Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Harry Potter for a kindergartener???
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Harry Potter for a kindergartener???  

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
At what age did you read the Harry Potter books to your dc? Ds will be 6 in November and is an avid reader. He really wants me to read the first Harry Potter to him. I am not sure if it age appropriate for him or not. I also have to admit that I really hae no interest in reading it. I am sure they are wonderful books, but it just isn't a genre I have eer been interested in. But I am willing to read it to him anyway. Maybe I will end up liking it.
Any thoughts?
post #2 of 8
The first Harry Potter is really mild (except the very last chapter.)

My daughter just started grade 1, and she L.O.V.E.S. Harry Potter. (The books, not the merchandise.)

If you don't think you actually want to read it aloud, maybe you can check it out in audiobook format from the library. (We have almost all of the books on tape; my daughter gets a bedtime story read by me and then we pop in a Harry Potter tape.)
post #3 of 8
both my 2 yr old and my 5 yr old love harry potter. just yesterday at a clothing swap, my 2 yr old recognized the cover of a HP book that we didn't have in the midst of a pile of toys. both love listening to the books at bed time.
post #4 of 8
My DH started reading the series to my DS when he was 2. DS is 4 now and loves listening to dad read to him. They are on book 3 or 4 now.
post #5 of 8
Thread Starter 
Thanks! I am going to go ahead and order a copy of the first one. Ds doesn't like to listen to books on tape even if I am sitting with him holding the book. I tried that a a few times when I've had sore throats and in the car, but ds says "it just isn't right." So I will be the one doing the reading. Maybe I'll turn into a Harry Potter fan.
post #6 of 8
I didin't think it was my genre, either, but my ds really wanted to read it, wasn't reading at that level, so I read it to him. I was hooked. I think I looked forward to the seventh book even more than he did!
post #7 of 8
My daughters started reading the series after I became hooked and they watched me reading them. I think they were in 2nd and 3rd grade at the time? It was right after the 5th book came out (that's when I purchased them, prior to that I'd read them from the library.)

I recently leant my copy of the first book to a friend to read aloud to her DS, the summer before he started 2nd grade. Her 4yo DD listened as well, which surprised her, but I'm not sure how much the 4yo really absorbed from it.

So the answer really depends on your particular child and his/her interest and level of comprehension. It does have a couple of scary parts- it opens with a double murder (of Harry's parents), then Harry is neglected by his aunt and uncle who are "caring" for him. Well, they don't actually show the Potters being killed, but you hear about it- and the thought of a 1yo suddenly being orphaned could be very frightening to some children, especially when coupled with his poor treatment by his foster family.

Later in the book you meet a mountain troll and a giant 3 headed dog, and during the "final showdown", Lord Voldemort's face is sticking out of the back of somebody else's head. That's a pretty freaky image- possibly the scariest image in the entire series.

Some children are going to find this story much too frightening before age 9 or 10. Other children won't have a problem with it- in general, things won't "look" any scarier to a child than he or she can imagine it, while images in movies can be a LOT more frightening than the same thing in a book.
post #8 of 8
My dd is 5.5 and I'm almost done reading the last book to her.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Harry Potter for a kindergartener???