moderation may, perhaps, restrict community growth.

OK... Thanks for reading (and hopefully posting) my 2 cents!
post #44 of 46
Hi guys,

I've had to do some cleanup on this thread as I have let it go too far with regard to the rules an regs of MDC. It put me in a diffucult place having to edit/delete posts about what's moderated and who is making decisions. I've removed a dozen of the posts that directly questioned the moderation, moderator, point of MDC, men here, women here, and even my own replies.

I'll leave Shadow Papa's post up for a bit, but then it will have to go as well in order to bring this thread back into its original spirit, and all the posts within MDC rules.

Thanks for your understanding.

pb.
post #45 of 46
we will only consider someone with a presence as a sincere member and who has demonstrated diplomacy and exemplary membership in posting.

Oh crap, so much for that idea. lol

Just kidding. I didn't think other guys posted here. hehehe...

I'm a dad to an almost 4 year old boy and 1 year old girl.

I'm seperated from my wife for almost a year now.
post #46 of 46

Here's hoping......

"Views of women, on one side, as inwardly directed toward home and family. Notions of men, on the other, as outwardly striving toward fame and fortune have resounded throughout literature and in the texts of history, biology, and psychology until they seem uncontestable. Such dichotomous views defy the complexities of individuals and stifle the potential for people to reveal different dimensions of themselves in various settings." - Sara Lawrence Lightfoot


I am going to discuss the issue with the administrators and see if we can place another moderator just to watch for off topic posting. If we can do that then perhaps we can remove the moderation.

That would rock. Thank you.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Dads
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Archives › Dads › Papas where are you?