Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › How do your children feel about hs'ing?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How do your children feel about hs'ing?  

post #1 of 37
Thread Starter 
Not the academics so much, but being different from the other kids. I've heard of some kids being excited to have more free-time and less sitting time. I've also heard of some kiddos feeling left out of what ps kids are doing.

Dd and ds both have attended ps in the past. I was planning on hs'ing both dd ( 8 ) and ds (4.5) this year, but as the first day of ps drew closer dd was crying she would miss her friends and neighbours were starting to stare and even ask her questions which made her feel awkward. Ultimately I caved to pressure and she has started ps gr. 3. She is happy and so I am not pulling her out at this time.

One of my biggest fears as school drew closer was her feeling like the odd one out/weird/different in an unacceptable way to others. I understand that children shouldn't always feel like they have to follow the crowd, however she is only 8 and her feelings and concerns were very real. When she would go to play with friends in the neighbourhood the parents and kids would ask her about it and although they didn't mean to make her feel awkward I could tell she did. I was trying to play up the positives of hs'ing and be upbeat about it, but I could tell whenever she'd come back from a friend's house that she was embarrassed or confused about hs'ing when everybody else was planning on going to school.

So far ds has said a couple of times he wants to go to school this year but once it was because he wanted a packed lunch like dd and the other time I think it was b/c dd was telling him all the things she was doing at school and he felt left out. Overall though he's happy to be home with mom this year.

How do your children feel not going to school like their friends? Were they always hs'ed or were they in ps previously? How do you deal with them feeling awkward or like people are looking down on them? My dd is a very sensitive girl so she senses very easily not only when others are looking at her like she is odd, but also when people are criticizing me and my choice to hs, even if subtly or unintentionally done.

Dd is happy to be in school so for now I'm leaving her in ps. I am not ruling out pulling her out at a later point in the year if she and I both feel comfortable with that decision, but I'm just looking forward to later on this year or possibly next year if she comes home for school. Also I want to be prepared for next year when ds is Gr. 1 level and the pressure will be even more intense for him and I for him to be in ps.
post #2 of 37
Most of my kids' friends are homeschooled also, so we haven't had any problems with it. The friends that do go to school on our street, we see after school anyway.

Have you looked into a local homeschool playgroup or co-op so your son can make some friends who aren't in school?
post #3 of 37
my dd went through a phase for a little bit where she wanted to go to school, but now she absolutely loves being homeschooled and says she wants to do it forever. but in actuality, i suspect she may want to go to public school down the road again when she's older ......and we'll cross that bridge as we come to it i suppose. as for now, she's incredibly happy homeschooling, and it's a great fit for our family
post #4 of 37
DS has gone through many stages of wanting to go to public school. Right now he's at a good place with it. It also helps to know that by staying home he can sleep in as late as he wants (usually 9-10am vs. 6-6-:30 for public school) and doesn't have to walk halfway across town to get to school . Plus he likes being able to learn at his own pace and learn what he wants. He can do a day's worth of work in less than an hour and have tons of time to play. Also, while he's ok in a classroom setting (he has 2 hours of church classes a week), he prefers the one on one interaction, even though he has to share me with his sister . DS knows all his friends are in school but he thinks he is "lucky" for being able to stay home and I hope he continues to feel that way.
post #5 of 37
I took my son out of school in the middle of first grade, public school. We have been hs now for 1.5 years. In our case, the reason we started hs was an aggressive teacher. I do remember him being skeptical, initially, probably because we were trying to maintain our ps school placement while we sorted out what to do-- it was confusing, we had the school send home work, we showed up for reading group. So in some ways we also gradually shifted into hs as I really got to see firsthand the academics and the classroom dynamics.

But, honestly, and my ds is a very sensitive kid, he loves hs. Almost all kids have responded that he is "lucky" and I think my ds realizes this. He knows that he spends a fraction of the day doing school related work (we are very relaxed homeschooler types). He knows that he has a lot of control over his schedule and what he learns. Socially, I see very little issues btw him and his ps friends, they still have time together, and they play well. I asked him once if he missed recess, and he said "kinda, but it really wasn't that great, some of the time he and his friends would be teased for about their play, and there really wasn't that much time to play.
post #6 of 37
I've been homeschooling for 16 years now--my oldest is 20 (and a junior in college) and my youngest is 6 and just starting. I also have a 17 year old (senior in high school) and a 13 year old (8th/9th grade). None of them have ever gone to "regular" school (except for college).

They have all loved homeschooling. The three oldest have had things that they "miss"--my oldest wanted to have a locker to put her books in and the 13 year old wanted to ride the school bus (until she actually rode on one). Social issues have never come up for us. My oldest has been to homecoming dances and formals and the next oldest has been to a homecoming dance as well. They were not so impressed. They have friends who are homeschooled and friends who go to school. They would rather be at home.

That's our experience.
post #7 of 37
Quote:
Originally Posted by emmsmama View Post
Not the academics so much, but being different from the other kids.
...
How do your children feel not going to school like their friends? Were they always hs'ed or were they in ps previously? How do you deal with them feeling awkward or like people are looking down on them?
My kids don't care about being different, but we've always homeschooled. We started in a homeschooling group before my kids were school age, so they've always know kids who homeschooled. They were quite surprised when they found out that more kids attend school than homeschool, because they thought it was more like half and half. The now understand that homeschooling is a bit unusual, but for them it is *normal*.

I don't think that anyone has ever looked down on them for homeschooling. We've gotten a few odd comments over the years, but we've had more positive comments that negative ones.

Quote:
My dd is a very sensitive girl so she senses very easily not only when others are looking at her like she is odd, but also when people are criticizing me and my choice to hs, even if subtly or unintentionally done.
I think that the more comfortable we are with our choices, the less criticism we get, and the less it effects our kids. I refuse to live my life based on other people's uninformed opinions, and I'm raising my kids to make their own choices. I want my kids to follow their bliss and listen to their inner voice, how can I teach them that if I'm scared of what everyone will think of me?

I'm also pretty sure that no matter how I raise my kids, some one will think it is a bad idea. I figured that out back when I was breastfeeding. Some people think I BF too long, others too short. As the song says, "You can't please everyone, so you got to please yourself."

Quote:
Originally Posted by chaos_pie View Post
Almost all kids have responded that he is "lucky" and I think my ds realizes this. He knows that he spends a fraction of the day doing school related work (we are very relaxed homeschooler types). He knows that he has a lot of control over his schedule and what he learns.
same here.
post #8 of 37
My oldest is only 6; he has never been to school, nor will his brothers. If you ask him (or his almost 4 year old brother) about homeschooling, they will tell you they love it. My oldest loves the freedom (and the work ... he wakes up and asks if we can start hs'ing right away ... he is a sponge right now and I'm trying to take advantage of the excessive eagerness! ). Sometimes they will argue with me about going to college ... they say they are going to homeschool through college. So, I'd venture to say their attitudes towards hs'ing is very positive.
post #9 of 37
My oldest is 7.5 and would be a second-grader age-wise, if she were in school. My kids have always been homeschooled, and they love it.

As far as being different from other... Well, I'm a single mom, I'm not straight, we're not Christian, we're liberal, I drive a funky painted and bumper-stickered hippie car, and my son frequently likes to go out (and stay in) in "drag". My kids know and embrace the phrase "Celebrate diversity!" and all its levels of meaning, and they love that everyone is different, and every family is different. They know that different ways all have value, and they pity those who are too close-minded to fully understand and embrace the value of diversity. YEs, even the almost 4-year-old get it.
post #10 of 37
My kids love unschooling! They do tell me that I have ruined them for school though. We joke that my kids would be the ones in a classroom saying "Excuse me!? I will go to the bathroom...why do you think you get to tell me that I can't?" or "Why does any of this matter? We could just look this up on google..." So so true.

Occasionally, Dd has talked about what it would be like if she were in school. Her best friend just started 8th grade so she has a little peek into that world. She knows that the decision to go to school is hers, and so far that kittke peek has been enough to tell her she doesn't really want it.

Ds left school and has never ever looked back for even a second! He is looking forward to a few college classes whenever he gets to it. He's 16.
post #11 of 37
I just asked ds about this the other day. He was in public school until last year. We were walking by his old school on our way to the store. I asked him if he misses school. He said, "No." At this point he much prefers being at home and has asked if he can homeschool all the way through high school. I said we can if he wants to. Of course we'll cross that bridge when we come to it but his thoughts and needs will play the major part in the decision.

And FWIW he is a very social kid who had tons of friends. He still plays with a couple of his old school friends, he just doesn't see them everyday. And he has made several new ones through our homeschool group.

So there is the opinion of one kid who knows exactly what he's "missing".
post #12 of 37
Dominick (7): I like it.

Abigail (5): I feel good.

Angelo (2): Do turns. And draw basketballs.

They have never had an issue "not being like the other kids" Sometimes they will even say they feel sad for their friends who have to sit in school all day.
post #13 of 37
Luke is 12. He left school when he was 10 and hasn't looked back.

Most of his friends go to school and he doesn't envy them in the slightest. He gets more sleep, has more free time, learns what he wants to learn and stays in close enough contact with the "schooled" kids that he doesn't feel left out or cut off from pop culture or hanging out.
post #14 of 37
Regarding the "not like other kids" issue....

My kids are honestly pretty happy to be different than many of the teens they know. They find a lot of the attitude annoying. In many ways my kids are like an average teen: goofy, lots of joking, lots of swearing and innuendo, myspace (Dd lol), video games (Ds), and music. But in many ways they are different, and they are really happy about it.
post #15 of 37
Oh dear. Is there a possibility of changing your social circle? It sounds like it's an issue of your daughter feeling insecure about being different and having to deal with others' negative reactions to homeschooling? I really don't know what to suggest as a solution for that, other than meeting it with homeschooling-positive influences and social outlets. We are really lucky in that we have a great support group and live in a homeschooling-friendly community. I don't think it's even occurred to the kids that there are people who don't think homeschooling is a great thing. When people ask why they aren't in school they proudly pipe up that they don't go to school!
post #16 of 37
My 15 yr. old has never been to school and has never wanted to. His schooled friends are always saying they wish they could be homeschooled. I think highschool gets tougher all the time,socially and academically.
My 9 yr. old really did like public school but opted out this year. She is VERY social.
My 8 yr. old absolutely hated first grade and is glad to be home now.

I let the two youngest go to school to check it out. They just thought everything was enclosed behind those doors that they could ever want.
They quickly learned with one school year that they didn't care for the rigidity. We have such a relaxed lifestyle I think they just couldn't deal with so much structure.
I'm soo glad. I absolutely hated all the school politics and functions. Yuck.
post #17 of 37
We have gone the other way: homeschooled for 3 years and this year my 9-year old is attending school for the first time. He is by nature a very solitary child, academically at 6th - 9th grade level and hence doesn't really "fit in" with the other kids at school (doesn't watch tv, reads obsessively, does fencing and plays the violin). BUT he *loves* school, loves the social aspect of it (who would have thought???!), loves the bus rides, loves knowing all the work and loves recess.

He used to get depressed / moody every year at the end of summer when all his friends in our community would go to school. I tried to fill the gaps with field trips, fun things to study and do, but it seemed to him (as best he could verbalize) that there was an undercurrent of "something missing".

I guess for now, the school milieu is that "something" and so far so good.
post #18 of 37
DD2 (the one who's being homeschooled) is very happy to HS. She doesnt' feel like she's missing out on anything at all- we go to HS activities 1-3 times a week (depending on the week and whether or not that week's planned activities interest her) and she's got her own group of friends. It's good for me too because I'm friends with the other moms and dads, and as a whole they're a lot crunchier than most people on Long Island, so I have much more in common with them than I ever did with the other parents from the kids' schools.

DS would like to be homeschooled, and is upset when he misses certain HS activities because he's in school, but he also enjoys going to school. DD1 enjoys school and wouldn't be happy HSing- she craves much more structure and organization than I'm able to provide.
post #19 of 37
My two youngest have never been to school. All their friends are homeschooled. Although they occasionally want to go to school to eat lunch with their older sister or to ride the bus, they don't really want to go to school for any school-type reasons. They are happy with the friends they have through homeschooling and the activities that we do instead of school.

When my oldest daughter came to us 16 months ago at age 11, I homeschooled her for 9 1/2 months before putting her in school. She liked not having to go to school and she made friends in Girl Scouts, through the homeschool group, and through our Ethiopia adoption group. I put her in school because it became clear that she needs a level of structure that I could not provide at home and, although I don't think she loves being in school (grumbles about having to get up early, is always glad to miss school for doctor appointments, etc.), I think she's fine with it.

dm
post #20 of 37
My son is 5 and loves homeschooling.
I have never applied that its "different" than what others do.
He knows some people go to school, some people homeschool and some people do not do "school".
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at Home and Beyond
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › How do your children feel about hs'ing?